Abstract
Background
To determine the relative contributions of bilateral versus unilateral femoral shaft fracture plus injuries in other body regions to mortality after injury.
Study design
A retrospective analysis of the prospectively recorded Trauma Registry data (TARN) from 1989 to 2003.
Methods
Patients were divided into groups UFi (isolated unilateral femur injury),BFi (isolated bilateral femur injury) and UFa and BFa if an associated injury was present. Data collected for each patient included age, Injury Severity Scores, Glasgow Coma Scale, mortality, physiological parameters, the timing and extent of prehospital care, the time to arrival at the hospital, initial treatments, time to and type of surgery, length of ICU and hospital stay. Logistic regression data analysis was performed to determine variables that were associated with increased mortality.
Results
Patients in group BFa had a significantly higher ISS (23 vs 9),reduced GCS (12 vs 15) and increased mortality rate (31.6% vs 9.8%) than patients in group BFi. Group BFa patients had an increased number of associated injuries than group UFa. Regression analysis of variables evident on admission revealed a significant correlation between bilateral femoral fractures with associated injuries and mortality. However bilateral fracture, even in isolation significantly increased the odds of mortality by 3.07(1.36-6.92). Intramedullary nailing (IMN) was the method of fracture fixation associated with the lowest patient mortality overall. However, when assessing patient mortality in the BFa group with an ISS of more than 40, three other fracture fixation regimens were associated with a lower mortality rate than the IMN group.
Conclusions
The increase in mortality with bilateral femoral fractures is more closely associated with the presence of associated injuries and poor physiological parameters than to the presence of the bilateral femoral fracture alone. However contrary to ISS scoring the latter does convey a significant additional risk of mortality. The presence of bilateral femoral fractures should alert the clinician to the very high likelihood (80%) of significant associated injuries in other body systems and their life-threatening potential.
