Introduction. Video recording to teach and assess both technical and non-technical skills is well-established within medical education. Trainees’ clinical and practical competencies are evaluated using Procedure-Based Assessments (PBAs). However, there is limited research describing how these PBAs truly reflect trainee performance. We sought to:. 1). assess the duration between the procedure and PBA completion. 2). assess the perceived viability of supplementing assessments using intra-operative camera footage and. 3). clarify medico-legal considerations for the use of cameras in theatre. Method. We undertook a survey of Orthopaedic trainees in the East of England Deanery, United Kingdom. A six-item questionnaire was designed and provided to trainees (paper and online) to assess the time between procedure and filling in PBA forms, level of consultant input, time to PBA sign-off and trainees’ views on current PBA methods, operative video recording and retrospective access to clinical footage. Results. The survey response rate was 75%. 60% felt current PBAs do NOT allow them to highlight their strengths and weaknesses; a higher percentage felt retrospective access to a video recording would aid reflective practice (87.5%) and completion of PBAs (70%). 49% stated they did not complete their PBAs with their Consultant. Conclusion. This paper highlights potential limitations in existing forms of trainee assessment and feedback. We suggest use of trainees’ clinical footage to evaluate skills and performance, enhance feedback & learning in PBAs which has resonated well with trainees, the intended beneficiary. We also consider the medicolegal implications of cameras in operative training, with possible limitations to their adoption in current practice

Objective. Guidelines published by the British Association of Spine Surgeons (BASS) and Society of British Neurological Surgeons (SBNS) recommend urgent MRI imaging and intervention in individuals suspected of having CES. The need for an evidence based protocol is driven by a lack of 24/7 MRI services and centralisation of neurosurgery to tertiary centres, compounded by CES's significant medico-legal implications. We conducted an audit to evaluate the pathway for suspected CES in BCUHB West between 2018 and 2021. Methods. A retrospective audit of patients managed for suspected CES between 01/11/2018 and 01/05/2021 was performed, using the SBNS/BASS guidelines as the standard. Results. A total of 252 patients received an emergency MRI for suspected CES between 2018 and 2021. 99% of patients were scanned in compliance with SBNS/BASS standards. Radiological evidence of CES was found in 18% of patients. 33% of emergency scans were performed by out-of-hours services. 4% of patients had repeated scans within the same 6-month period. The majority of referrals originated from Orthopaedics surgeons (78%), or staff in the Emergency Department (8%). 92% of ambulatory patients were not admitted to hospital. During the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic, referrals increased from 2.5 to 3.5 per week. Conclusion. SBNS/BASS standards were largely met, avoiding life changing disability and medico-legal consequences. The department should continue to follow SBNS/BASS guidance on the management of individuals with suspected CES. Challenges regarding the use of repeated scans should be addressed to avoid unnecessary costs. Introduction of new early recognition guidelines and Same Day Emergency Care (SDEC) has likely driven an increase in suspected CES referrals, and subsequent MRI demand. This audit should be utilised as an ongoing tool to ensure best practice continues, and to implement simple measures which may improve compliance with the pathway

Two discrete legal factors enable the surgeon to treat an injured patient the fully informed, autonomous consent of the adult patient with capacity via civil law; and the medical exception to the criminal law. This article discusses current concepts in consent in trauma; and also considers the perhaps less well known medical exception to the Offences against the Person Act 1861, which exempts surgeons from criminal liability as long as they provide ‘proper medical treatment’.

Cite this article: Bone Jt Open 2024;5(7):565–569.

Aims

Occult (clinical) injuries represent 15% of all scaphoid fractures, posing significant challenges to the clinician. MRI has been suggested as the gold standard for diagnosis, but remains expensive, time-consuming, and is in high demand. Conventional management with immobilization and serial radiography typically results in multiple follow-up attendances to clinic, radiation exposure, and delays return to work. Suboptimal management can result in significant disability and, frequently, litigation.

Aims

We introduced a self-care pathway for minimally displaced distal radius fractures, which involved the patient being discharged from a Virtual Fracture Clinic (VFC) without a physical review and being provided with written instructions on how to remove their own cast or splint at home, plus advice on exercises and return to function.

Acute post-operative urinary retention (POUR) is a recognized complication following lower limb arthroplasty. Its occurrence may have patient and ultimately medico-legal implications. Identifying high-risk patients and the associated risk factors pre-operatively, is vital to tackle this issue and reduce its occurrence, which ultimately, may enhance the overall success of our operations. Our aim was to assess the incidence of POUR following elective lower limb arthroplasty and analyze the related factors that could potentially predict the likelihood of developing POUR in our patient cohort. A prospective audit of 158 patients was conducted in our department. POUR was defined as inability to pass urine voluntarily within the first 24 hours following elective lower limb arthroplasty leading to the insertion of a urinary catheter. Surgical-related factors including intra-operative fluid use, type of spinal anesthetic, duration of surgery, time from surgery till insertion of a urinary catheter as well as patient-related factors including medication, urological history and Body Mass index (BMI) was collected and analyzed. 21 (13.3%) patients developed post-operative urinary retention, 11 (52%) and 10 (48%) following knee and hip replacements respectively. Of which, 19 (90.5%) were male and 2 (9.5%) were female with an average age of 66 yrs. 13 (62%) had a previous urological history and 10 (48%) were on retention associated medication. Bupivacaine as a spinal anesthetic was associated with an increased risk of developing post-operative urinary retention. The average time till catheter insertion was 14 hrs. Only 2 (10%) had an unsuccessful TWOC on discharge. Bupivacaine as a spinal anesthetic and a previous urological history can be considered as risk factors for the development of POUR. Pre-operative urinary catheterization should be considered in this high-risk group of patients

The number of total knee arthroplasties continues to increase annually with over 90,000 total knee replacements performed in the United Kingdom in 2018. Multiple national bodies including the British Association for Surgery of the Knee (BASK) and the British Orthopaedic Association collaborated in July 2019 to produce best practice guidance for knee arthroplasty surgery. This study aims to review practice in a regional healthcare trust against these guidelines.

Fifty total knee replacement operation notes were reviewed between January and February 2020 from 11 different consultant orthopaedic surgeons. Documents were assessed against 17 criteria recommended by the BASK guidance. Personnel names and grades were generally well documented. Tourniquet time and pressure were documented in over 98% of operation notes however, protection from spirit burns was not documented at all. Trialling and soft tissue balancing was well recorded in 100% and 96% of operation notes respectively.

Areas lacking in documentation included methods utilised to optimise cementation technique and removal of cement debris. Protection of key knee structures was documented in only 56% of operation notes clearly. Prior to closure, final assessment of mechanism integrity, collateral ligament was not documented at all and final ROM after implantation of components was recorded 34% of the time.

Subsequently authors have created a universal operation note template, uploaded onto the patient electronic notes, which prompts surgeons to complete documentation of the relevant criteria advocated by BASK.

In conclusion, detailed and systematic documentation is vital to prevent adverse events and reduce the risk of litigation. By producing detailed operative templates this risk can be mitigated.

Background

Due to the overwhelming demand for trauma services, resulting from increasing emergency department attendances over the past decade, virtual fracture clinics (VFCs) have become the fashion to keep up with the demand and help comply with the BOA Standards for Trauma and Orthopaedics (BOAST) guidelines. In this article, we perform a systematic review asking, “How useful are VFCs?”, and what injuries and conditions can be treated safely and effectively, to help decrease patient face to face consultations. Our primary outcomes were patient satisfaction, clinical efficiency and cost analysis, and clinical outcomes.

The cost of clinical negligence in the UK has continued to rise despite no increase in claims numbers from 2016 to 2019. In the US, medical malpractice claim rates have fallen each year since 2001 and the payout rate has stabilized. In Germany, malpractice claim rates for spinal surgery fell yearly from 2012 to 2017, despite the number of spinal operations increasing. In Australia, public healthcare claim rates were largely static from 2008 to 2013, but private claims rose marginally. The cost of claims rose during the period. UK and Australian trends are therefore out of alignment with other international comparisons. Many of the claims in orthopaedics occur as a result of “failure to warn”, i.e. lack of adequately documented and appropriate consent. The UK and USA have similar rates (26% and 24% respectively), but in Germany the rate is 14% and in Australia only 2%. This paper considers the drivers for the increased cost of clinical negligence claims in the UK compared to the USA, Germany and Australia, from a spinal and orthopaedic point of view, with a focus on “failure to warn” and lack of compliance with the principles established in February 2015 in the Supreme Court in the case of Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board. The article provides a description of the prevailing medicolegal situation in the UK and also calculates, from publicly available data, the cost to the public purse of the failure to comply with the principles established. It shows that compliance with the Montgomery principles would have an immediate and lasting positive impact on the sums paid by NHS Resolution to settle negligence cases in a way that has already been established in the USA.

Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2020;102-B(5):550–555.

Aims

Informed patient consent is a legal prerequisite endorsed by multiple regulatory institutions including the Royal College of Surgeons and the General Medical Council. It is also recommended that the provision of written information is available and may take the form of a Patient Information Leaflet (PIL) with multiple PILs available from leading orthopaedic institutions. PILs may empower the patient, improve compliance, and improve the patient experience. The national reading age in the United Kingdom is less than 12 years and therefore PILs should be written at a readability level not exceeding 12 years old. We aim to assess the readability of PILs currently provided by United Kingdom orthopaedic institutions.

All skeletally immature patients who presented with a supracondylar fracture between 01/09/2013 and 24/11/2015 (n = 50) were used to compare the current management of supra-condylar fractures of the humerus in children to the standards set by the BOAST 11 guidelines. 8.1% did not have full documentation of their neurovascular assessment. 93.9% underwent surgery within 24 hours of presentation. Average time to theatre for neurovascularly compromised patients was 4 hours 46 minutes. 81.8% were managed with 2 K-wires as recommended. Only 39.4% of the patients had their wires removed within 3 – 4 weeks. Only 6.1% had the recommended 2 mm wires. AO recommends the use of 2mm wires if 2 lateral wires are used whereas the BOAST 11 guideline recommends 2mm wires where possible. The results clearly demonstrate a need for further education and awareness of the BOAST 11 guidelines. Of particular interest is the documentation of patients' neurovascular status for appropriate management and for medico-legal purposes. Long term outcome comparison of surgical fixation with 2mm and 1.6mm wires would be useful to support the use of 2mm wires as recommended by the professional consensus in the BOAST 11 guidelines

Aims

To determine whether the findings from a landmark Canadian trial assessing the optimal management of acute rupture of the Achilles tendon influenced the practice patterns of orthopaedic surgeons in Ontario, Canada.