Purpose: The purpose of this work was to compare the precision and reliability of screw fixation using two different guiding systems. The first system was based on computed tomography (CT) imaging and the second on digitalized fluoroscopic imaging.

Material and methods: Between 1998 and 2000, 88 patients underwent spinal fixation for diverse disease states (idiopathic scoliosis in 43, and fracture, spondylolisthesis or instability in 45). Pedicular screws (n = 223) were inserted in levels T4 to S1. The passive CT navigation system was used for 73 patients (177 pedicular screws) and the fluoroscopic navigation system for 15 (46 pedicular screws). An independent observer identified the position of the pedicular screws on the postoperative CT.

Results: Among the 73 patients who underwent a CT-guided procedure (177 pedicular screws) the rate of incorrect screw position was 6.2% (11/117) with = 2 mm penetration of the cortical. Among the 15 patients who underwent a fluoroscopy-guided procedure (46 pedicular screws), the rate of incorrect screw position was 17% (8/46) again with = 2 mm penetration of the cortical. For scoliosis patients, the rate of erroneous screw insertion was 6% for CT navigation and 28% for fluoroscopic navigation. For fractures and degenerative instability, the rates were 6% and 11% respectively.

Discussion: The passive nature of the two navigation systems used do not induce any peroperative constraint on the surgeon. With the CT system, landmarks have to be collected peroperatively on the posterior arch of the operated vertebra, a step that is not needed for the fluoroscopic system. The two techniques appear to be reliable for insertion of pedicular screws. We did not have any neurological disorders in this series. It can be recalled that the conventional method produces a 15 to 40% rate of erroneous insertion. The CT system provides better results for all types of diseases; the improvement is about 6%.

Conclusion: With CT-navigation, a large portion of the per-operative radiographs are no longer necessary. Operative time is slightly longer than for the classical procedure due to the collection of the 3D information, particularly important for scoliosis. With the fluoroscopy system, no special preoperative imaging is required. Two or three peroperative radiographs are sufficient, limiting irradiation during insertion of the pedicular screws. The fluoroscopic system does not however provide 3D images.