Abstract
Purpose: We report on minimum 2 year follow-up results of 71 patients randomised to autologous chon-drocyte implantation (ACI) using porcine-derived collagen membrane as a cover (ACI-C) and matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation (MACI) for the treatment of osteochondral defects of the knee.
Introduction: ACI is used widely as a treatment for symptomatic chondral and osteochondral defects of the knee. Variations of the original periosteum-cover technique include the use of porcine-derived type I/type III collagen as a cover (ACI-C) and matrix-induced autolo-gous chondrocyte implantation (MACI) using a collagen bilayer seeded with chondrocytes.
Results: 71 patients with a mean age of 33 years (15–48) were randomised to undergo either an ACI-C or a MACI. 37 had ACI-C and 34 MACI. The mean size of the defect was 5.0cm2. Mean duration of symptoms was 104.4 months (9–456). Mean follow-up was 33.5 months (24–45). Functional assessment using the modified Cincinnati knee score, the Bentley functional rating score and the visual analogue score was carried out. Assessment using the modified Cincinnati knee score showed a good to excellent result in 57.1% of patients followed up at 2 years, and 65.2% at 3 years in the ACI-C group; and 63.6% of patients at 2 years, and 64% at 3 years in the MACI group. Arthroscopic assessments showed a good to excellent International Cartilage Repair Society score in 81.8% of ACI-C grafts (22 patients) and 50% of MACI grafts (6 patients). Fisher’s exact test showed a p value of p=0.35 (not statistically significant). Hyaline-like cartilage or hyaline-like cartilage with fibrocartilage was found in biopsies of 56.3% of the ACI-C grafts (9 out of 16 patients) and 30% of the MACI grafts (3 out of 10 patients) after 2 years. Fisher’s exact test showed a p value of p=0.25 (not statistically significant).
Conclusion: At this stage of the trial we conclude that the clinical, arthroscopic and histological outcomes are comparable for both ACI-C and MACI.
Correspondence should be addressed to Mr Carlos Wigderowitz, Senior Lecturer, University Department of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery, Ninewells Hospital and Medical School, Dundee DD1 9SY.
