Abstract
A prospective evaluation comparing functional results in conventional and percutaneous femoral nailing techniques was performed.
4 patients (8 nails) were operated on with a conventional IM nailing technique (CT), and 4 (8 nails) with the percutaneous technique (PT).
Limited trochanteric approach was performed, allowing the setting up of the sighting device for the nail.
Patient was positioned on the lateral side, hip at 60° flexion. A long k-wire was passed through the skin, along the axis of the medullary canal in the anterior-lateral part of the Piriformis fossa, into the medullary canal. A small skin incision was performed, and then a cannulated drill introduced over the k wire. The reamer guide was pushed down to the distal femoral metaphysis. Percutaneous flexible reaming was then performed in a conventional manner, taking care to introduce the reamer through the gluteus medius with no torque. Section was performed through the same incision with a modified intramedullary saw. The nail was inserted, fixed on a modified sighting device. The continuous passive machine was set up in the recovery room or in the intensive care unit. Physiotherapy was directed towards maintaining knee range of motion. Patients were evaluated for scar size, muscle function, leg raise and range of motion (ROM).
Follow-up averaged 30 (CT) and 11 (PT) months. Gain averaged 61 mm (CT) and 79 mm (PT). Scar size for nail insertion ranged from 6 to 11 cm (CT) and 1.1 to 3 cm (PT). Total number of operations from nail insertion to removal, including GA for ratcheting (GAR) and GA for other complications (GAC) was: 18 (CT, all nails removed) 9 (PT, among them 3 removal operations on the waiting list). On postoperative day 1, all patients with PT returned to a subnormal ROM. At one week, Knee flexion averaged 93° (CT) and 131° (PT). For CT, it increased gradually, passing 100° at 8 weeks, and 130° at 20 weeks. In PT, the minimum obtained was 126° at 10 weeks, passing 130° at 13 weeks. In CT, the decreased knee flexion was 90° (5 knees) and 80° (1 knee), while in PT; only 2 knees went below 110° (85 and 95°). Trendelenburg sign was negative in all PT by 3 months.
Percutaneous IM nailing, along with a good physiotherapy programme, seems to improve tremendously the outcome and decrease the complication rate, even in large limb lengthenings, which are considered as major surgery and often are associated with numerous complications.
The abstracts were prepared by Mr Simon Donell. Correspondence should be addressed to him at the Department of Orthopaedics, Norfolk & Norwich Hospital, Level 4, Centre Block, Colney Lane, Norwich NR4 7UY, United Kingdom.
