Abstract
Introduction
Sternoclavicular dislocations are well-known adult injuries. The same traumatism causes growth-plate fracture of the medial clavicle in children and young adults. At this location, the emergence of the secondary ossification center and its bony fusion are late. We report the results of 20 cases hospitalized in the Toulouse University Hospital Center that were treated surgically.
Materials & Methods
20 patients were treated between 1993 and 2007, 17 boys and 3 girls, 16 years old (6–20). The traumatism was always violent (rugby 75%). Two physeal fractures were anteriorly displaced, and 18 posteriorly. The follow-up is 64 month (8–174).
Clinical, radiographic and therapeutic characteristics were assessed. The long-term results were analysed with: an algo-functional scale (Oxford shoulder score), the subjective Constant score, a functional disability scale (Shoulder simple test), a quality of life scale (DASH), and global indicators (SANE and global satisfaction).
Results
all the patients were symptomatic before surgery: pains, oedema and partial functional impotence. Only 2 dysphagia, 1 dyspnea and 1 venous circulation alteration were observed. The first clinical and radiological examination, before CT scan, didn't diagnose the injury in 8 cases. The CT scan were realized for all the patients: it diagnosed the physeal fracture and showed 4 cases of vascular or respiratory compressions.
There were 5 attempts of closed reduction, without success: all the patients were surgically-treated.
The open reduction were completed by pinning (12 cases) or cerclage with absorbable suture (3 cases). Per-operatory findings lead to realize costo-clavicular repair plasties with the sub-clavicular muscle (3 cases) and/or capsular-ligamentous-perosteal selective plasties (13 cases).
Two cases of broken Kirschner wires were noticed, without migration. Functional outcomes are largely good or excellent: STT 11,74/12 (10–12)–OSS 12,95/60 (12–19)–DASH 2,07/100 (0–17,6)–SANE 93,16% (60–100).
Discussion and Conclusion
we present the largest case series in the literature. CT scanner is the essential element of the diagnostic process and may allow the distinction between true sterno-clavicular dislocation and displaced physeal fractures. This distinction is difficult at younger ages and is facilitated by the progression of ossification. Very good results were obtained, but classical pitfalls of treatment were found: instability after closed reduction, broken K-wires, recurrent anterior instability, inesthetic scars.
