Mayo 2A Olecranon fractures are traditionally managed with a tension band wire device (TBW) but locking plates may also be used to treat these injuries. To compare clinical outcomes and treatment cost between TBW and locking plate fixation in Mayo 2A fractures.Introduction:
Objectives:
Post-operative check radiographs following Total Hip Replacements (THR) are routine practice in most orthopaedic units. In our unit an Anteroposterior and Turned Lateral View (TLV) radiograph was used routinely in this assessment, but the TLV method has anecdotally been reported as painful by patients. We undertook a study to evaluate patients' experiences of pain using this technique and to consider if a change to a Horizontal Beam Lateral View (HBLV) radiograph method would result in a reduction in pain. The study was conducted in two phases. Patients who underwent a primary THR and subsequent post-operative TLV over 3months (n=46) were contacted by telephone and asked to grade their experience using a numerical and descriptive pain scale. After a change in practice to HBLV, the study was repeated (n=53) to identify any difference in pain. Ten radiographs were randomly selected from each group and assessed for radiation exposure and quality by two independent assessors. 87.0% of patients who underwent the TLV radiograph described the post-operative radiograph as painful, with a mean pain score of 7.44+1.5. After a change in practice to the HBLV radiograph, only 28.4% of patients experienced any pain, with a significantly lower mean pain score of 1.00+1.89 (p< 0.001). There was a significant increase in radiation dose in the HBLV vs. TLV method (62.4mAs vs. 25.8mAs, p< 0.001). HBLV X-ray quality was only slightly inferior to TLV when evaluating stem alignment and cement mantle quality. There was a dramatic reduction in both number of patients experiencing pain and level of pain experienced when switching from TLV to HBLV radiographs; this is most likely due to reduced direct pressure on the wound post-operatively. X-ray quality was not compromised, and whilst there was increased radiation exposure, the benefits in patient experience were felt to outweigh this. We recommend the HBLV radiograph method when performing a lateral post-operative check x-ray following THR.
