Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Results 1 - 20 of 23
Results per page:
Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 102-B, Issue SUPP_11 | Pages 58 - 58
1 Dec 2020
Ranson J Nuttall G Paton R
Full Access

Aims & Background. Congenital Talipes Equinovarus (CTEV) is the most common congenital musculoskeletal birth defect affecting 1 in 1000 births per annum. We have compared our surgical results to the British Society of Children's Orthopaedics (BSCOS) published guidelines. Methods. Between, 2006–16, patients who were referred for treatment of pathological CTEV were audited. Data from a combination of Clinical Portal, Orthotic Patient Administration System and Surgical Elogbook were assessed. In addition, the degree of deformity was classified by the Harrold & Walker method at the time of diagnosis (senior author). Most of this information was recorded prospectively and analysed retrospectively. Ponseti technique was the method of treatment. Results. 96 patients assessed (133 feet). There were 78 males and 18 females, 37 patients were affected bilaterally and 11 had associated syndromes. There were 23 Harrold & Walker (H&W) 1, 28 H&W 2 and 82 H&W 3 classification feet. Average time period in Ponseti boots and bars was 14.4 months (95% CI 12.9–15.9), average time in all types of bracing of was 17.1 months (95% CI 14.8–14.8). Number and rate of surgeries performed were as follows: 77 Tendoachilles release (63.1%), 19 Tibialis Anterior Transfer (5.6%), 15 Radical Release (12.3%), revision 25 Surgery (20.5%) & 5 Abductor Hallucis Release (4.1%). Conclusion. The audit confirms that the unit meets most of the current BSCOS guidelines. All surgical procedures apart from radical release surgery fall within accepted limits. This may be due, in part, to the syndromal cases. We do however demonstrate a significantly reduced average time period in bracing compared to that recommended by BSCOS. There are multiple reasons for this discrepancy including non-compliance and poor splint tolerance (child refusing to use). We feel this work demonstrates a reduced period in bracing can be achieved whilst maintaining standards of treatment


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 86-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 269 - 269
1 Mar 2004
Chesney D Barker S Maffulli N
Full Access

Aim: Congenital Talipes Equinovarus (CTEV) is managed in a variety of ways, with little agreement on how best to assess outcome. Some authors advocate patient based subjective assessments, while others use a variety of objective measures. Without agreement, it is impossible to evaluate different management methods. We have therefore evaluated a number of objective parameters compared to a subjective assessment following management of CTEV. Methods: 216 children and their families consented to participate in the study. The children had been managed in a number of hospitals across Scotland, and in a variety of ways. Outcome was assessed by a researcher not involved in the management of the children. Subjective assessment consisted of a postal questionnaire. Objective assessment consisted of a number of anthropometric measures. Results: A strong correlation was seen between subjective assessment, and several objective outcome measures including foot length discrepancy, calf muscle wasting, and range of movement at the ankle. Conclusions: Objective assessment using several parameters correlates well with subjective assessment. Using these objective measures, it is possible to evaluate and compare different management protocols in CTEV


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XVII | Pages 48 - 48
1 May 2012
Moroney P Noel J Fogarty E Kelly P
Full Access

Congenital Talipes Equinovarus (CTEV) occurs in approximately 1 in 1000 live births. Most cases occur as an isolated birth defect and are considered idiopathic. The widespread adoption of the Ponseti technique of serial casting followed by Achilles tenotomy and long term bracing has revolutionised the outcomes in CTEV. In most cases, plantigrade, flexible, pain-free feet may be produced without the need for extensive surgery. It is estimated that about 10% of cases of CTEV are not idiopathic. These feet are stiffer and more challenging to treat. In particular, there is little evidence in the literature concerning the efficacy of the Ponseti method in these cases. In our institution, a dedicated weekly Ponseti clinic has operated since 2005. To date 140 patients have been treated. We prospectively enter all details regarding their management onto an independent international database. The aim of this study was to audit the non-idiopathic cases of CTEV and to assess the effectiveness of the Ponseti technique in these challenging cases. Outcome measures included the Pirani score and eventual need for surgical intervention. We identified 29 cases (46 feet) with non-idiopathic CTEV. This comprises 21% of our workload. Seventeen were bilateral. The commonest diagnoses were neuromuscular conditions such as spina bifida (5 cases) and cerebral palsy (3 cases). There were 4 cases of Trisomy 21. Other causes included Nail Patella syndrome, Moebius syndrome, Larsen syndrome and Ito syndrome. In approximately 12% of cases, the underlying disorder remained undiagnosed despite thorough medical and genetic testing. In cases of non-idiopathic CTEV, the mean starting Pirani score was 5.5 (out of 6). After serial casting and Achilles tenotomy, the average score was 2.0. Twenty-one of 46 feet (46%) ultimately required further surgical intervention (mostly posteromedial release). We found that certain conditions were more likely to be successfully treated with the Ponseti method – these included conditions characterised by ligamentous laxity such as Trisomy 21 and Ehlers Danlos syndrome. All patients showed some improvement in Pirani score after serial casting. We believe that it is essential to attempt the Ponseti method of serial casting in all cases of CTEV. More than half of all non-idiopathic cases will not require further surgical intervention – and those that do are not as stiff thanks to the effects of serial casting. Thus, the surgery required is not as complex as it might otherwise have been. This is the largest series of its kind in the current medical literature


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 96-B, Issue SUPP_1 | Pages 3 - 3
1 Jan 2014
Hughes S Jugdey R Choudry Q Paton R
Full Access

Aim:. An assessment of the relationship between pathological Developmental Dysplasia of the Hip (DDH) and Congenital Talipes Equinovarus (CTEV). Introduction:. Traditional UK guidelines consider abnormalities of the foot to be a risk factor for DDH. 1,2. Currently, there is controversy whether congenital foot abnormalities are true risk factors for pathological DDH. 3,4. There is a relationship between CTCV and hip dysplasia though the relationship between CTEV and pathological DDH is less clear. 5. In a previous 11 year prospective longitudinal study no case of Graf Types III, IV or irreducible hip dislocation were associated with CTEV. 5. Subsequent correspondence and case histories have challenged this view. 6. Methods:. In order to clarify this issue, a 20-year prospective longitudinal observational study was undertaken. All cases of fixed CTEV (Harold & Walker types 1 to 3) referred to the sub-regional Paediatric Orthopaedic clinic at the Royal Blackburn Hospital were evaluated, the feet and hips clinically assessed (Ortolani & Barlow manoeuvres) and the hips ultra-sounded by the senior author (RWP). Modified Graf and Harcke hip ultrasound classification systems were employed. Graf Type III, IV and irreducible hip dislocation were considered pathological. Results:. The incidence of CTEV was 1.46 per 1000 live births (nationally quoted incidence of 1 to 2 per 1000 live births. 7. ). There was one case of Graf Type III dysplasia with no cases of clinical hip instability. Currently, the clinical significance of this type of dysplasia is uncertain. There were no cases of Graf Type IV dislocations or radiological irreducible hip dislocation. Conclusion:. Fixed CTEV should not be considered as a risk factor for pathological DDH and routine sonographic hip screening of CTEV should not be advocated. This is supportive evidence for the current English NIPE guidelines in which the only risk factors screened are family history and breech presentation. Level of evidence: II


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 95-B, Issue SUPP_24 | Pages 1 - 1
1 May 2013
Pullinger M Easton V Southorn T Smith R Sanghrajka A
Full Access

Aim. Congenital Talipes Equinovarus (CTEV) has been excluded from the standards set by the NHS fetal anomaly screening programme (NHS FASP) for the 18. +0. –20. +6. week fetal ultrasound scan (USS). Whilst adhering to NHS FASP guidelines, the antenatal ultrasound department at our centre performs “incidental screening” for CTEV; parents are informed if CTEV is noted incidentally during the scan and referral made to the fetal medicine department. Our aim was to investigate the effectiveness of incidental antenatal screening for structural CTEV. Method. The database of the antenatal ultrasound department was interrogated for all suspected cases of CTEV on the 18. +0. –20. +6. week USS, between August 2006 and June 2012. Terminations, stillbirths and outside referrals were excluded. Our Ponseti-service database was searched to identify all patients treated for structural CTEV between January 2007 and November 2012. Cases were excluded if the mother did not receive antenatal-care at our centre. Results from the two searches were cross-referenced, and statistical analysis performed. Results. 30077 18. +0. –20. +6. week USS were performed on 24282 patients, with CTEV diagnosed in 74 patients. After exclusions, there were 39 patients. 54 patients were treated for structural CTEV with 37 patients (54 feet, CTEV-incidence 0.001) after exclusions; 25 (67.5%) diagnosed pre-natally (15 unilateral, 10 bilateral), and 12 (32.5%) diagnosed post-natally (5 unilateral, 7 bilateral). Sensitivity of screening for CTEV was 67.5%, specificity 99.8%, positive predictive value (PPV) 64.1% and negative predictive value 99.9%. The proportion of cases detected antenatally has reduced since introduction of NHS-FASP. Conclusion. This data is important and necessary to comprehensively counsel our patients. We are unable to find similar contemporary data from other units within the NHS for comparison. NHS-FASP guidelines seem to have reduced the efficacy of antenatal detection of CTEV at our unit, and further prospective study is required to determine the value of screening for patients


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 105-B, Issue SUPP_2 | Pages 44 - 44
10 Feb 2023
Kollias C Neville E Vladusic S McLachlan L
Full Access

Specific brace-fitting complications in idiopathic congenital talipes equinovarus (CTEV) have been rarely described in published series, and usually focus on non-compliance. Our primary aim was to compare the rate of persistent pressure sores in patients fitted with Markell boots and Mitchell boots. Our additional aims were to describe the frequency of other brace fitting complications and identify age trends in these complications. A retrospective analysis of medical files of 247 idiopathic CTEV patients born between 01/01/2010 - 01/01/2021 was performed. Data was collected using a REDCap database.

Pressure sores of sufficient severity for clinician to recommend time out of brace occurred in 22.9% of Mitchell boot and 12.6% of Markell boot patients (X2 =6.9, p=0.009). The overall rate of bracing complications was 51.4%. 33.2% of parents admitted to bracing non-compliance and 31.2% of patients required re-casting during the bracing period for relapse. For patients with a minimum follow-up of age 6 years, 44.2% required tibialis anterior tendon transfer. Parents admitting to non-compliance were significantly more likely to have a child who required tibialis anterior tendon transfer (X2=5.71, p=0.017). Overall rate of capsular release (posteromedial release or posterior release) was 2.0%.

Neither medium nor longterm results of Ponseti treatment in the Australian and New Zealand clubfoot have been published. Globally, few publications describe specific bracing complications in clubfoot, despite this being a notable challenge for clinicians and families. Recurrent pressure sores is a persistent complication with the Mitchell boots for patients in our center. In our population of Australian clubfoot patients, tibialis anterior tendon transfer for relapse is common, consistent with the upper limit of tibialis anterior tendon transfer rates reported globally.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 100-B, Issue SUPP_14 | Pages 90 - 90
1 Nov 2018
Tully R McQuail P McCormack D
Full Access

Congenital talipes equinovarus (CTEV), also known as club foot or talipes is a common congenital disorder. Parents are using the Internet more and more as a source of information about health care. Unfortunately, the quality of health care information on the Internet varies. This study looked at information available to parents using two instruments for judging the equality of information on the internet. The top five search engines were searched on Google. Three of these were also included in the top 50 sites in Ireland so these 3 sites were used. The phrases CTEV and club foot were searched from all 3 platforms. Websites were then scrutinized using the HON code and the DISCERN tool. 54 organic sites were found for the 3 search engines using the key word club foot. For the key word CTEV 55 matches were returned for the three search engines. 4 websites displayed the HON code. Using the discern tool CTEV websites had a mean score of 60 with a standard deviation of 17. While club foot had a mean score of 56.8 with a standard deviation of 13. Max score 80. Large volumes of information are available to parents on the Internet. Often parents find comfort in sharing experiences and feel empowered by learning about their children's illnesses. However, information provided on the interned can also be ambiguous and disingenuous. Practitioners should be aware of a number of key websites that parents can be directed towards.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 91-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 365 - 365
1 May 2009
Mihelarakis J Markeas N Volonakis E Valentis E
Full Access

Aim: This study was carried out in order to clarify the causes that are mainly responsible for the necessity of reoperation after the initial correction of the deformity in congenital talipes equinovarus. The cases, which had been treated surgically with the same method and recurred later, were studied retrospectively in order to be ascertained epidemiological data related to the disease, to be isolated operative findings related to its pathology and to be estimated the surgical results based on clinical and radiological criteria.

Material-Methods: During the 15-year-period from 1990 to 2004, 123 infants (196 feet) with congenital talipes equinovarus have been treated operatively. There were 88 males and 35 females. Seventy three patients (59.3%) had the deformity bilaterally, 20 patients in right foot and 30 in left. Family history was positive in 5 infants. Other congenital anomalies coexisted in 12 infants (9.7%). Preoperative application of successive plasters was started into the first week for 93 infants (75.6%) and its duration was 3 months for 83.7% of cases. All the patients have been operated on with posteromedial approach, extensive ligament division and generous release of soft tissues during the first year of age. Two thirds of cases (67.4%) were treated surgically into the first 6 months of age.

Results: Anatomical variations were revealed during the operation in 14 feet (7.1% of the cases). The clinical results as well as the radiological signs into the first 6 postoperative months were satisfactory, but a reoperation was necessary in 21 feet (in 14 infants) for correction of part of the initial deformity into the following 2–5 years. The clinical criteria were related to the manner of standing and walking, the range of motion of the foot joints and block test. The radiological criteria were related to anteroposterior and lateral talocalcaneal angles and the angle between the longitudinal axis of the talus and that of the first metatarsal in the anteroposterior view as well as the position of the calcaneus in the lateral view. The causes that led to recurrence were related to imperfect correction with the plasters, to incomplete release of soft tissues during the initial operation and to some likely predisposing congenital and environmental factors.

Conclusions: The prevention of recurrence of the initial deformity, in the operative correction of congenital talipes equinovarus, is mainly related to the attentive pre-operative application of plasters, the careful lege artis surgical technique and the early diagnosis and treatment of the predisposing factors.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 85-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 168 - 168
1 Feb 2003
Fehily M Paton R
Full Access

From mid-1992 to 2000 and in conjunction with our paediatric department, we have run a screening program to detect congenital orthopaedic abnormalities. Over this period, we have been referred 245 patients with a provisional diagnosis of clubfeet, of these 54 or 22% were true CTEV (78 feet) giving an incidence in the general population of 0.18% while the rest were diagnosed as having simple postural clubfoot (0.6%).

Each patient was assessed clinically and classified according to the Harrold and Walker scale as well as being checked for other congenital/neurological abnormalities. 83% of patients were seen within two weeks of referral. Initial management entailed strapping for 6 weeks with further periods of plaster immobilization (required by 46%). Those who failed to respond or who deteriorated underwent surgical correction with sub-talar release. A small percentage required secondary procedures such as Tibialis Anterior transfer, Tendoachillis release and revision.

Patients were continued in the program until at least 6 years of age. While there was a wide variation of other abnormalities in those with type 2 CTEV, those with type 3 had a high incidence of neurological conditions and in particular, arthrogryphosis (59%). These patients did worse and 55% required further surgery after the initial sub-talar release.

We would like to present the findings of an 8.5 year prospective study looking at the incidence of the condition, the frequency of other abnormalities and the results of conservative and surgical treatment for each grade.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 91-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 215 - 215
1 May 2009
Valentine KM Uglow MG Clarke NMP
Full Access

Aim: To compare the rate of relapse of Ponseti treatment method with a historical cohort who underwent conventional surgery.

Method and Results: From June 2002 to December 2004, 70 patients presented with 107 clubfeet and started the Ponseti treatment method. 15 feet in 9 patients were excluded due to teratologic deformity. 50 patients with 75 clubfeet were studied (41 boys and 9 girls). There was at least a two-year follow up period, or failure of the Ponseti method within this time frame. Data was compiled from clinic assessment forms and patient notes. All cases resulting in recasting or further surgical procedures were regarded as failure of conservative treatment. This was compared to published data from the same centre, regarding relapse for the two-stage surgical method. From 1988 to 1995, 86 patients presented with 120 clubfeet and had surgical treatment. 68 patients with 91 clubfeet (48 boys 20 girls) had the two-stage surgical procedure and were followed up at a mean age of 5.7 years (2.2 to 9.6). The mean age for surgery was 8.9 months.

Relapse rate of both treatment methods was compared for all feet in all Dimeglio grades. Relapse rates for Ponseti and surgery respectively were: grade 2, 18.2% vs 0%; grade 3, 36.2% vs 20.4%; grade 4, 35.3% vs 65.4%. The differences were not statistically significant

Conclusions: The Ponseti method is as valid as the two-stage surgical method for the treatment of clubfoot. Functional outcomes of the two treatment methods need to be compared.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 99-B, Issue SUPP_16 | Pages 17 - 17
1 Oct 2017
Humphry S Lumb B Clabon D Baker D
Full Access

This is the first study in the Ponseti-era to compare severity and outcomes in cases of idiopathic congenital talipes equinovarus (CTEV) diagnosed antenatally versus those diagnosed at birth. Small pre-Ponseti studies showed antenatal diagnosis to be a predictor of severity and poor prognosis.

Prospective data collection was used to compare indicators of severity and outcomes for idiopathic CTEV between these two groups. These include Pirani score, number of casts, follow-up Roye score and need for surgery.

68 children with 106 affected feet were included. Antenatal diagnosis (AD) was made in 45 children (71 feet), with birth diagnosis (BD) in 23 children (35 feet). Mean follow-up age was 4.8 years (AD = 4.9, BD = 4.7), male:female ratio 2:1 (AD=BD) with bilateral CTEV in 55% (AD = 58%, BD=52%). Mean initial Pirani scores were 5.25 in the AD group vs 4.86 in the BD group (p=0.06). Mean Roye score at follow-up was 1.39/4 in the AD group vs 1.26/4 in the BD group (p=0.33) with 33% vs 30% complaining of pain respectively (p=0.80). Surgery was needed in 11/71 (15.5%) in the AD group vs 1/35 (2.9%) in the BD group (p=0.06))

There is no significant difference in severity between antenatal and birth diagnoses of idiopathic CTEV and no difference in outcomes between these groups when treated with the Ponseti regime. Although small, our sample size is greater than the largest published comparable study.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 94-B, Issue SUPP_XLIII | Pages 20 - 20
1 Sep 2012
Tong A Bizby O Price N Williams P
Full Access

Introduction

The Ponseti regime was introduced in Swansea in 2003 for the treatment of congenital talipes equinovarus (CTEV). The aim of this retrospective cohort study was to compare children treated with this regime with a historical group treated traditionally before then.

Materials and Methods

Sixty children (89 feet) were treated with the Ponseti regime between 2003 and 2010. Their notes were compared with notes from 12 children (21 feet) treated between 1995 and 2002. Clinic attendance for serial manipulation and immobilisation (strap/cast) was compared using a two-tailed Mann Whitney U test. Major release surgery was compared using a two-tailed Fisher's Exact test.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 88-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 260 - 260
1 May 2006
Blake S Cox P
Full Access

It is difficult to predict the outcome or likely treatment that will be required for an individual child with a rigid clubfoot deformity at an early stage.

32 Dimeglio grade II, III or IV CTEV feet in 24 infants were treated with weekly serial casts according to Ponseti method. Graphical plots of the improvement obtained in Dimeglio scores during serial cast treatment of CTEV were subsequently analysed to identify characteristic features that would help predict the likely success of casting or the need and extent of surgical release. The rate of change in global Dimeglio score, hindfoot (equinus / heel varus) and midfoot (adduction / derotation) components were specifically studied.

During casting the rate of change over 4 weeks and a “plateauing” of the global Dimeglio score after 4–6 weeks of casting separated those feet that responded to casting alone from those that required additional surgery. Those with “plateauing” and minimal midfoot deformity by 4 weeks (adduction /derotation score < =2) required a posterior release. Failure to correct the mid-foot deformity by 4 weeks (adduction /derotation score > = 3) predicted the need for a combined plantar medial and posterolateral release. These parameters were clearly demonstrated by graphical plots that can be easily obtained in a busy clinic setting.

Graphical representation of the rate of change in Dimeglio parameters can predict the likely treatment needed for children with CTEV. A graphical algorithm has been developed that can be used during the first 6 weeks of treatment to guide Ponseti method casting and early surgical intervention.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 84-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 122 - 122
1 Jul 2002
Harvey A Uglow M Clarke N
Full Access

From a cohort of 110 idiopathic clubfeet, 26 feet in 18 children requiring surgery for severe relapse have been studied. Surgery was comprised of a lateral column shortening procedure (Lichtblau) plus or minus a plantarmedial release. Surgery was staged to avoid wound complications.

Pre-operatively, feet were prospectively categorised into one of four grades according to a system reported by Dimeglio. Children were reviewed on two subsequent occasions. At review, feet were again graded. In addition, appearance and functional outcome was analysed and included an assessment of gait, activity and functional limitation.

Three children were lost to follow-up, leaving 22 feet in seven male and eight female patients available for review. The mean age at surgery was 43 months (23–82). The mean time from surgery to first and second reviews was 35 and 56 months, respectively.

There was a significant improvement in grading at first review compared to pre-operative grading (Wilcoxon signed ranks test). Although there remained a significant improvement in grading at second review compared to the preoperative grading, there was a significant reduction in the number of feet in which grading had improved when compared to first review.

There was no significant change in function between the two post-operative reviews (Chi-square tests), with the majority of children experiencing little functional limitation. There were no wound complications.

Relapse surgery, involving a lateral column shortening procedure for severe clubfoot, results in a significant initial improvement when assessed using a grading system. This improvement in grading subsequently decreases over time. However, the functional outcome in such cases remains favourable.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 88-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 436 - 436
1 Oct 2006
Tennant S Eastwood D Catterall A Franceschi F Monsell F
Full Access

Introduction: The Ilizarov external fixator has theoretical advantages over conventional revision surgery for the treatment of recurrent clubfoot deformity. The aim of this study was to assess the outcome of such treatment.

Materials & Methods: Patients were reviewed clinically and completed extensive questionnaires documenting pain, function and satisfaction before and after the frame at a mean follow-up of 44 months (range 14–131). All patient notes and radiographs were reviewed.

Results: There were 42 frames applied to 40 feet in 31 patients. Deformity was idiopathic in 29 cases. Pain and function scores after treatment improved in 67% and 72% of cases respectively. A subjective increase in stiffness was noted in 46%. Patient satisfaction with outcome was 61%. Pain and function scores were not significantly different in stiff versus non-stiff feet. The overall recurrence rate was 44%; these feet had been treated with the Ilizarov fixator at a younger mean age (7.8 years) than those feet which did not recur (12.6 years). Recurrence was highest in the idiopathic group (59%) compared with the constriction band group (17%) and the neuromuscular/syndromic group (0%), despite the fact that the idiopathic group were older overall. 71% of recurrences experienced significant pain post treatment, compared with only 36% of non-recurrent feet. Functional ability was, however, similar in the two groups. Further surgical treatment has currently been necessary in 6 patients, including 4 repeat Ilizarov frames. Complications included almost universal minor pin-site infections, flexion contractures of the toes in 5 feet and skin ulceration in 2 feet, 1 requiring a muscle flap.

Conclusions: Treatment of the relapsed clubfoot with the Ilizarov fixator can improve the appearance of the foot, correlating with improvement in pain and function. Risks include recurrence, particularly in young, idiopathic feet, an increase in stiffness of the ankle, which has implications for future surgery, and other complications.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 87-B, Issue SUPP_I | Pages 71 - 71
1 Mar 2005
Uglow M Senbaga N Pickard R Clarke N
Full Access

Introduction: To review the medium term outcome of staged surgery for treating recalcitrant idiopathic talipes equinovarus.

Methods: Between 1988 and 1995, we studied 91 club feet from a series of 120 recalcitrant feet in 86 patients requiring surgical treatment. The initial results have been reported previously and this cohort has been subsequently followed up for between 7 and 15years. The mean age at initial operation was 8.9 months. Surgery consisted of an initial plantar medial release followed two weeks later by a posterolateral release. This strategy was used specifically to address the problems of wound healing associated with single-stage surgery and to ascertain the rate of relapse after a two-stage procedure. The feet were classified preoperatively and prospectively into four grades according to the system suggested by Dimeglio et al. Reported relapse at last review was 0.0% in grade 2, 20.4% in grade 3 and 65.4% in grade 4 feet. The rate of overall relapse was 30.8%. At 7 to 15 year review an additional 9.1% in grade 2, 7.4% in grade 3, 11.5% in grade 4 had relapsed. Overall a further 8.8% had relapsed and were treated with further surgery. Functional outcome of the group remains good with 95.6% overall finding no restrictions to activities.

Conclusion: This review confirms that the strategy of staged surgery is supported in the medium term when considering rates of relapse and functional outcome.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 85-B, Issue SUPP_I | Pages 42 - 42
1 Jan 2003
Thomas R O’Doherty D
Full Access

The Cincinnati incision is widely utilized in clubfoot surgery and allows excellent access to the medial, lateral and posterior structures involved. Closure of the skin at the end of the procedure without undue tension may be difficult. Wound necrosis and excessive scarring may occur and may lead to inadequate correction. One alternative is to splint the foot in an initial equines position post-operatively with repeat cast changes to achieve optimal position once soft tissue swelling has decreased. A further method is to leave the wound open and allow it to granulate.

The healing and final cosmetic appearance of wounds allowed to heal by granulation following the Cincinnati incision were reviewed.

We reviewed 14 feet in 10 patients who had undergone partial closure of the Cincinnati incision following peritalar release. The majority of the children were male and the average age at surgery was 28 weeks. All corrections were performed as primary procedures on patients with idiopathic CTEV. At the end of the procedure an above-knee plaster was applied. The plaster was changed weekly in the outpatients department until the wound had healed. Patients were maintained in plaster for 12 weeks.

All final wounds were cosmetically acceptable both to the surgeon and the parents. The widest scar was 3 mm and the average time to heal four weeks. No infection had occurred although two wounds were treated for overgranulation.

Partial wound closure of the Cincinnati incision avoids undue tissue tension and allows a fully corrected position of the foot to be maintained at the end of the initial procedure. A second anaesthetic to obtain further correction is therefore avoided. Partial wound closure leaves cosmetically acceptable scarring with minimal complications. Parents should be warned about the initial appearance of the wound but may be reassured regarding final outcome.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 92-B, Issue SUPP_II | Pages 286 - 286
1 May 2010
Mehrafshan M Rampal V Wicart P Seringe R
Full Access

Purpose of the study: The aim of this study was to evaluate the results of the repeated soft tissue release for recurrent postoperative idiopathic congenital talipes equinovarus. There is no real consensus on the appropriate therapeutic option.

Materials and Methods: Fifty two patients (74 feet) underwent revision surgery performed by our senior surgeon between 1974 and 2001. One, two or three soft tissue release procedures were performed on 59, 12 and 3 feet respectively. Mean age at the time of the revision surgery was 5.7 years (range 15m-14y). Triple deformity (varus, equinus, adductus) was found in 46 feet, while 28 feet had one dominant deformity. The operation consisted of complete release of the soft tissues in 26 feet and partial release in 48. Subtalar release was indicated in 21 feet. Lichtblau osteotomy was performed in 48 feet. The clinical and radiological outcome was assessed using the Ghanem and Seringe scores recorded before surgery and at last follow-up.

Results: Mean follow-up was 11 years (range 4–30). Complications included overcorrection in valgus (n=6) and recurrence (n=8). The anatomic correction was highly significant. Dorsoplantar X-rays show the improvements in the mean talocalcaneal divergence (18–21°), the mean talus-first metatarsal angle (reduced from 28° to 4°), and the calcaneus-fifth metatarsal angle (reduced from 20° to 2°). The average of tibiocalcaneal angle in lateral view increased from 1° to 10° and the average of calcaneal incidence from 6° to 9°. At last follow-up, outcome was considered as ‘excellent’ in 29% and ‘good’ in 42% of the cases. We had ‘fair’ results in 14 feet (19%) because of poor functional results in one third and anatomical defects in two-thirds of them. The outcome was considered ‘poor’ in seven feet (10%), which was due to significant anatomical defects. Triple arthrodesis was needed in seven feet after skeletal maturity.

Discussion and Conclusion. Repeated soft tissue release provides an effective means for correcting anatomical anomalies caused by recurrent postoperative talipes equinovarus. The mid-term results are however affected by functional limitations characterised by decreased range of motion and joint pain, particularly in ankle joint. Excessive subtalar release raises the risk of valgus overcorrection. A splint worn at night may be helpful for preventing the recurrence.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 91-B, Issue SUPP_I | Pages 57 - 57
1 Mar 2009
Blake S Cox P
Full Access

It is difficult to predict the outcome or likely treatment that will be required for an individual child with a rigid clubfoot deformity at an early stage.

32 Dimeglio grade II, III or IV CTEV feet in 24 infants were treated with weekly serial casts according to Ponseti method. Graphical plots of the improvement obtained in Dimeglio scores during serial cast treatment of CTEV were subsequently analysed to identify characteristic features that would help predict the likely success of casting or the need and extent of surgical release. The rate of change in global Dimeglio score, hindfoot (equinus/heel varus) and midfoot (adduction/derotation) components were specifically studied.

During casting the rate of change over 4 weeks and a “plateauing” of the global Dimeglio score after 4–6 weeks of casting separated those feet that responded to casting alone from those that required additional surgery. Those with “plateauing” and minimal midfoot deformity by 4 weeks (adduction/derotation score < =2) required a posterior release. Failure to correct the mid-foot deformity by 4 weeks (adduction/derotation score > = 3) predicted the need for a combined plantarme-dial and posterolateral release. These parameters were clearly demonstrated by graphical plots that can be easily obtained in a busy clinic setting.

Graphical representation of the rate of change in Dimeglio parameters can predict the likely treatment needed for children with CTEV. A graphical algorithm has been developed that can be used during the first 6 weeks of treatment to guide Ponseti method casting and early surgical intervention.


Orthopaedic Proceedings
Vol. 90-B, Issue SUPP_III | Pages 500 - 500
1 Aug 2008
Maffulli N Cardy§ AH Barker S Sharp L Chesney D Miedzybrodzka Z
Full Access

Background: Congenital talipes equinovarus (CTEV) is a common developmental disorder of the foot, affecting between 1 and 4.5 babies per 1000 live births. The etiology is not well elucidated. While both genetic and environmental factors are implicated, no specific genes have been identified and little is known about environmental risk factors.

Methods: We conducted a case-control study of idiopathic congenital talipes equinovarus (ICTEV) in the United Kingdom. 194 cases and 60 controls were recruited. Pedigrees were obtained for 162 cases.

Results: The rank of the index pregnancy, maternal education and cesarean delivery were significantly associated with ICTEV risk in a multivariate model. There were suggestions that maternal use of folic acid supplements in the three months before the pregnancy decreased ICTEV risk, and that parental smoking during the pregnancy increased risk. One quarter of pedigrees showed a family history of CTEV, and autosomal dominant inheritance was suggested in some of these.

Conclusion: Uterine restriction did not appear to have a strong influence on ICTEV development in our study. Large population-based studies are needed to clarify the etiology of this common developmental disorder.