EVALUATION OF THE VALIDITY OF THE SIX HOUR RULE FOR OPEN TIBIAL FRACTURES

Abstract

It is generally accepted that urgent debridement and fixation of open tibial fractures minimizes the risk of infection. Traditionally surgeons follow the unwritten six hour rule. The purpose of this study was to determine the association between time to definite surgical management and rates of infection in open fractures of the tibia.

One hundred and twenty-seven patients with one hundred and twenty-eight open tibia fractures were retrospectively reviewed. Of these ninety patients with ninety-one one fractures were available for this study. All patients were followed up to clinical and radiological fracture union or until a definitive procedure for infection or non-union had been carried out.

The time from injury to surgery ranged from 2 hours 35 minutes to 12 hours with an average time of 5 hours 40 minutes. There were 24 Gustillo type I fractures (26.37%), 11 type II fractures (12.08%), 23 type IIIA fractures (25.27%) and 33 type IIIB fractures (36.26%). 5 patients (5.49%) in this study went onto develop a deep infection and there were 4(4.39%) non-unions. No infection occurred when the surgery was done within 2 hours. All the 5 infections in this study occurred in patients operated between 3 to 8 hours of the injury and were all in Gustillo Grade III fractures. The average time to treatment was not significantly different between the infected versus non infected group across all fracture types. There was no increase in infection rate in those treated after 6 hours compared to those treated within 6 hours.

The risk of developing an infection was not increased if the primary surgical management was delayed more than 6 hours after injury provided intravenous antibiotics were administered on presentation to the emergency department. The Gustillo grading of open fractures is a more accurate prognostic indicator for developing an infection.