Abstract
Aims
Dead space management is an important element in the surgical management of chronic osteomyelitis and can be addressed with the use of a biodegradable local antibiotic carrier. We present the clinical and radiographic outcomes in two different biodegradable antibiotic carriers used in the management of chronic osteomyelitis.
Method
A single centre series reviewed between 2006–2017. The initial cohort (2006–2010) of 180 cases (Group A) had a calcium sulphate carrier containing tobramycin (Osteoset® T, Wright Medical). The second cohort (2013–1017) of 162 cases (Group B) had a biphasic calcium sulphate, nano-crystalline hydroxyapatite carrier containing gentamicin (CeramentTM G, Bonesupport AB).
All cases were Cierny-Mader Grade III and IV and had a minimum of one-year clinical follow-up.
Clinical outcomes reviewed included infection recurrence rate, wound leak, and subsequent fracture involving the treated segment. All cases with a minimum one-year radiographic follow-up were reviewed and bone void filling was assessed as percentage filling on the final follow-up radiograph to the nearest five percent increment.
Results
Mean follow-up in Group A was 4.2 years (range 1.3–10.5 years) and in Group B it was 1.8 years (1–4.7 years). Group A had a significantly higher rate of infection recurrence (19/180 (10.6%) Vs. 7/163 (4.4%) p=0.030), wound leak (33/180 (18.3.%) Vs. 16/162 (9.9%) p=0.026) and subsequent fracture rate (11/180 (6.1%) Vs. 3/162 (1.9%) p=0.047) compared to Group B.
Of the cases with a minimum of one-year radiographic follow-up Group A had 96 cases (mean follow-up 3.3 years, range 1.0–10.5 years) and Group B had 137 cases (mean follow-up 1.6 years, range 1.0–4.7 years). The mean bone void healing in Group B was significantly better than Group A (74.0% Vs. 41.7%, p <0.00001).
Conclusions
CeramentTM G has significantly better bone healing compared to a calcium sulphate carrier and was associated with a lower rate of recurrent infection, wound leak and subsequent fracture risk.