The effectiveness of each one of the two procedures was evaluated on the basis of multiple objective characteristics like safety, total surgical duration, total blood loss, Constant Score, range of motion of the joints, post-surgical discomfort (pain, stiffness, motion, disability), post-surgical complications and ability of resumption of daily living activities.
Surgery was performed with the patients in the beach chair position and with a horizontal skin incision above the acromioclavicular joint. The length of the coracoacromial ligament was determinant to achieved reduction. The soft tissues were double breasted above the acromioclavicular joint. After surgery the limb was placed in a sling for 15 days and then complete mobilization exercises was began. Draft weight was avoided for 3 months.
The presence of a dislocation did not affect the final outcome. On the contrary the displacement of the tuberosities was decisive, and it was combined with greater scaring of the soft tissues and greater loss of motion. One patient developed transient palsy of the axillary nerve and another aseptic loosening of the prosthesis 7 years postoperatively.