RETURN TO SPORTS AFTER RECONSTRUCTION OF ISOLATED ACL RUPTURES

Abstract

Purpose: To assess the results of ACL reconstructions carried out at our institution in a non-elite cohort of patients with regards to return to active sports post reconstruction.

Materials & Methods: Seventy-five (71%) of 106 patients who underwent reconstruction of isolated ACL tears between June 2001 and August 2004 performed by the senior author completed a newly designed questionnaire (incorporating Cincinnati Sports Activity Scale [CSAS]) to help us fully assess their return to sports and to elucidate reasons if not returning to pre-injury level. 55 were completed at follow up, with objective clinical assessment and other subjective questionnaires [KOOS, IKDC and Lysholm] and 20 were done through telephone interview.

Results: All 75 patients were involved in sports at CSAS Levels 1 & 2 prior to their injury and 39 (52%) had to drop to level 4 after injury. Following reconstruction 61 patients (81.3%) returned to CSAS 1 & 2 levels. 28 of 30 patients (93.3%) operated within 2 years from injury achieved pre-injury CSAS levels compared to 33 of 45 (73.3%) with a longer interval. The mean Lysholm, IKDC and KOOS Sports scores at 12 to 24 months follow up revealed a progressive trend and were 84.9, 76.3 and 73.6 respectively.

One reason for not returning to pre–injury intensity of sports was that many (71.7%) expressed fears of instability though most (70%) had no instability on playing. 77.8% of non-returners who were more than 30 years age reasoned not wanting to risk re-injury compared to 36.8% in the under 30 group. More significantly, 44.4% of over 30s said they were planning to drop their sporting level anyway compared to 5.5% in the younger group.

Conclusion: ACL reconstruction is best done as early as possible after injury for persons intending to return to competitive sports. The results are even better after early intervention in younger patients. Psychosocial issues play a significant role in return to active sports.