Aims. The COVID-19 pandemic presents an unprecedented burden on global healthcare systems, and existing infrastructures must adapt and evolve to meet the challenge. With health systems reliant on the health of their workforce, the importance of protection against disease transmission in healthcare workers (HCWs) is clear. This study collated responses from several countries, provided by clinicians familiar with practice in each location, to identify areas of best practice and policy so as to build consensus of those measures that might reduce the risk of transmission of COVID-19 to HCWs at work. Methods. A cross-sectional descriptive survey was designed with ten open and closed questions and sent to a representative sample. The sample was selected on a convenience basis of 27 senior surgeons, members of an international surgical society, who were all frontline workers in the COVID-19 pandemic. This study was reported according to the Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research (SRQR) checklist. Results. Responses were received by all 27 surgeons from 22 countries across six continents. A number of the study respondents reported COVID-19-related infection and mortality in HCWs in their countries. Differing areas of practice and policy were identified and organized into themes including the specification of units receiving COVID-19 patients, availability and usage of personal protective equipment (PPE), other measures to reduce staff exposure, and communicating with and supporting HCWs. Areas more specific to surgery also identified some variation in practice and policy in relation to visitors to the hospital, the outpatient department, and in the operating room for both non-urgent and emergency care. Conclusion. COVID-19 presents a disproportionate risk to HCWs, potentially resulting in a diminished health system capacity, and consequently an impairment to population health. Implementation of these recommendations at an international level could provide a framework to reduce this burden

In treating open long bone fractures our current policy includes early administration of intravenous antibiotics and surgery on a scheduled trauma list. We have reviewed our infection rates 6 years following the initiation of this policy. 220 fractures were studied. Our records included time of administration of antibiotics, time to theatre and seniority of surgeon. We identified cases of superficial or deep infection. Surgical debridement occurred within 6 hours of injury in 45% of cases and after 6 hours in 55%. Overall infection rates were 11% and 15.7% respectively. Intravenous antibiotics were administered within 3 hours of injury in 80% of cases and after 3 hours in 20% of cases. Overall infection rates were 14% and 12.5% respectively. Infection rates where the most senior surgeon present was a consultant were 9.5% compared to 16% with the consultant absent. Our results suggest that the change in policy may have contributed to an improvement of the deep infection rate to 4.3% from the previous figure of 8.5%, although this decrease was not statistically significant. Time to theatre has not adversely affected the infection rate, and presence of a senior surgeon may have improved infection rates, although both trends were not statistically significant

Despite a lack of evidence, the UK's Department of Health introduced a policy of ‘Bare below the elbows’ attire to try to reduce the incidence of nosocomial infection. This study investigates the link between attire and hand contamination. A prospective observational study of doctors working in a District General Hospital was performed. The fingertips were imprinted on culture medium, and the resulting growth assessed for number of colony forming units, presence of clinically significant pathogens and multiply resistant organisms. These findings were correlated with attire, grade, gender and specialty. 92 doctors were recruited of which 49 were ‘Bare below the elbows’ compliant and 43 were not. There was no statistically significant difference between those doctors who were ‘bare below the elbows’ and those that were not for either the number of colony forming units (p=1.0), or the presence of significant organisms (p=0.77). No multiply resistant organisms were cultured from doctors' hands. ‘Bare below the elbows’ attire is not related to the degree of contamination on doctors' fingertips or the presence of clinically significant pathogens. Further studies are required to establish whether investment in doctor's uniforms and patient education campaigns are worthwhile

Although wait-times for hip fracture surgery have been linked to mortality and are being used as quality-of-care indicators worldwide, controversy exists about the duration of the wait that leads to complications. Our objective was to use new population-based wait-time data to emprically derive an optimal time window in which to conduct hip fracture surgery before the risk of complications increases.

We used health administrative data from Ontario, Canada to identify hip fracture patients between 2009 and 2014. The main exposure was the time from hospital arrival to surgery (in hours). The primary outcome was mortality within 30 days. Secondary outcomes included a composite of mortality or other medical complications (MI, DVT, PE, and pneumonia) also within 30 days. Risk-adjusted cubic splines modeled the probability of each complication according to wait-time. The inflection point (in hours) when complications began to increase was used to define ‘early’ and ‘delayed’ surgery. To evaluate the robustness of this definition, outcomes amongst propensity-score matched early and delayed patients were compared using percent absolute risk differences (% ARDs, with 95% confidence intervals [CIs]).

There were 42,230 patients who met entry criteria. Their mean age was 80.1 (±10.7) and the majority were female (70.5%). The risk of complications modeled by cubic splines consistently increased when wait-times were greater than 24 hours, irrespective of the complication considered. Compared to 13,731 propensity-score matched patients who received surgery earlier, 13,731 patients receiving surgery after 24 hours had a significantly higher risk of 30-day mortality (N=898 versus N=790, % ARD 0.79 [95% CI 0.23 to 1.35], p = .006) and the composite outcome (N=1,680 versus N=1,383, % ARD 2.16 [95% CI 1.43 to 2.89], p < .001). Overall, there were 14,174 patients (33.6%) who received surgery within 24 hours and 28,056 patients (66.4%) who received surgery after 24 hours.

Increased wait-time was associated with a greater risk for 30-day mortality and other complications. The finding that a wait-time of 24 hours represents a threshold defining higher risk may inform existing hip fracture guidelines. Since two-thirds of patients did not receive surgery within this timeframe, performance improvement efforts that reduce wait-times are warranted.

Oxford hip and knee scores are being used by many heath care commissioners to determine whether individual patients are eligible for joint replacement surgery. Oxford scores were not designed for use in deciding whether patients are suitable for surgery and they are not validated as a triage tool. The aim of this study was to assess what effect these predetermined threshold Oxford Scores would have on a contemporary patient cohort.

An analysis was undertaken of 4254 pre-operative Oxford scores in patients who had already undergone either hip resurfacing, a total hip, total knee or unicompartmental knee replacement surgery at our institution between 2008 and 2011. We assessed how these scores would affect the decision making pathway determining which patients would be eligible for joint replacement surgery. We also evaluated the effects this would have on patients undergoing surgery in terms of gender, sex, age and type of arthroplasty.

22.4% hip resurfacings, 10.0% of total hip replacements, 7.5% total knee replacements and 11.0% unicompartmental knee replacements would have been declined on the Oxford Scores system. The selection criteria as set by the health care commissioners was found to be ageist as there was a bias against older patients obtaining surgery. There was a bias against different forms of arthroplasty, particularly those patients suitable for resurfacing or unicompartmental knee replacement. It was also sexist as it selectively excluded male patients from surgery.

Rather than using pre-operative Oxford scores to discern which patients are eligible for surgery, evaluation of patient factors which are reported to adversely affect the outcome of hip and knee replacement surgery, may offer a better solution to improving quality of care. Oxford scores are undertaken to benchmark a providers performance and not to decide on an individual's suitability for surgery.

Long waiting times and a growing demand on services for joint replacement surgery (JRS) prompted the Victorian Department of Human Services to fund a University of Melbourne/Melbourne Health partnership to develop and implement an osteoarthritis (OA) hip and knee service delivery and prioritisation system for those who may require JRS.

The service delivery model consists of a multidisciplinary team providing, comprehensive early assessment, evidence-based interventions, including support for patient self-management, continuity of care processes, and prioritisation for both surgical assessment and JRS. Prioritisation occurs via clinical assessment and the Hip and Knee Multi-Attribute Prioritisation Tool (MAPT), a patient, clinician, or proxy-administered 11-item questionnaire, resulting in a 100-point scale ranking of need for surgery. The Hip and Knee MAPT was developed using intensive consultation with surgeons, state-of-the-art clinimetrics and with input from patients, hospital management groups. Ninety-six surgeons contributed to the developing the final scoring system.

Over 4000 patients per year are entering the system across 14 hospitals in Victoria. Under the supervision of the orthopaedics unit, musculoskeletal coordinator (MSC), typically an experienced physiotherapist or nurse, as part of the multidisciplinary team, undertakes early comprehensive assessment, referral and prioritisation of patients with hip or knee OA referred to orthopaedic outpatient clinics. In addition, the MSC coordinates the monitoring and management of patients on the orthopaedic surgery waiting list. The processes enable patients who are most needy (via higher MAPT score and clinical assessment) to be fast-tracked to orthopaedic surgery; conversely those patients with lower scores receive prompt conservative management.

Time to first assessment and waiting times to see a surgeon for many patients have reduced from 12+ months to weeks. Patients seen by surgeons are more likely to be ready for surgery and have had more comprehensive non-operative optimisation. Patients placed on the surgical waiting list receive quarterly reassessments and evidence of deterioration is used as a basis for fast-tracking to surgery.

The OWL system is a whole of system(tm) approach informed by patients needs and surgeons needs. Clinicians have developed confidence in the clinical relevance of the MAPT scores. Uptake of the OWL model of care has been very high because it facilitates better care and better patient outcomes.

Instant messaging via WhatsApp is used within hospital teams. Group messaging can lead to efficient and non-hierarchical communication. Despite being end-to-end encrypted, WhatsApp is owned by Facebook, raising concerns regarding data security. The aims of this study were: 1) to record the prevalence of WhatsApp group instant messaging amongst clinical teams; 2) to ascertain clinician attitudes towards use of instant messaging, 3) to gauge clinicians’ awareness of best practice regarding mobile data protection and 4) to create a practical guideline based off available literature that can be used to by clinicians to improve data security practice. Over a two-week period, clinical nurse specialists in the Auckland District Health Board Department of Orthopaedics retrospectively completed a blind audit of all messaging activity across the five teams WhatsApp group message threads, recording quantity of messages sent and the nature of the messages. Concurrently individuals in these WhatsApp groups completed an anonymous survey of their use of WhatsApp and their awareness of local data security policies and practice. A guideline adapted from available literature was created to compare current practice to recommended standards and subsequently adopted into local policy. 1360 messages were sent via WhatsApp in a two-week period. 384 (28%) of the messages contained patient identifiable data. Thirty-six photos were shared. Participants rated use of WhatsApp at 9.1/10 – extremely beneficial. Sixty-five per cent of clinicians reported they had not read or were unaware of the ADHB policies regarding mobile devices and information privacy and security. WhatsApp use is widespread within the Orthopaedic department and is the preferred platform of communication with many perceived benefits. Data security is a risk and implementation of an appropriate guideline to assist clinicians in achieving best practice is crucial to ensure patient data remains protected

Escalating health care expenditure worldwide is driving the need for effective resource decision-making, with medical practitioners increasingly making complex resource decisions within the context of patient care. Despite raising serious legal and ethical issues in practice, this has attracted little attention in Australia, or internationally. In particular, it is unknown how orthopaedic surgeons perceive their obligations to the individual patient, and the wider community, when rationing care, and how they reconcile competing obligations. This research explores legal and ethical considerations, and resource allocation by Australian orthopaedic surgeons, as a means of achieving public health cost containment driven by macro-level policy and funding decisions. This research found that Australian orthopaedic surgeon's perceptions, and resource allocation decision making, can be explained by understanding how principles of distributive justice challenge, and shift, the traditional medical paradigm. It found that distributive justice, and challenges of macro level health policy and funding decisions, have given rise to two new medical paradigms. Each which try to balance the best interests of individual patients with demands in respect of the sustainability of the health system, in a situation where resources may be constrained. This research shows that while bedside rationing has positioned the medical profession as the gate keepers of resources, it may have left them straddling an increasingly irreconcilable void between the interests of the individual patient and the wider community, with the sustainability of the health system hanging in the balance

Musculoskeletal (MSK) injuries are one of the leading causes of disability worldwide. Despite improvements in trauma-related morbidity and mortality in high-income countries over recent years, outcomes following MSK injuries in low and middle-income countries, such as South Africa (SA), have not. Despite governmental recognition that this is required, funding and research into this significant health burden are limited within SA. This study aims to identify research priorities within MSK trauma care using a consensus-based approach amongst MSK health care practitioners within SA. Members from the Orthopaedic Research Collaborative (ORCA), based in SA, collaborated using a two round modified Delphi technique to form a consensus on research priorities within orthopaedic trauma care. Members involved in the process were orthopaedic healthcare practitioners within SA. Participants from the ORCA network, working within SA, scored research priorities across two Delphi rounds from low to high priority. We have published the overall top 10 research priorities for this Delphi process. Questions were focused on two broad groups - clinical effectiveness in trauma care and general trauma public health care. Both groups were represented by the top two priorities, with the highest ranked question regarding the overall impact of trauma in SA and the second regarding the clinical treatment of open fractures. This study has defined research priorities within orthopaedic trauma in South Africa. Our vision is that by establishing consensus on these research priorities, policy and research funding will be directed into these areas. This should ultimately improve musculoskeletal trauma care across South Africa and its significant health and socioeconomic impacts

The Victorian state government introduced a trial electronic scooter sharing scheme on 1. st. February 2022 in inner city Melbourne. Despite epidemiological data from other jurisdictions that show these devices are associated with significant trauma. This is a descriptive study from the largest trauma centre in Victoria demonstrating the “scope of the problem” after introduction of this government-approved, ride sharing scheme. Retrospective case series. Our hospital orthopaedic department database was searched from 1/1/2021 to 30/6/22 to identify all presentations associated with electronic scooter trauma, the mechanism of injury and admission information was confirmed via chart review. Data collected included: mode of arrival, alcohol/drug involvement, hospital LOS, injury severity score, ICU admission, list of injuries, operations undertaken, surgical procedures, discharge destination, death. In the 12 months prior to and 5 months since introduction of the ride share scheme, 43 patients were identified. 18 patients (42% of our cohort) presented in the 5 months since ride sharing was introduced, and 25 patients in the preceding 12 months. 58% were found to be alcohol or drug affected. All patients were admitted to hospital, 14% of which included ICU admission. 44% were polytrauma admissions. Median hospital length of stay was 2 days. The longest individual hospital stay was 69 days. No patients in this series died. There were 49 surgical procedures in 35 patients including neurosurgical, plastics and maxillofacial operations. Mean Injury Severity Score was 10. Despite data demonstrating their danger in other jurisdictions, the Victorian state government approved a trial of an electronic scooter ride share scheme in inner Melbourne in February 2022. These devices are associated with a significant trauma burden and the rate has increased since the introduction of the ride-sharing scheme. This data may be combined with other hospital data and could be used to inform policy makers

Objectives. As per NICE guidance, one of the cornerstones of management of AKI is risk assessment. Aim of the audit is to identify the potential risk factors for postoperative AKI in hip fracture patients. Design and Methods. Using local NOF registration data, Patient details were selected using inclusion and exclusion criteria. Electronic records of patients were assessed retrospectively including blood results, radiological investigations, clinical documentation and drug chart. Inclusion Criteria: All patients > 50 years old with NOF fractures underwent operative management from January 2022 to June 2022 Exclusion Criteria: 1- Pathological fractures. 2- Non-operative management. 3- Died directly postoperative. Results. 250 patients underwent hip fracture surgery at our hospital in 6 months (January 2022-June 2022) (Cemented Procedures were 133 (53 %) while Fixation procedures were 117 (47%)). Female patients were 174 (70%), and male were 76 patients. Average age was 83.4 years and number of operations done over Weekend (Friday-Sunday) = 123 (49%). The incidence of Postoperative AKI was 56 (22.4%). Forty-five from fifty-six cases were stage 1 (80.4%) while 7 cases (12.5%) were stage 2. The studied risk factors for Postoperative AKI were: cemented procedures (61% of postoperative AKI incidence), female Gender (66%), time from admission to operation (>24 hours =33 %), day of operation (operations done Friday/Saturday/Sunday = 55%) and Postoperative antibiotics (71%). Conclusion. We need strategies to reduce incidence of postoperative AKI like: AKI alert on laboratory results, IV fluid prescription preoperative since arrival of patients to ED, avoid/stop nephrotoxic medications on admission, regular review of postoperative U&Es and fluid balance especially in high-risk patients, increase nursing staff and junior doctors on wards over weekends and we need to review our policy of giving postoperative IV antibiotics

Supracondylar fractures of the humerus (SCH) are the most common fractures sustained following a fall among children. The majority of these fractures are mild, but the most severe injury types can result in a disruption to the nerves and blood supply resulting in limb threatening injuries and potential life-long disability. Better understanding of mechanisms of injury and child-related factors that influence injury, especially for severe cases, is crucial to identifying best practices and informing policy. We aim to stratify fractures and examine the associated mechanisms and circumstances of injury to identify best practices and inform supportive policy. In doing so, we plan to investigate why some children sustain more severe fractures than others by exploring mechanisms and locations of injury, and risk-taking behaviours. A prospective, mixed-methods pilot study employing a child-led research design. Our approach links narratives from qualitative photo elicitation interviews (PEI) to mapped images of the locations of injury using geotagged photographs children have taken themselves, complications and injury outcomes, and an assessment of overall risk-taking tendencies. Participants aged six-12, with the help of their photographs, were able to lay out the events leading up to, including, and following their injury. Much of this information was either not included in their medical charts or was markedly different. Themes included not being able to prevent the injury and being adventurous, as well as becoming more cautious afterwards. These can have applications to the necessity of exploration as well as possibilities to prevent injury or not. Thus, the in-depth, first-person retelling of injury mechanism illustrated the need for mechanistic data and statistics beyond injury location alone. Risk-taking behaviours, as scored by the Sensation Seeking Scale for Children, correlated to injury severity, which is known to be associated with poorer outcomes and long-lasting complications. PEI of children sustaining SCH fractures in Vancouver reveals mechanisms of injury beyond those previously reported in literature and suggest the feasibility of a large-scale study. PEI in this age group allows for clarifications and a clearer picture of injury mechanism as well as context of injury. These aspects significantly affect our ability to determine the relationship between injury mechanism and injury severity. Mixed-methods analysis of child-directed data as well as quantitative injury demographics reveals unique translational knowledge which can be shared with clinicians, patients/care-givers, community-based health teams, and local policy makers to make timely and impactful improvements in injury prevention, clinical practice, and play structure safety

Timely and competent treatment of paediatric fractures is paramount to a healthy future working population. Anecdotal evidence suggests that children travel greater distances to obtain care compared to adults causing economic and geographic inequities. This study aims to qualify the informal regionalization of children's fracture care in Ontario. The results could inform future policy on resource distribution and planning of the provincial health care system. A retrospective cohort study was conducted examining two of the most common paediatric orthopaedic traumatic injuries, femoral shaft and supracondylar humerus fractures (SCH), in parallel over the last 10 years (2010-2020) using multiple linked administrative databases housed at the Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences (ICES) in Toronto, Ontario. We compared the distance travelled by these pediatric cohorts to clinically equivalent adult fracture patterns (distal radius fracture (DR) and femoral shaft fracture). Patient cohorts were identified based on treatment codes and distances were calculated from a centroid of patient home forward sortation area to hospital location. Demographics, hospital type, and closest hospital to patient were also recorded. For common upper extremity fracture care, 84% of children underwent surgery at specialized centers which required significant travel (44km). Conversely, 67% of adults were treated locally, travelling a mean of 23km. Similarly, two-thirds of adult femoral shaft fractures were treated locally (mean travel distance of 30km) while most children (84%) with femoral shaft fractures travelled an average of 63km to specialized centers. Children who live in rural areas travel on average 51km more than their adult rural-residing counterparts for all fracture care. Four institutions provide over 75% of the fracture care for children, whereas 22 institutions distribute the same case volume in adults.?. Adult fracture care naturally self-organizes with proportionate distribution without policy-directed systemization. There is an unplanned concentration of pediatric fracture care to specialized centers in Ontario placing undue burden on pediatric patients and inadvertently stresses the surgical resources in a small handful of hospitals. In contrast, adult fracture care naturally self-organizes with proportionate distribution without policy-directed systemization. Patient care equity and appropriate resource allocation cannot be achieved without appropriate systemization of pediatric fracture care

In 2011 health policy dictated a reduction in iatrogenic infections, such as Clostridium difficile (C. diff), this resulted in local change to antimicrobial policy in orthopaedic surgery. Previous antimicrobial policy was Cefuroxime, this was changed to Flucloxacillin and Gentimicin. Following this change an increased number of patients appeared to suffer from acute kidney injury (AKI). We initially evaluated the incidence of AKI pre and post antibiotic change and found a correlation between the Flucloxacillin and AKI. We then made changes to antibiotic policy to mitigate the increased rates of AKI and proceeded to evaluate the outcomes. In this prospective study all patients admitted with fracture neck of femurs were identified from the National Hip Fracture database and data obtained. The degree of AKI was classified according to the validated RIFILE criteria. Evaluation showed a 4 fold decrease, from 13% to only 3%, in AKI after introduction of the modified antibiotic policy. C.difficile continues to be non-existent since this change. Flucloxacillin obviously had a significant impact on this patient group. However, we have shown that with appropriate changes to antibiotic policy AKI associated morbidity can be significantly reduced. Dose dependent antibiotics will now be given based on weight and eGFR

Abstract. Non-operative management of AIS can present practical and psychological challenges, as effective bracing requires a considerable investment of time in adolescence which is a formative point of physical and emotional development. The management team lacks input from the psychological team and thus, it would be prudent for the spinal teams to appreciate and deal with the psychosocial effects associated with bracing. We sought to investigate how bracing as a part of non-operative management of idiopathic scoliosis, is perceived among adolescents. We performed a search of CINAHL, Medline, AMED, PsychARTICLES, Psychology and Behavioral Sciences Collection and PsychINFO databases to identify qualitative research investigating the thoughts, feelings and experiences and attitudes of those undergoing bracing for AIS. Keywords used were (((“adoles∗” OR “young pe∗”) AND “idiopathic scoliosis”) AND “brac∗”) AND (“perce∗” OR “experience∗” OR “perspective∗” OR “attitude∗”). Ten research articles were identified using our search strategy. Only one article addressed our research question specifically. This reported that almost all adolescent patients experienced psychological difficulties during treatment and received most of their support from family and friends rather than health professionals. Our interpretation of the literature on this subject has yielded three recommendations for service providers. First, the policy ought to change to ensure that psycholological support is engrained within the treatment process; second, more information and advice must be given to patients and their families; and third, health professionals should appreciate and directly address in their consultations the psychological difficulties involved in brace wearing and the need for adequate support

Abstract. Introduction. Clinic letters to the general practitioner (GP) form an essential part of communication in a patient's care. One essential variable requiring 100% compliance is the laterality/side of the diagnosis. Rationale of this audit was to check compliance of the same in clinic letters, to implement changes within the department initially followed by trust wide change in policy to improve the same. Material and Methods. Clinic letters over a period of time were read through in retrospect to see for mention of side. The exclusion criteria were COVID consenting letters over phone, “did not attend” letters and letters for spinal pathology. After 1st limb of audit following actions were taken: doctor education, secretaries to remind the dictating doctor to mention side in the letter and putting up of laminated prompters in all T&O clinic rooms to remind doctors. Following this a 2nd limb was conducted with similar parameters. Results. 1st Limb:. Total letters 271: Fracture clinic- 126. Elective/orthopaedic clinic – 106. Excluded letters– 39. 2nd Limb:. Total letters 169: Fracture clinic- 91. Elective/orthopaedic clinic – 62. Excluded letters– 16. Letters without the mention of side of diagnosis. 1st Limb: Fracture clinic – 28 out of 126 (22.3%). Orthopaedic clinic – 12 out of 106 (11.3%). 2nd Limb: Fracture clinic – 2 out of 91 (2.2%). Orthopaedic clinic – 2 out of 62 (3.2%). Conclusion. With the changes there was an overall compliance of 97.8% in fracture clinic and 96.8% compliance elective clinic dictations

Spine surgery is common and costly. Researchers and policy makers believe that utilization of spine surgery in the US is significantly higher than in other industrialized countries. Although within-country variation in spine surgery utilization is well studied, there has been little exploration of variation in spine surgery between countries. We used population level administrative data from Ontario (years 2011–2015) and New York (2011–2014) to identify all adults who underwent inpatient spinal decompression or fusion surgery. We compared Ontario and New York with respect to patient demographics and the percentage of hospitals performing spine surgery. We compared rates of decompression and fusion surgery (procedures per-10,000 population per-year) in Ontario and New York for all procedures, emergent procedures alone, and elective procedures and after stratifying by patient age. Patients in Ontario were older than patients in New York for decompression (mean age 58.8 vs. 51.3 years, P<.001) and fusion (58.1 vs. 54.9, P<.001). A smaller percentage of hospitals in Ontario performed decompression or fusion compared to New York (decompression, 26.1% in Ontario vs 54.9% in New York: fusion 15.2% vs 56.7%, both P<.001). Overall, utilization of spine surgery in Ontario was 6.6 procedures per-10,000 population per-year and in New York was 18 per-10,000 per-year (P<.001). Ontario-New York differences in utilization were small for emergent cases (2 per-10,000 in Ontario vs. 2.8 in New York, P<.001), but large for elective cases (4.6 vs 15.2, P<.001). In analyses stratified by surgical subtype, differences in utilization of decompression in New York and Ontario were relatively modest (2.4 vs 3.1, P<.001), while utilization of fusion was approximately 400% higher in New York than Ontario (15.7 vs 3.5, P<.001). Further analysis demonstrated that the New York-Ontario difference in utilization was substantially larger among younger patients and smaller for older patients. For example, utilization of spine procedures in New York was 340% greater than Ontario for patients less-than 50 years of age (11.7 vs 3.4), but only 25% greater in patients age 80 and above (10 vs 12.6). After adjusting for patient demographics, hospital LOS and surgical urgency, differences in mortality in Ontario and New York were not significant for either decompression or fusion. In adjusted analyses differences in hospital LOS were slightly greater for decompression in Ontario, but similar for fusion and readmission rates in Ontario were significantly lower than in New York. In conclusion, we found significantly lower utilization of spine surgery in Ontario when compared to New York. The difference in utilization was attributable to less elective fusion surgery, primarily in younger (i.e. non-Medicare) patients. These findings can serve inform broader spine surgery policy reforms in both jurisdictions

There is a lack of evidence as to the best way to deliver rehabilitation following TKA. Previous work has suggested that postoperative physiotherapy applied to all patients is not effective at improving one-year post-surgical outcomes. The aim of this study was to target physiotherapy to those at risk of poor outcome following TKA, and to determine if a therapist-led intervention offered superior results compared to a home-exercise based protocol in this ‘at risk’ group. The Targeted Rehabilitation to Improve Outcomes (TRIO) study was a prospective randomised controlled trial run at 15-centres in the UK. Patients were identified as ‘potential poor outcome’ based on an Oxford Knee Score (OKS) classification at 6-weeks post-surgery and randomised to either therapist-led or home-exercise based protocols. Patients were reviewed by a physiotherapist and commenced 18-exercise sessions over 6-weeks. The therapist-led group undertook a progressive functional protocol (modified weekly in 1-1 contact sessions) in contrast to the static home-exercise based regime. Evaluation took place following rehabilitation intervention, then at 6-months and 1-year post-surgery. Primary outcome was comparative group OKS at 1-year. Secondary outcomes included, ‘worst’ and ‘average’ pain scores, OXS and EQ-5D, and satisfaction questionnaire. Health economic (cost-utility) analysis was undertaken from NHS perspective up to 1-year post-surgery. Incremental cost per Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs) were calculated from intervention costs, patient reported primary and secondary care usage, and EQ-5D data. 4264 patients were screened, 1296 were eligible, 334 patients were randomised, 8 were lost to follow-up, therapy compliance was >85%. Clinically meaningful improvement in OKS (between baseline and 1-year) was seen in both arms (p < 0 .001). Between group difference in 1-year OKS was 1.91 (95%CI, −0.17–3.99) points favouring the therapist-led arm (p=0.07). Incorporating all time point data, between group difference in OKS was 2.25 points (95%CI, 0.61–3.90, p=0.008). Small, non-significant reductions (< 5 %) in both worst and average pain scores were observed favouring the therapist-led group. Enhanced satisfaction with pain relief (OR 1.65, p < 0 .02), ability to perform daily functional tasks (OR 1.66, p < 0 .02), and perform heavy functional tasks (OR 1.6, p=0.04) was reported in the therapist-led group. There was a small non-significant difference of 0.02 points (95%CI −0.02–0.06) between groups in EQ-5D, resulting in a £12,125 cost per QALY of delivering the therapist led intervention with a 57% chance of being cost-effective at the standard UK policy threshold of £20,000 per QALY. TRIO is the largest randomised trial of physiotherapy following TKA, and the first to target rehabilitation to patients at risk of poor outcomes. Both therapist-led and home-exercise based rehabilitation groups made clinically meaningful improvements in outcome by 1-year. We observed a modest difference in OKS in favour of therapist-led rehabilitation compared to the home-exercises which was not statistically significant. The relatively tight confidence intervals suggests that any difference which might exist is too small to be clinically relevant. Patient satisfaction with outcome was however higher in those that received greater physiotherapist contact. While cost per QALY estimates were below UK policy threshold, this result is uncertain and insufficient to make accept-decline recommendations

Background. In October 2008, CMS instituted a new “No payment for preventable complications“ programme and has released a list of conditions for which it intends to expand the programme in 2009. Although not reimbursing for preventable complications is justifiable, some of the proposed target conditions are lacking in both adequate diagnostic testing accuracy and preventability. Aims. This study examines the effects of imperfect sensitivity and specificity of diagnostic testing, the prevalence of condition, and the rate of surveillance on the ratio of numbers of DVT/PE diagnosed and those that actually occur. Methods. Given that proximal DVT following orthopaedic surgery are not preventable (incidence 4-10% despite prophylaxis), and that the accepted screening test (duplex ultrasonongraphy) has a sensitivity of 96.5% and specificity of 94%, up to 2.5 times as many DVT will be diagnosed as actually occur. Since the new CMS policy would withhold payment when a complication is identified, hospitals would be encouraged to decrease screening for DVT, which would save them lost reimbursement but would result in an increase in incidence of unrecognised – and therefore untreated – DVT after major orthopaedic surgical procedures. The study examines the likely CMS savings in the United States for implementation of this proposed policy (estimated $300M annually), as well as the potential increase in undiagnosed DVT likely to result from implementation of the policy. The overall goal of this study is to provide information to better enable the reader to draw their own conclusions on whether non-payment for DVT after an orthopaedic procedure is a fiscal policy that makes sense and improves the health and healthcare of Americans

We examined the rates of infection and colonisation by methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) between January 2003 and May 2004 in order to assess the impact of the introduction of an MRSA policy in October 2003, which required all admissions to be screened. Emergency admissions were treated prophylactically and elective beds ring-fenced. A total of 5594 admissions were cross-referenced with 22 810 microbiology results. The morbidity, mortality and cost of managing MRSA-carrying patients, with a proximal fracture of the femur were compared, in relation to age, gender, American Society of Anaesthesiologists grade and residential status, with a group of matched controls who were MRSA-negative. In 2004, we screened 1795 of 1796 elective admissions and MRSA was found in 23 (1.3%). We also screened 1122 of 1447 trauma admissions and 43 (3.8%) were carrying MRSA. All ten ward transfers were screened and four (40%) were carriers (all p < 0.001). The incidence of MRSA in trauma patients increased by 2.6% per week of inpatient stay (r = 0.97, p < 0.001). MRSA developed in 2.9% of trauma and 0.2% of elective patients during that admission (p < 0.001). The implementation of the MRSA policy reduced the incidence of MRSA infection by 56% in trauma patients (1.57% in 2003 (17 of 1084) to 0.69% in 2004 (10 of 1447), p = 0.035). Infection with MRSA in elective patients was reduced by 70% (0.56% in 2003 (7 of 1257) to 0.17% in 2004 (3 of 1806), p = 0.06). The cost of preventing one MRSA infection was £3200. Although colonisation by MRSA did not affect the mortality rate, infection by MRSA more than doubled it. Patients with proximal fractures of the femur infected with MRSA remained in hospital for 50 extra days, had 19 more days of vancomycin treatment and 26 more days of vacuum-assisted closure therapy than the matched controls. These additional costs equated to £13 972 per patient. From this experience we have been able to describe the epidemiology of MRSA, assess the impact of infection-control measures on MRSA infection rates and determine the morbidity, mortality and economic cost of MRSA carriage on trauma and elective orthopaedic wards