Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Full Access

HIP RESURFACING ARTHROPLASTY: THE EFFECT OF ANTERIOR AND POSTERIOR NOTCHING ON FRACTURE RESISTANCE



Abstract

This study was designed to determine the risk of femoral neck fracture after anterior or posterior notching of the femoral neck. The anterior femoral neck is under tensile forces during gait similarly to the superior neck [6].

Method: Fortyseven 4th generation synthetic femora were implanted with Birmingham Hip Resurfacing pros-theses (Smith & Nephew Inc. Memphis, USA). Implant preparation was performed using imageless computer navigation (VectorVision SR 1.0, BrainLAB, Germany). The prosthesis was initially planned for neutral version and translated anterior, or posterior, to create a femoral neck notch. The femora were fixed in a single-leg stance and tested with axial compression. This method enabled comparison with previously published data. The synthetic femora were prepared in 8 experimental groups: 2mm and 5mm anterior notches, 2mm and 5mm posterior notches, neutral alignment with no notching (control), 5mm superior notch, 5mm anterior notch tested with the femur in 25° flexion and 5mm posterior notch tested with the femur in 25° extension

We tested the femora flexed at 25° flexion to simulate loading as seen during stair ascent. [3] The posterior 5mm notched femoral necks were tested in extension to simulate sporting activities like running. The results were compared to the control group in neutral alignment using a one- way ANOVA:

Results: Testing Group Mean load to failure Significance

  • Neutral (Control) 4303.09 ± 911.04N

  • Superior 5mm 2423.07 ± 424.16N p=0.003

  • Anterior 5mm in 25° flexion 3048.11 ±509.24N p=0.087

  • Posterior 5mm in 25° extension3104.61±592.67N p=0.117

The anterior 5mm notch tested in single-leg stance and anterior notch in flexion displayed lower compressive loads to failure (3374.64N and 3048.11N). The mean load to failure value for the posterior 5mm notches in extension was 3104.62N compared to 4303.09N for the control group.

Our data suggests that anterior and posterior 2mm notches are not significantly weaker in axial compression. The anterior 5mm notches was not significant in axial compression (p=0.38), but trended towards significance in flexion (p=0.087). A 5mm posterior notch was not significant. (p=0.995, p=0.117). The 5mm superior notch group was significantly weaker with axial compression supporting previous published data (p=0.003).

Conclusion: We conclude that anterior and posterior 2mm notching of the femoral neck has no clinical implications, however a 5mm anterior femoral neck notch may lead to fracture. The fracture is more likely to occur with stair ascent rather than normal walking given the reduction in strength noted after testing in flexion. Posterior 5mm notches are not likely to fracture. Hip resurfacing is commonly performed on active patients and 5mm notching of anterior cortex has clinically important implications.

Correspondence should be addressed to: EFORT Central Office, Technoparkstrasse 1, CH – 8005 Zürich, Switzerland. Tel: +41 44 448 44 00; Email: office@efort.org

Author: Gordon Higgins, United Kingdom

E-mail: higgins_gordon@hotmail.com