Aims. The evidence base within trauma and orthopaedics has traditionally favoured quantitative research methodologies. Qualitative research can provide unique insights which illuminate patient experiences and perceptions of care. Qualitative methods reveal the subjective narratives of patients that are not captured by quantitative data, providing a more comprehensive understanding of patient-centred care. The aim of this study is to quantify the level of qualitative research within the orthopaedic literature. Methods. A bibliometric search of journals’ online archives and multiple databases was undertaken in March 2024, to identify articles using qualitative research methods in the top 12 trauma and orthopaedic journals based on the 2023 impact factor and SCImago rating. The bibliometric search was conducted and reported in accordance with the preliminary guideline for reporting bibliometric reviews of the biomedical literature (BIBLIO). Results. Of the 7,201 papers reviewed, 136 included qualitative methods (0.1%). There was no significant difference between the journals, apart from Bone & Joint Open, which included 21 studies using qualitative methods, equalling 4% of its published articles. Conclusion. This study demonstrates that there is a very low number of qualitative research papers published within trauma and orthopaedic journals. Given the increasing focus on patient outcomes and improving the patient experience, it may be argued that there is a requirement to support both quantitative and qualitative approaches to orthopaedic research. Combining qualitative and quantitative methods may effectively address the complex and personal aspects of patients’ care, ensuring that outcomes align with patient values and enhance overall care quality

The purpose of this study was to determine whether the reasons for delay to surgery are secondary to health system constraints or patient factors. This study explored factors that contribute to patients' delay to surgery as well as how patients perceive the delay in surgery to have affected their treatment and care. Semi-structured qualitative interviews were conducted with 30 patients aged 18 to 50 years old who had undergone arthroscopic ACL reconstruction. Qualitative data analysis was performed in accordance with the Straus and Corbin theory to derive codes, categories and themes. Patient interviews revealed three overarching themes regarding delay to ACL reconstruction surgery: access to care, finances and work, and personal advocacy. Elements of those factors were shown to influence the timing of ACL reconstruction surgery. Less common factors included choice of imaging study (i.e., ultrasound), geography, and family commitments. Patients' perceptions of delay in access to care was overwhelming due to the wait time for MRI. Several patients also described significant self-advocacy required to navigate the healthcare system, suggesting that some level of medical literacy may be necessary to gain timely access to surgery. Once patients had seen the surgeon, few patients described untimely delay to surgery, suggesting that OR resources are adequate. Recommendations to decrease delays to ACL reconstruction surgery include better access to MRI and broader education of non-surgical healthcare providers to help navigate access to surgery

Aim. Alpha-defensin is a new synovial fluid biomarker for the diagnosis of periprosthetic joint infections (PJI). We compared the performance of two different alpha-defensin assays: quantitative ELISA test and qualitative lateral flow test. Method. In this prospective cohort study, consecutive patients with a painful prosthesis of the lower limb were eligible for inclusion. In addition to standard diagnostics of PJI, alpha-defensin was determined in the aspirated synovial fluid between October 2016 and April 2017. PJI was defined according to the modified Zimmerli criteria, the Musculoskeletal Infection Society (MSIS) criteria and the Infectious Disease Society of America (IDSA) criteria. A positive quantitative alpha-defensin test was defined at a cut-off value of 5.2 mg/L. The sensitivity, specificity, accuracy and area under the curve of each test were determined and the AUCs were compared among each other. Results. We included 72 patients (55 knee, 27 hip prosthesis) with a median age of 70 years (range: 41 – 85 years). Based on the modified Zimmerli criteria, 23 cases (32%) were categorized as septic and 49 (68%) as aseptic prosthesis failure. The sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, and AUC of quantitative alpha-Defensin were 48%, 98%, 82%, and 0.73, respectively; for qualitative alpha-Defensin, results were 48%, 100%, 83%, and 0.74, respectively. When the IDSA criteria were applied, the sensitivity of the quantitative and qualitative alpha-defensin test was 83% and 75%, respectively; when the MSIS criteria were applied, the sensitivity of the quantitative and qualitative alpha-Defensin was 92% and 83%, respectively. The comparison between the qualitative and quantitative alpha-defensin tests showed no statistically significant difference regardless of the used infection classification (modified Zimmerli: [difference AUC −0.01; p = 0.792], IDSA: [difference AUC 0.04; p = 0.317], MSIS: [difference AUC 0.04; p = 0.264]). Conclusions. The sensitivity of the alpha-defensin test in synovial fluid showed poor sensitivity (48%) for diagnosing PJI when modified Zimmerli criteria were used. No difference were observed between the qualitative and quantitative alpha-defensin test

There have been no studies assessing the acceptability of opioid tapering in the pre-arthroplasty setting. This qualitative study aimed to (1) explore barriers and facilitators to opioid tapering amongst patients with chronic non-cancer pain (CNCP), and (2) explore the similarities and differences in acceptability of opioid tapering between pre-arthroplasty patients and those participating in a biopsychosocial pain management program. From January 2021, adult participants diagnosed with CNCP and taking opioids daily (any dose at time of screening for a period of 3 months) were recruited from either Fairfield Orthopaedic Hip and Knee Service (FOHKS) or Liverpool Hospital Pain Clinic (LHPC). Semi-structured interviews underwent thematic analysis using the framework method. 17 participants were recruited (FOHKS, n=9, mean age 67, female 77%, LHPC, n=8, mean age 54, female 63%). Both groups had participants who; (i) were reluctant to use opioid medications and used them out of “necessity”, (ii) were reluctant to taper due to concerns of worsening pain, quality of life, (iii) believed opioids were “toxins” causing bodily harm. Some FOHKS participants believed tapering should be a post-operative focus, whilst others believed tapering opioids pre-operatively will assist in post-op pain management. Few LHPC participants felt dependent/addicted to opioids, thus driving their intention to taper opioids. The belief of tapering opioids causing worse pain was based on either previous experiences or concerns alone. Some FOHKS participants were more inclined to taper opioids if they were educated on the chronic and peri-operative risks associated with using opioids at time of arthroplasty. Opioid users recognise the harms associated with chronic opioid use and believe they are used out of desperation for adequate analgesia, function, and quality of life. Tapering opioids in the pre-arthroplasty context may need coupling with patient education highlighting the importance of opioid tapering pre-operatively

Background. Acromegaly, which stems from high level of serum growth hormone secreted by a benign tumour in the anterior pituitary gland, is likely to cause severe peripheral joint pains due to hypertrophic changes in such joints. Recently, the life expectancy of such patients has been improved and more patients with acromegaly have undergone joint surgeries to mitigate joint pain and malfunctions. However, little is known about to what extent surgical procedures can improve the joint functions of acromegalic patients compared to non-acromegalic cases. Methods. First, we qualitatively analysed prognosis of total hip arthroplasty (THA) of acromegalic patients by investigating 11 cases in which direct anterior approach (DAA) THAs were performed to 8 acromegalic patients in our hospital between 2012 and 2015. Second, we quantitatively compared the functional prognosis of the 11 cases with that of 107 non-acromegalic cases. Technically, to control the difference in age, sex, height, and weight between the two patient groups, we first identified a model that could predict 3month-/6month-/12month-functional prognosis in the control cases. We estimated differences in functional outcomes between the two groups by calculating how accurately the control-case-based model could predict the prognosis of the acromegalic cases. Results. In the qualitative analysis, we found that compared to the control, the most acromegalic cases had atypically advanced degenerative arthritides with osteophytes and enthesophytes proliferations. In addition, some cases showed other signs, such as flattering of femoral head and arthritis with slight osteophytes. Regarding surgical procedures, acromegalic cases were likely to require longer operation time and larger amounts of blood loss compared to the control. In the quantitative analysis, we first identified a model in which age and body height could predict the functional prognosis of DAA THA in the non-acromegalic cases (F[2,104] = 6.7, P = 0.0017). We then found that the actual functional outcomes of the acromegalic cases were not significantly different from those predicted by this control-case-based model (P = 0.18). Conclusions. The qualitative analysis shows the atypical joint structures and resultant prolonged operation time and blood loss in the acromegalic cases. However, the quantitative analysis could not find significant differences in prognosis between the acromegalic and non-acromegalic cases. Although these observations and analyses need to be examined in studies with large sample sizes, this work suggests that functional outcomes of DAA THA to acromegalic patients can be comparable to that to non-acromegalic patients

Advances in algorithms developed with sensor data from smart phones demonstrates the capacity to passively collect qualitative gait metrics. The purpose of this feasibility study was to assess the recovery of these metrics following joint reconstruction. A secondary data analysis of an ethics approved global, multicenter, prospective longitudinal study evaluating gait quality data before and after primary total knee arthroplasty (TKA, n=476), partial knee arthroplasty (PKA, n=139), and total hip arthroplasty (THA, n=395). A minimum 24 week follow-up was required (mean 45±12, range 24 - 78). Gait bouts and gait quality metrics (walking speed, step length, timing asymmetry, and double support percentage) were collected from a standardized smartphone operating system. Pre- and post-operative values were compared using paired-samples t-tests (p<0.05). A total of 595 females and 415 males with a mean age of 61.9±9.3 years and mean BMI of 30.2±6.1 kg/m. 2. were reviewed. Walking speeds were lowest at post-operative week two (all, p<.001). Speeds exceeded pre-operative means consistently by week 21 (p=0.015) for PKA, and week 13 (p=0.007) for THA. The average weekly step length was lowest in post-operative week two (all, p<0.001). PKA and THA cases achieved pre-operative step lengths by week seven (p=0.064) and week 9 (p=0.081), respectively. The average weekly gait asymmetry peaked at week two post-operatively (all, p <0.001). Return to pre-operative baseline asymmetry was achieved by week 11 (p=0.371) for TKA, week six (p=0.541) for PKA, and week eight (p=.886) for THA. Double limb support percentages peaked at week two (all, p<0.001) and returned to pre-operative levels by week 24 (p=0.089) for TKA, week 12 (p=0.156) for PKA, and week 10 (p=0.143) for THA. Monitoring gait quality in real-world settings following joint reconstruction using smartphones is feasible, and may provide the advantage of removing the Hawthorne effect related to typical gait assessments and in-clinic observations

Background. Hip replacement surgery is an effective treatment, however quantitative outcome does not necessarily delineate the true picture. It is important to triangulate data methods in order to ascertain important contextual factors that may influence patient perception. Aims. The aim of the current study was to explore the patient perception on resurfacing hip arthroplasty (RHA) and mini-hip arthroplasty (MHA) in a unique cohort where each patient has received a resurfacing on one side and a mini-hip on the contralateral side using both quantitative and qualitative measures (Fig. 1). Materials and methods. We identified patients in our Practice database that had undergone RHA on one side and MHA in the opposite hip. All prostheses were implanted by two experienced surgeons using a posterior approach and followed a standard anaesthetic protocol, post-operative care and rehabilitation guidelines. The patients received Cormet 2000 hip resurfacing and MiniHip (Corin®, Ciencester, UK) implants. Data were collected pre-operatively and post-operatively at weeks 6, 12, 26 52 and annually thereafter. The data included demographic details, mHHS (modified Harris Hip Score), patient satisfaction and a qualitative semi-structured interview. Data analysis was done using both quantitative (descriptive statistics, student's t-test) and qualitative (constant comparative method of grounded theory). Results. There were 24 hips in 12 patients with mean age of 63.6 years (range 42,81) and a mean follow-up of 5.3 years (SD 4.2). The mean mHHS in pre-operative and one-year post-operative period for RHA was 50.9 (SD 22.9, range 9,71) and 82.6 (SD 11.2, range 67,91) respectively with a mean improvement of 32.9. The mean mHHS in pre-operative and one-year post-operative period for MHA was 47.83 (SD 14.6, range 20,62) and 83.2 (SD 27.3 range 53,94) respectively with mean improvement of 35.3. There was no significant difference in mHHS in the two groups (p=0.26). However, the qualitative analysis showed that a patient's perception of improvement did not always reflect the validated score improvement such as in mHHS. In 8/24 of arthroplasty cases the mHHS indicated a high return to functionality, however, interview highlighted perception of a reduction in certain aspects such as range of movement and ability to perform at a high-level such as competitive windsurfing (2/24), skiing (6/24) or martial arts (2/24). The results, therefore, suggest that the quantitative data is not sensitive enough to deduce return to function in a specialised subset of patients. The interviews indicate a marginal preference for resurfacing due to improved stability. However, the differential to the satisfaction with the mini hip was not sufficient for the potential metal ion problem to be ignored and therefore mini hip was shown to offer a reasonable bone-conserving alternative. Conclusions. Results indicate the need for more than just a quantitative score to demonstrate satisfaction and that RHA generally offers better results although when the metal ion problem is taken into account the MHA can offer sufficient function and satisfaction as an alternative

This study explored psychological functioning and coping styles in adult patients with localized and metastatic extremity soft-tissue sarcoma (STS) from diagnosis through survivorship in a single expert sarcoma center in Canada. Our analyses were driven by three main goals: 1) to develop a better understanding of the affective responses and coping mechanisms in patients who face this rare illness, 2) to identify areas of psychological functioning in which patients with STS experience most difficulties, and 3) to describe how these areas could be best addressed in clinical settings. This descriptive qualitative study is a part of a larger mixed-methods study on health related quality of life (HRQoL) in adult patients with soft-tissue sarcoma treated between 2003 and 2018. Purposive sampling based on demographic and disease variables from all patients within a prospective database was utilized to ensure a representative patient population. Three formats of data collection were conducted in French and English, 2 online focus groups (total n=12), 2 in-person focus groups (total n=12), as well as individual semi-structured interviews (n=4). Data was analyzed using inductive thematic networks approach using the qualitative software N-Vivo 12. Codes were generated by 2 independent qualitative experts that captured key concepts referring to psychological functioning and coping mechanisms. Basic themes were clustered into organizing themes, which were later merged into a global theme. Attention was paid to deviant cases, and within-group dynamics during focus group discussion analysis. Any discrepancies or inconsistencies in coding were resolved in a consensus meeting. The final sample size was determined when data saturation was reached, and no new themes emerged. Our analyses of psychological well-being and functioning revealed three main themes, mood, anxiety, and body image concerns. Feelings of depression and low mood were prominent, coinciding with physical symptoms and limitations especially during the phase of treatment and recovery. Women were more likely to report emotional volatility, while men tended to report more preoccupation. Loss of control and independence, anxiety related to illness recurrence, uncertainty about the future and facing one's mortality significantly impacted quality of life. Furthermore, while patients were more concerned with limb functionality, disfigurement and self-consciousness featured prominently in the narrative. Four adaptive coping styles were observed, positive reframing and optimism, finding a purpose, being proactive, and using humor. Among the maladaptive strategies, we noted passive acceptance, and avoidance and denial. Psychological well-being is an important domain in the HRQoL of adult patients with extremity STS. Physicians and medical workers should encourage adaptive coping mechanisms such as positive reframing and optimism. Patients endorsing higher levels of psychological distress and maladaptive coping styles should be monitored for their well-being and multidisciplinary strategies employed to optimize psychological function and HRQoL

There has been a widespread adoption of training programs or “boot-camps” targeting new surgical residents prior to entrance to the hospital environment. A plethora of studies have shown positive reactions to implementations of “boot camps”. Reaction surveys, however, lack the ability to provide a deeper level of understanding into how and why “boot camps” are seen as effective. The purpose of this study was to develop a rich perspective on the role “boot camps” are perceived to play in resident education. A constructivist approach to qualitative grounded theory methodology, employing iterative semi-structured, in-person, interviews was used to explore the construct of a “boot camp” through the eyes of key stakeholders, including junior surgical residents (n=10), senior surgical residents (n=5), and faculty members (n=5) at a major academic centre. Interviews were coded and analysed thematically using NVIVO software. Three members of the research team coded data independently and compared themes until consensus was reached. A method of constant comparative analysis was utilised throughout the iterative process. Emerging themes were revisited with stakeholders as a measure of rigor. Axial coding of themes was used to discover the overlying purposes embedded in the “boot camp” construct. The overarching themes resonating from participants were ‘anxiety reduction’, ‘cognitive unloading’ and ‘practical logistics’. Resident anxiety was ameliorated through subthemes of ‘social inclusion’, ‘group formation’, ‘confidence building’ and ‘formalisation of expectations’. A resident commented “the nuances of how things work is more stressful than the actual job.” Residents bonded together to create personal and group identities, “forming the identity of who we are as a group”, that shaped ongoing learning throughout training, “right from the beginning we would be able to call on each other.” Junior residents found themselves cognitively unloaded for higher level learning through ‘expectation setting’ and ‘formalised basic skills’; “I knew how the equipment was going to fit together, it allowed me to focus more on what was happening from the operative perspective.” Stakeholders highlighted the importance of positioning “boot camp” at the beginning of residency training, as it directly influenced the point of transition. This highlights the strength of the “boot camp” construct at targeting the challenges associated with discrete moments of transition in the advancement in practice. While surgical preparatory “boot camps” were initially born out of a competency-based framework focused on technical skill development, our findings demonstrate that the benefits outweigh simple improvement in technical ability. The formation of a learner group identity has downstream effects on resident perceptions of anxiety and confidence, while priming for higher-level learning. “Boot camp” then, is re-imagined as an experience of social professional enculturation

Heterotopic ossification (HO) is the formation of lamellar bone in extra-skeletal soft tissues. Its exact pathogenic mechanism remains elusive. Previous studies demonstrate observation only of HO at the microscopic scale. This study uses scanning electron microscopy (SEM), Back-scatter electron (BSE) imaging and mechanical testing to detail the organic and non-organic elements of HO, compared to normal bone, to guide stem cell and bio-modelling research into HO. Samples analysed were 5 military blast related HO patients, 5 control cadaveric samples (age and sex matched). Samples were imaged using SEM, BSE and the I13 beam Synchrotron x-ray diffraction scanner using validated quantitative and qualitative techniques of measurement. Appearances seen in HO compared to normal bone were characterised by the presence of a hyper-vascular network and high lacunae (osteocyte) counts, two distinct zones of bone mineral density distribution, with a tendency for hypermineralisation with kurtosis of the grey scale plots (mineral content as a weight percentage of Ca. 2+. was calibrated to atomic weight of C, Al and HA). Direction of dependence and collagen orientation in HO suggest isotropic properties. This research demonstrates that HO is bone, however its characteristics suggest a high metabolic turnover and disorganised ultra-structure consistent with an inflammatory origin

The study used a qualitative methodology to explore the attitudes and beliefs of military physiotherapists and how these influenced the management of military patients presenting with chronic low back pain. Semi-structured interviews were undertaken with a sample of 16 military physiotherapists; the transcripts were analysed using a method of thematic content analysis. Analysis of semi-structured interviews undertaken resulted in the identification of six themes. These were: military culture, occupational issues, continuing professional development, clinical reasoning, need for cure and labelling the patient. The importance of understanding the occupational demands on their patients was considered highly significant by all of the military physiotherapists interviewed. However, there appeared generally poor knowledge of the biopsychosocial model in the management of low back pain and over-reliance on the medical model. Three-quarters of the military physiotherapists interviewed expressed frustration in their management of patients with low back pain. Similarly, the military physiotherapists displayed a poor awareness of current evidence-based clinical guidelines for the management of low back pain. The themes military culture and occupational issues were significant in influencing the military physiotherapist's clinical management. The highly physical and arduous nature of military occupations resulted in investigative procedures being requested at an earlier stage than is recommended in the current evidence-based guidelines. Justification for early investigations was provided on the basis of the unique occupational factors combined with requirement to optimise the number of military personnel able to deploy operationally. It was concluded that the management of low back pain in military personnel could be improved by increasing awareness of the current evidence-based guidelines. This would benefit both patients and the Armed Services, by reducing the disability caused by low back pain and increasing the number of operationally deployable service personnel

The process of obtaining informed consent is an important and complex pursuit, especially within a paediatric setting. Medical governing bodies have stated that the role of the trainee surgeon must be explained to patients and their families during the consent process. Despite this, attitudes and practices of surgeons and their trainees regarding disclosure of the trainee's participation during the consent process has not been reported in the paediatric setting.

Nineteen face-to-face interviews were conducted with surgical trainees and staff surgeons at a tertiary level paediatric hospital in Toronto, Canada. These were transcribed and subsequently thematically coded by three reviewers.

Five main themes were identified from the interviews. 1) Surgeons do not consistently disclose the role of surgical trainees to parents. 2) Surgical trainees are purposefully vague in disclosing their role during the consent discussion without being misleading. 3) Surgeons and surgical trainees believe parents do not fully understand the specific role of surgical trainees. 4) Graduated responsibility is an important aspect of training surgeons. 5) Surgeons feel a responsibility towards both their patients and their trainees. Surgeons don't explicitly inform patients about the involvement of trainees, believing there is a lack of understanding of the training process. Trainee perspectives reflect this, with the view that families are aware of their participation but likely underestimate their role, and suggest that information is kept purposely vague to reduce anxiety.

The majority of surgeons and surgical trainees do not voluntarily disclose the degree of trainee participation in surgery during the informed consent discussion with parents. An open and honest discussion should occur, allowing for parents to make an informed decision regarding their child's care. Further patient education regarding trainees' roles would help develop a more thorough and patient centred informed consent process.

Acute Haematogenous Osteomyelitis (AHO) remains a cause of severe illness among children with the possibility of long-term consequences for growth and development. Previous research on sequelae from AHO rarely considers outcomes more than two years following treatment. This study aims to establish the quality of life of patients diagnosed with AHO in childhood up to 13 years after diagnosis, evaluating the impact on social, emotional, physical, and school function. Children treated for AHO between 2008–2018 at a tertiary referral centre in New Zealand were identified. PedsQL™ questionnaires were conducted via phone with either the child or primary caregiver and responses analysed. 40 patients met inclusion criteria, were contactable by phone, and consented to participate. The mean age was 7 years (range 0–15) and most were female (60%). Health related quality of life (HRQOL) was scored as a percentage with most participants scoring >80% (n=27). Those who do experience reduced quality of life following treatment for AHO were likely to complain of pain, stiffness, or anxiety. The impact of significant childhood illness on mental health was not adequately captured by the PedsQL™ but was highlighted in qualitative feedback. We conclude that the majority of children treated for AHO reported excellent health-related quality of life up to 13 years following treatment although an negative impact on mental health was reported using qualitative analysis. A refined scoring system is needed to assess the long-term impact of musculoskeletal infection

This qualitative study aims to explore and highlight the experiences of trainees in the Orthopaedic Surgical Education Training (SET) program in New Zealand, with a focus on identifying gender-specific biases which may impact professional development. Orthopaedic SET trainees in New Zealand were invited to complete a qualitative, semi-structured questionnaire exploring their experiences in the Orthopaedic SET program. A broad range of topics were covered, addressing culture, belonging, learning styles and role modelling. Recurrent themes were identified using inductive methods. Analysis of questionnaire responses identified several key themes for women in the Orthopaedic SET program, compared to their male counterparts, including (1) role incredulity, (2) confidence vs. competence, (3) adaptation, (4) interdisciplinary relationships and (5) role modelling. Female participants described experiencing gender bias or discrimination by both patients and interdisciplinary colleagues at a higher rate than their male counterparts. The majority of female participants described feeling as competent as their male counterparts at the same SET level, however, identified that they do not typically exhibit the same confidence in their surgical abilities. Whilst similar numbers of female and male participants described experiencing barriers to career progression, female participants described having to adapt both physically and socially to overcome additional gender-specific barriers. Positive influences on training experience included role modelling and supportive relationships amongst trainee groups. This study highlighted gender-specific biases experienced by trainees in the Orthopaedic SET program in New Zealand. Further investigation is warranted to determine how these experiences affect professional development, and how they may be addressed to foster increased gender equity in the surgical profession. This will likely require system-level interventions to create meaningful and sustainable culture change

Introduction. Traditionally, limb reconstruction physiotherapy consisted of face to face group rehabilitation. During the COVID-19 pandemic OP physiotherapy service provision was significantly reduced and delivery methods limited due to staff redeployment, service prioritisation and restriction of footfall within the hospital. A virtual exercise group for acute limb reconstruction patients was set up to maintain contact and clinical support. Materials and Methods. A small single centre study was performed over two 4 week periods capturing the experience of 35 patients. A patient reported questionnaire was used and revised post-pandemic to gather quantitative and qualitative data about the patients experience of the Limb Reconstruction Physiotherapy Service at each point in time. The qualitative data was analysed using an inductive thematic analysis. Results. Four key themes emerged from the qualitative data: Sense of community through shared experience, support & encouragement from staff and peers, increasing confidence with the frame – fostering independence, the challenging nature of the class. Recommendation of the service, positive functional impact and overall experience remained >88% of the population (face to face & virtual). Conclusions. The results highlight the benefits of group physiotherapy (face to face & virtual) to patients recovery with improvements in confidence, mobility, function, psychosocial factors and overall QoL. Peer support is paramount in the rehabilitation and progression of limb reconstruction patients. Virtual platforms for rehabilitation are helpful in maintaining participation and should be offered where possible to facilitate ongoing inclusion, however face to face contact is preferred

Introduction. LIMB-Q Kids is a new patient-reported outcome measure (PROM) for children with Lower limb differences (LLDs). The objective is to conduct an international field test study. Materials & Methods. A mixed method multiphase approach was used to develop LIMB-Q Kids. In phase one, a systematic review was conducted to identify concepts from existing PROMs used in research with children with LLDs. A preliminary conceptual framework derived from the systematic review informed an international qualitative study. The data from qualitative interviews were used to form the LIMB-Q Kids, which was further refined through multiple rounds of cognitive debriefing interviews with children. Input was obtained from parents and healthcare professionals from Australia, Canada, Ethiopia, India, UK, and the USA. LIMB-Q Kids was translated and culturally adapted into multiple languages. Results. The final field-test version consists of 11 scales (159 items) that measure appearance, physical function, symptoms (hip, knee, ankle, foot, and leg), leg-related distress, and school, social and psychological function. This version was rigorously translated into Danish and German. Translations that are in progress include Arabic, Finnish, Hindi, Swahili, Portuguese, Spanish, and Luganda. An international field-test study is underway in nine countries (15 sites with a target recruitment of 150 participants per country). At the time of abstract submission, 190 patients from seven sites have completed LIMB-Q Kids. The UK collaborative has worked on language adaption for the UK and is currently validating the score across five paediatric limb reconstruction units. Conclusions. No internationally applicable PROM exists for children with LLDs. We present the current progress in developing and validating such a score. Data from the international field-test study will be used to reduce items and perform psychometric testing of LIMB-Q Kids. The rigorous translation and cultural adaption process will provide versions of LIMB-Q Kids in different languages. Once completed, the LIMB-Q Kids will provide a common metric for outcome assessment for children with lower limb differences internationally

Aims. COVID-19 has compounded a growing waiting list problem, with over 4.5 million patients now waiting for planned elective care in the UK. Views of patients on waiting lists are rarely considered in prioritization. Our primary aim was to understand how to support patients on waiting lists by hearing their experiences, concerns, and expectations. The secondary aim was to capture objective change in disability and coping mechanisms. Methods. A minimum representative sample of 824 patients was required for quantitative analysis to provide a 3% margin of error. Sampling was stratified by body region (upper/lower limb, spine) and duration on the waiting list. Questionnaires were sent to a random sample of elective orthopaedic waiting list patients with their planned intervention paused due to COVID-19. Analyzed parameters included baseline health, change in physical/mental health status, challenges and coping strategies, preferences/concerns regarding treatment, and objective quality of life (EuroQol five-dimension questionnaire (EQ-5D), Generalized Anxiety Disorder 2-item scale (GAD-2)). Qualitative analysis was performed via the Normalization Process Theory. Results. A total of 888 patients responded. Better health, pain, and mood scores were reported by upper limb patients. The longest waiters reported better health but poorer mood and anxiety scores. Overall, 82% had tried self-help measures to ease symptoms; 94% wished to proceed with their intervention; and 21% were prepared to tolerate deferral. Qualitative analysis highlighted the overall patient mood to be represented by the terms ‘understandable’, ‘frustrated’, ‘pain’, ‘disappointed’, and ‘not happy/depressed’. COVID-19-mandated health and safety measures and technology solutions were felt to be implemented well. However, patients struggled with access to doctors and pain management, quality of life (physical and psychosocial) deterioration, and delay updates. Conclusion. This is the largest study to hear the views of this ‘hidden’ cohort. Our findings are widely relevant to ensure provision of better ongoing support and communication, mostly within the constraints of current resources. In response, we developed a reproducible local action plan to address highlighted issues. Cite this article: Bone Jt Open 2021;2(8):583–593

The number of women entering medical school has been steadily increasing over the past two decades; however, the number of women pursuing careers in orthopaedic surgery has not increased at the same rate. One of the suggested reasons for this discrepancy is the perceived incompatibility of having a family while upholding the demands of a surgical career in orthopaedics. A growing body of scientific literature has also outlined the increased rate of infertility and pregnancy complications in women surgeons. The extent to which these factors play a role in the recruitment and retention of women in orthopaedic surgery is unknown. Understanding pregnancy and parenthood in orthopaedic surgery is a critical first step in addressing this issue. A scoping review was conducted to identify literature pertaining to the perceptions and experiences of pregnancy and/or parenthood of women in orthopaedic surgery. Embase, MEDLINE and PsychINFO were searched on June 7th, 2021 with Boolean operators to combine the following terms: orthop?e*, pregnancy, maternity, motherhood, parenthood, parental, and parenting. Studies pertaining to orthopaedic surgery residents, fellows and staff were included. The Arksey and O'Malley framework for scoping studies was followed. Descriptive statistics were used to quantify the included studies while thematic analysis as described by Braun and Clarke was used to analyze the qualitative data. A total of 17 studies from 2006 to 2021 met inclusion criteria. Over half of the available research was conducted within the last two years (n=9, 53%). The majority of studies were conducted in the United States (n=15, 88%) and the United Kingdom (n=2, 12%). The most commonly used study design was survey-based research (n=13, 76%), followed by review studies (n=3, 18%), and case series (n=1, 6%). Thematic analysis revealed five key themes contributing to the women's experiences of pregnancy and/or parenthood in orthopaedics: (1) women are subtly or blatantly discouraged from becoming pregnant by their colleagues and superiors, (2) women delay childbearing to preserve their professional reputation, (3) there are higher rates of infertility and preterm labor in orthopaedic surgeons than in the general population, (4) the orthopaedic work environment can be hazardous and challenging for the pregnant woman, but accommodations are possible to mitigate risks, and (5) overall, there is limited support for pregnant and/or parenting women in orthopaedics throughout their career. The first woman to be board-certified in orthopaedic surgery in the United States was Ruth Jackson in 1937. Eighty-four years later, orthopaedic surgery has the lowest number of women of the surgical specialties. The barriers related to pregnancy and/or parenthood during a woman's career in orthopaedics may be one cause. This study identified five themes related to pregnancy and parenthood that warrant further investigation. Qualitative research approaches can be used to elucidate the details of women's experiences and to provide suggestions for structural changes in the orthopaedic work environment

Introduction. There are currently no quality of life Patient Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs) that have been validated for patients with conditions requiring lower limb reconstructive surgery. The extent to which current generic and lower limb specific PROMs address relevant dimensions for these patients is unclear. Materials and Methods. We will present an overview of the PROLLIT (Patient-Reported Outcome Measure for Lower Limb Reconstruction) mixed-methods study. PROLLIT aims to establish the adequacy of current PROMS for this population, whether a new measure is required, and to develop a new measure if appropriate. Results. The PROLLIT study consists of three phases:. Phase 1 is currently underway and involves the development of a conceptual model to map the key quality of life constructs relevant to people undergoing reconstructive surgery, to specify the intended population and uses of a PROM in this field. The conceptual model is being developed in a 3 step process: (i) Existing evidence is being collated in a systematic review of published qualitative research (Qualitative Evidence Synthesis); (ii) a multi-site qualitative study of patients, orthopaedic surgeons, specialist nurses and physiotherapists; (iii) an interdisciplinary panel of patients, surgeons, healthcare professionals and methodologists to finalise the conceptual framework based on the findings of the Qualitative Evidence Synthesis (i) and qualitative study (ii). Phase 2 involves mapping the conceptual framework onto existing PROMs measures that are used with this population to determine whether the constructs identified as important by patients and healthcare professionals are reflected in existing PROMS. Phase 3 involves developing a new outcome measure, if deemed necessary/appropriate during Phase 2. Conclusions. Current PROMS may not adequately address the issues relevant to patients recovering from lower limb reconstructive surgery. Phase 1 and 2 will provide robust evidence as to whether this is the case in order to seek funding for research to develop a new measure (Phase 3)

Introduction. Patient reported outcome measures (PROMs) are used to understand the impact of lower limb reconstruction on patient's quality of life (QOL). Existing measures have not been developed to specifically capture patient experiences amongst adults with lower limb conditions that require reconstruction surgery. This systematic review of qualitative studies (qualitative evidence synthesis) aimed to identify what is important to these patients. Materials and Methods. MEDLINE, Embase, PsychINFO and Cinahl were searched from inception until November 2020. Studies were included if they employed qualitative research methods, involved patients requiring, undergoing or following lower limb reconstruction and explored patients' experiences of care, treatment, recovery and QOL. Mixed methods/population studies that did not separate the findings from each group and studies not in English were excluded. Included studies were analysed using thematic synthesis. The review followed the methodological framework published by the Cochrane Qualitative and Implementation Methods Group for qualitative evidence syntheses. Results. Nine studies met the inclusion criteria. Thematic synthesis identified two overarching themes:(1) areas of living key to QOL for lower limb reconstruction patients, with sub-themes: pain, daily functioning and lifestyle, identity, income and emotional wellbeing and (2) moving towards a new normal, with sub-themes: support, the ability to adapt and adjust and the ability to move forwards. The impact of lower limb reconstruction on QOL and recovery is complex and is influenced by a range of inter-related factors, which will affect patients to varying degrees depending on individual circumstances. Conclusions. The impact of lower limb reconstruction on patients' QOL is complex, may change over time and is strongly linked to their recovery. This review was conducted as part of the wider ‘PROLLIT' study, which will develop a conceptual framework to identify what outcomes are important to patients and should be included in a PROM. We will then map our conceptual framework onto existing PROMS to establish whether our identified factors are captured by current PROMS. Depending on the outcome of this work, a new PROM for patients following lower limb reconstruction may be developed