Whiplash injury is surrounded by controversy in both the medical and legal world. The debate on whether it is either a potentially serious medical condition or a social problem is ongoing. This paper briefly examines a selection of studies on low velocity whiplash injury (LVWI) and whiplash associated disorder (WAD) and touches upon the pathophysiological and epidemiological considerations, cultural and geographical differences and the effect of litigation on chronicity. The study concludes that the evidence for significant physical injury after LVWI is poor, and if significant disability is present after such injury, it will have to be explained in terms of psychosocial factors

Background Non-weight bearing hip is a common problem in the elderly population after a minor fall. Magnetic reasonance imaging (MRI) is used to diagnose occult fractures in the hip and the pelvic ring in these individuals. The aim of this study is to find the relationship between the incidence of occult fractures in the hip and that in the pelvic ring following low velocity trauma in the elderly. Material and Methods Between January 2000 and February 2004, 106 elderly patients (mean age = 81.4 years; range = 67–101 years), underwent an MRI scan of the pelvis and hip to rule out fracture neck of femur. All of them presented with a non-weight bearing hip after a history of low velocity injury. All had standard radiographs of the pelvis and the hip which did not reveal a fracture of the femoral neck. However, eight patients had fracture of the pubic rami visible on plain radiographs. MRI scans were subsequently performed in all of them to rule out an occult fracture of the femoral neck. Results Out of the 106 patients, 17 (16%) had intracapsular neck of femur fracture, 26 (24.5%) had extracapsular neck of femur fracture, 26 (24.5%) had pubic rami fracture, 17 (16%) had sacral fractures, and 37 (34.9%) had no fractures. All the sacral fractures occurred in patients with pubic rami fractures. Further except in one patient where the pubic rami fracture and the sacral fracture were contralateral, the remaining 16 patients had ipsilateral pubic rami and sacral fractures. None of the patients with pelvic ring fracture had associated femoral neck fracture. Conclusion Inability to weight bear after a fall is a common presentation in the elderly population. Falls can lead to fracture neck of femur or a fracture of the pelvic ring but seldom both. We can also conclude that in an elderly patient with low velocity injury, if a pelvic ring fracture is detected in the plain radiograph there is no indication for further MRI to rule out femoral neck fracture. Further, the fracture in the anterior and posterior pelvic ring commonly involves the same side than the contralateral side, in the elderly after trivial trauma

The Quebec Task Force defined whiplash as “an acceleration–deceleration mechanism of energy transfer to the neck”. It is logical that the lower the velocity change following impact, the lower the risk of injury. The accepted velocity change (delta-v) for whiplash injuries following rear impact has been quoted as 5 mph. There is some debate as whether this is valid in the clinical setting. We aimed to investigate this further.

A series of low speed controlled crash simulations were undertaken. There were a total of 27 runs on 23 individuals. Accelerometers were placed on the head and chest of the volunteers. Video recordings were analysed to assess relative displacement of the head and chest. The presence of symptoms was documented over a period of 7 days. The volunteers consisted of 23 males and 1 female with an average age of 38 (range 20–56). The average delta-v achieved was 2.3 mph (range 1.8–3.1 mph). The average maximum accelerations recorded were 3.46g at the chest and 2.93g at the head. The average difference was 0.53g. There was no significant displacement between the head and body. No symptoms were reported beyond 1 hour.

Whiplash is triggered if the disparity between movements of the head and neck is of sufficient magnitude. It seems logical that there is a threshold below which whiplash will not occur. Our results have shown that below a delta-v of 3 mph there is little difference in the magnitude and timing of the movements of the head and chest.

Therefore the whiplash mechanism of injury does not occur at these changes of velocity.

Purpose of study:

The treatment goals in diaphyseal radius fractures are to regain and maintain length and rotational stability. Open reduction and plating remains the gold standard but carries the inherent problems of soft tissue disruption and periosteal stripping. Intramedullary nailing offers advantages of minimally invasive surgery and minimal soft tissue trauma. The purpose of this study is to describe the results of locked intramedullary nailing for adult gunshot diaphyseal radius fractures.

The most common injury in rugby resulting in spinal cord injury (SCI) is cervical facet dislocation. We report on the outcome of a series of 57 patients with acute SCI and facet dislocation sustained when playing rugby and treated by reduction between 1988 and 2000 in Conradie Hospital, Cape Town. A total of 32 patients were completely paralysed at the time of reduction. Of these 32, eight were reduced within four hours of injury and five of them made a full recovery. Of the remaining 24 who were reduced after four hours of injury, none made a full recovery and only one made a partial recovery that was useful. Our results suggest that low-velocity trauma causing SCI, such as might occur in a rugby accident, presents an opportunity for secondary prevention of permanent SCI. In these cases the permanent damage appears to result from secondary injury, rather than primary mechanical spinal cord damage. In common with other central nervous system injuries where ischaemia determines the outcome, the time from injury to reduction, and hence reperfusion, is probably important.

In order to prevent permanent neurological damage after rugby injuries, cervical facet dislocations should probably be reduced within four hours of injury.

The aims of this study was to determine the incidence of malnutrition in children with supracondylar fractures. It was hypothesised that the presence of malnutrition will increase the severity type of fractures. The study was a retrospective, cross-sectional study at a single institution. Children between 0 years and 12 years of age, who sustained documented supracondylar fracture treated surgically as a result of low velocity trauma were included in the study. Patients who sustained high velocity trauma, who had known bone disorders or had incomplete chart data, were excluded from the study Data was captured from children's’ notes who have been treated surgically for supracondylar fractures from casualty, theatre and the clinic notes. The nutritional status of children and fracture grade were identified and the two sets of data were compared against each other to try to identify a possible relation between fracture severity and malnutrition. Data was analysed in STATA and 5% level of significance was used to signify statistically significant associations. 150 patients were identified and included in the study. The majority of patients reviewed were in the normal nutritional range according to their z-scores. The severity of the fracture was not only associated with a poorer nutritional status however children with high and low z-scores (over weight as well as undernourished children) had the more severe fracture patterns, while children with normal z-scores had a fracture patterns of varying severity. Children who were malnourished were more likely to sustain more severe fracture types. The results highlighted the need for all children to have a good nutritional status as this may play a role in preventing more complex fractures

Aims. Cementless acetabular components rely on press-fit fixation for initial stability. In certain cases, initial stability is more difficult to obtain (such as during revision). No current study evaluates how a surgeon’s impaction technique (mallet mass, mallet velocity, and number of strikes) may affect component fixation. This study seeks to answer the following research questions: 1) how does impaction technique affect a) bone strain generation and deterioration (and hence implant stability) and b) seating in different density bones?; and 2) can an impaction technique be recommended to minimize risk of implant loosening while ensuring seating of the acetabular component?. Methods. A custom drop tower was used to simulate surgical strikes seating acetabular components into synthetic bone. Strike velocity and drop mass were varied. Synthetic bone strain was measured using strain gauges and stability was assessed via push-out tests. Polar gap was measured using optical trackers. Results. A phenomenon of strain deterioration was identified if an excessive number of strikes was used to seat a component. This effect was most pronounced in low-density bone at high strike velocities. Polar gap was reduced with increasing strike mass and velocity. Conclusion. A high mallet mass with low strike velocity resulted in satisfactory implant stability and polar gap, while minimizing the risk of losing stability due to over-striking. Extreme caution not to over-strike must be exercised when using high velocity strikes in low-density bone for any mallet mass. Cite this article: Bone Joint Res 2020;9(7):386–393

Introduction. The emergence of a new variant of subtrochanteric stress fractures of the femur affecting patients on oral bisphosphonate therapy has only recently been described. This fracture is often preceded by pain and distinctive radiographic changes, and associated with a characteristic fracture pattern. We undertook a review of this cohort of patients in our service. Method. A retrospective review was carried out looking for patients with subtrochanteric fractures who were taking oral bisphosphonates presenting with a low velocity injury over a two year period. Clinical data and radiographs were assessed. Results. 11 fractures were found in 10 patients matching the inclusion criteria outlined. All were female, and taking bisphosphonates for a mean of 4.3 years. 5 of the 10 patients described prodromal symptoms, for an average of 7.8 months before fracture. Although all fractures were deemed low velocity, 5 of 11 were atraumatic. 3 patients have had bilateral subtrochanteric fractures. Presence of the distinctive radiological ‘bleb’ was common. Surveillance on 2 patients shows lateral cortical blebs on the contralateral femur which merit close follow up. Conclusion. Patients taking oral bisphosphonate therapy may be at risk of a new variant of stress fracture of the proximal femur. Awareness of the symptoms is key to ensure appropriate investigations are undertaken. Following such a fracture surveillance of the contralateral femur is recommended, and the option of discontinuing bisphosphonates should be discussed

We describe a case of type-I Arnold-Chiari malformation in a 27-year-old woman who presented on two separate occasions with an apparent whiplash injury. She developed debilitating symptoms after two apparently low velocity vehicle collisions. MRI revealed a type-I Arnold-Chiari malformation. She was referred for consideration of neurosurgical decompression. Type-I Arnold-Chiari malformation is the downward herniation of the cerebellar tonsils through the foramen magnum. It is usually asymptomatic but may present after apparently insignificant trauma with a wide range of possible symptoms. The protean nature of its presentation and the similarity of the symptoms to those of a whiplash injury mean that it is easily overlooked. It is, however, important that it is detected early

Abstract Arm wrestling as both a formalised sport and recreational pastime has increased in popularity in recent years. It is not without risks. We report 3 cases that have recently presented at our hospital having sustained injuries to the distal humerus within the last year. We discuss their history, injuries sustained and subsequent treatment. We discuss the supposed mechanism of injuries and review the literature. When assessing patients in A/E, the history of arm wrestling should be taken seriously as it is important to realise that severe bone injury can occur. However this is a low velocity mechanism and responds well with non-operative management

This case presentation highlights the problem of thermal necrosis of the tibia following reaming, in a tibia with a narrow canal. A 2 year follow up of a 19 yr old aspiring dancer, who had a closed low velocity fracture to her midshaft left tibia. This was treated with intramedullary nailing of the tibia. Difficulty encountered while reaming of the canal at the time of operation because of the narrowness of the canal. She subsequently had a refracture of the shaft of the tibia, above the united fracture after the removal of the intramedullary nail. This happened in the narrow isthmic part of the tibia proximal to the fracture and was confirmed to have avascularity with isotope bone scan. This subsequently showed no appreciable sign of healing. Patient had renailing of the tibia with bone grafting and the fracture. Latest review shows the fracture to be consolidating. Surgeons have to be aware of the dangers of narrow canal in tibia before intramedullary nailing and appropriate reamers to be used if the canal is too narrow

Background. Fractures of the odontoid peg are one of the commonest cervical spinal injuries in the elderly population. In this population there is a higher risk of morbidity and mortality as a result of the injury. The magnitude of the mortality risk has not been quantified in the literature. Aim. To show a survivorship analysis in a cohort of elderly patients with odontoid peg fractures. Method & Materials. A 6-year retrospective analysis was performed on all patients >65 years old with isolated odontoid peg fracture. Kaplan-Meir curve was used to estimate survivorship from the date of fracture. Results. A total of 32 patients witha mean age of 82.1 years were analysed. There were 17 male and 15 female with an average follow-up of 20.4 months. A low velocity mechanical fall was the commonest cause for the injury in 93.7% of cases. 81% of cases were treated with rigid collar immobilsation. Overall, it was estimated that only 62.5 % would be alive by one year. The period of greatest mortality was within the first 12 weeks, a lesser contribution from then to one year, and had no impact on mortality thereafter. Multivariate logistic regression demonstrated that age (P= 0.02) was significant factor with an odds ratio of 1.2. There was no significant relationship among gender or treatment with the occurrence of an adverse event. Conclusion. We observed a 3 month and one year mortality rates of 255 and 37.5% respectively. Odontoid peg fractures in the elderly are not benign injuries and are a cause of high mortality rates within the first three months of the injury. Patients who survived to one year following the injury were observed to have their risk return to age and sex matched rates for this population

Background. Fractures of the odontoid peg are one of the commonest spinal injuries in the elderly population. In this population there is a higher risk of morbidity and mortality as a result of the injury. The magnitude of this risk has not been quantified in the literature. Aim. To show a survivorship analysis in a cohort of elderly patients with odontoid peg fractures. Method and Materials. A 6-year retrospective analysis was performed on all patients >65 years old admitted to a spinal unit with an isolated odontoid peg fracture. Actuarial (Life-Table) analysis was used to estimate survivorship from the date of fracture. Results. A total of 32 patients > 65 years of age with isolated odontoid peg fractures were identified. There were 17 male and 15 female. A low velocity mechanical fall was the commonest cause for the injury. The average age for the females was 86.7 years and for the males 78 years. The age distribution was unimodal in both sex, the greatest number occurring for the females in the 85-94 year age group and 75-84 years for the males. Overall, it was estimated that only 62.5 % would be alive by one year. The period of greatest mortality was within the first 12 weeks, a lesser contribution from then to one year, and had no impact on mortality thereafter. Males appeared to suffer a heavier mortality than females within the first year. At one year the male survival rate had fallen to 58.8% compared with a female rate of 66.6%. Conclusion. We observed that odontoid peg fractures in the elderly are not benign injuries and are a cause of high mortality rates within the first three months of the injury. Patients who survived to one year following the injury were observed to have their risk return to age and sex matched rates for this population

Introduction. Isolated trochlea fractures are very rare and have only been described previously as case reports. Aims. To report on a case of isolated trochlea fracture and to present a review of the literature. Results. There have only been four previous reports of isolated trochlea fracture. Our fifth case is included in the analysis of the literature given below. Average age 26 (Range 12–33). 60% female, 80% left sided. Dominance only stated in 40% of cases- 50% dominant side. Mechanism of injury: 60% low velocity fall onto an outstretched hand, 40% high velocity- RTA & fall off horse- exact mechanism of injury unknown. Patients all presented with elbow held in flexion, pain and swelling over the medial aspect and a painfully reduced range of motion. Diagnosis made on plain radiographs in 80%, tomograms required in 20%. AP noted to be essential to differentiate from more common capitellum fracture. 20% of fractures associated with comminution. Management consisted of open reduction through a medial approach and internal fixation in 80% (20% headless screw, 20% k-wire, 40% 4.0mm partially threaded cancellous screws) and olecranon traction in 20%. Elbows were immobilised from 3 to 8 weeks. Time to union ranged from 6 weeks (80%) to 13 weeks (20%). Outcomes were uniformly excellent with 40% being asymptomatic with a FROM, 20% asymptomatic with 10 degrees loss of extension and 40% asymptomatic with 5–20 degrees loss of flexion. There were no reported complications. Conclusion. These are rare injuries and can occur through high and low energy mechanisms. They tend to occur in younger age groups. Diagnosis can be made readily with plain radiographs- the AP is essential in differentiating it from the more common capitellum fracture. The prognosis for this intra-articular fracture is good to excellent

Aims

Post-traumatic periprosthetic acetabular fractures are rare but serious. Few studies carried out on small cohorts have reported them in the literature. The aim of this work is to describe the specific characteristics of post-traumatic periprosthetic acetabular fractures, and the outcome of their surgical treatment in terms of function and complications.

Objective: The purpose of this study is to evaluate the functional performance of patients who underwent to two different types of total knee prosthesis replacement (TKR). Methods: Kinematics and kinetics of the knee and ankle and electromyography activity of the lower limb muscles were obtained from 16 patients who underwent a TKR. 8 patients had received a fixed bearing prosthesis while the other 8 patients had received a mobile bearing prosthesis. The functional performance of the patients was evaluated using two tests, the gait and the squat. As control, 8 normal subjects, matched by age, were also evaluated. Results: During the stance phase of gait, patients with TKR showed a reduced knee extensor (internal) moment as compared to normal controls. During the squat test, patients with TKR exhibited a knee ROM that was reduced with respect to normal patients. Moreover, all patients with TKR showed a low velocity of execution of the both tests. There were no significant differences between patients who had received a fixed vs. mobile bearing prosthesis. Discussion: The results showed that after TKR, the functional performance of the patients is different from that of the normal subjects, regardless of the type of prosthesis implanted

Aim: To determine whether timing of intervention affects neurological outcome after spinal cord injury resulting from rugby cervical facet dislocations. Methods: An observational study on 57 rugby players who were admitted to a Spinal Cord Injuries Unit from 1988 to 2000 with cervical spine facet dislocations. Experienced medical officers, an orthopaedic specialist and physiotherapists determined the admission and discharge Frankel grades (A to E). The time was recorded from the actual injury to successful reduction in hours. The usual method of reduction was by Rapid Incremental Traction on an Awake Patient. Statistical analysis was performed using parametric and non-parametric tests (Mann Whitney). Results: 14 patients were treated within 4 hours of injury and 43 were treated after 4 hours. The median Frankel gain for patients reduced within 4 hours was 5 but only 2 for those reduced after 4 hours (p= 0.0002). Conclusion: Time from injury to intervention does significantly affect neurological outcome in a homogenous group of spinal cord injuries in fit young males as a result of low velocity trauma mechanisms. Spinal cord injuries secondary to cervical facet dislocations in these patients should be regarded as an absolute emergency

Royal Liverpool University Hospital, Liverpool, UK. To retrospectively review outcomes in patients who underwent vertebroplasty in Liverpool in response to recent level 1 publications claiming vertebroplasty to be no better than sham procedure assessed using 2 criteria. We reviewed cases between 2006 and 2009 looking at 5 criteria for procedure. Visual Analogue Score (VAS). Oswestry disability index scores (ODI). 96 patients identified. 10 patients excluded (inadequate data recorded) (n=86). Operated levels n=134 (thoracic n=61, lumbar n=71, sacral n=2). Presenting symptoms included back pain (86/86) and point tenderness was present in 90% (77/86). Average length of symptoms was 11.50 months with 28% reporting greater than 12 months. 72% recalled definite onset of symptoms with 90% being associated with a low velocity injury. Radiological findings showed an average of 54% height collapse and 91% showing high signal on STIR MRI sequences. Number of levels operated – 3 or more (n=9 VAS 5.3 ODI 10.6); 1 to 2 levels (n= 77 VAS 3.7 ODI 13.9). Average improvement in VAS score was 3.8.and ODI 13.6. 47% (40/86) of patients met all 5 current criteria recommended for operation (VAS 3.7, ODI 14). 53% (46/86) of patients met 2-5 criteria (VAS 3.8, ODI 13.4). There was improvement in pain scores in 91% of patients with an average pre-op VAS 7.8 and post-op VAS 4.0. There was no significant difference in patients meeting all 5 criteria compared to those meeting 2-5 criteria

This prospective evaluation of early experience using this technique. Patients with fracture of the distal clavicle were surgically treated with clavicular hook plate fixation. They were reviewed clinically and radiographically by one observer. 12 patients, 7 male, 5 female, were treated in our unit. Mean age (34.7) range 25–60 years. 10 were the results of low velocity injury. 9 were treated within one week of injury. 3 were treated at 13, 14 and 16 weeks post injury. Mean hospital stay 2.7 range 2–5 days. All patients healed, 10 within 12 weeks. All resumed full activity by 24 weeks. 2 had superficial wound infection, treated successfully with oral antibiotics without implant removal. One had a seroma, which resolved spontaneously. One patient developed limitation of movement at 20 weeks ultrasound confirmed impingement. Plate was removed and patient regained full range of movement after six weeks. No implant fracture or loosening was observed. Based on experience to date the clavicular hook plate is a safe and reliable method of fixation. Relatively simple implant with good results. Allows early mobilisation and has little complication

Purpose: Traumatic knee dislocations are complex injuries. A thorough knowledge of the pattern of ligament damage is essential to plan for definitive treatment. Injuries to the structures of the posteromedial corner (posterior oblique ligament, the semi-membranosus tendon and its expansions, the meniscofemoral and meniscotibial ligaments, posterior horn of the medial meniscus and posterior reflections of the deep and superficial medial collateral ligament) can contribute to rotational laxity and have not been previously described in the setting of knee dislocations. We set out to evaluate the injury patterns of the posteromedial corner in a series of traumatic knee dislocations. Method: A radiographic (MRI) study was conducted on 22 multi-ligament knee injuries in 22 patients, managed at a level one trauma centre by a single surgeon between July 2006 and May 2008. Results: There were 14 male and 6 female patients with an average age of 29. The mechanism of injury was high velocity in 10 cases, and low velocity in 12 cases. One case (ACL/PCL/posterolateral corner injury) was associated with a vascular injury. While the incidence of MCL injury was 59%, injury specific to the PMC was evident on MRI in 81.8% (18/22) of cases. The deep and superficial MCL were involved in 13/18 and 12/18 PMC injuries, respectively. The posterior oblique ligament was injured in 11/18 cases and the semi-membranosus and its expansions were injured in 10/18 cases (all distal). Injuries to the posterior horn of the medial meniscus (9/18 cases) were associated with a tear of the menisco-femoral/meniscotibial ligaments in all cases. Conclusion: Injury to the PMC was common with high-grade multi-ligament knee injuries in this series. PMC injuries were more common than MCL injuries alone. Injury to the posterior horn of the medial meniscus was predictive of more extensive PMC injury in all cases. The posteromedial corner of the knee is an under recognized area where important injuries can occur in the setting of a dislocatable knee. Future research will involve the correlation of the injury patterns described in this series to clinical measures of knee instability and laxity