The purpose of this study was to evaluate and to compare the mechanical stability of external fixation with and without ankle spanning fixation using a foot plate in an in-vitro model of periarticular distal tibia osteotomy/fracture. Ten fresh frozen lower extremities (five pairs) with a simulated distal tibia osteotomy/fracture were stabilised with an Ilizarov hybrid fixator with and without a foot plate. All specimens were loaded using a servohydraulic load frame. Relative interfragmentary motions (vertical and horizontal translations, and rotation) were measured. Statistical analysis was performed as a paired t-test to compare the different frame constructs. A p<0.05 was considered indicative of a significant difference between fixator constructs. The vertical displacement measured at the centre of the distal fragment under load with the foot plate was such that the bone fragments became closer together (-0.83±0.64 mm). Loading of specimens without the foot plate resulted in distraction of the distal fragment (2.57±0.97 mm). The difference was statistically significant (p<0.05). The horizontal displacement of distal fragment with (1.12±0.98 mm) was not significantly different from the motion without (1.19±1.23 mm) a foot plate and was in the anterior direction in both cases. Loading of the construct with the foot plate caused sagittal plane angulation of the fragments with the osteotomy/fracture gap opening anteriorly (-1.15±0.61 deg.). Loading of the construct without a foot plate resulted in sagittal plane angulation of fragments with the gap opening posteriorly (4.49±0.45 deg.). These motion differences were statistically significant (p<0.05). There was not a statistically significant difference between the order of testing the construct with a foot plate and the construct without it (p>0.05). Fixators with ankle spanning using foot plates increase the mechanical stiffness of external fixation of periarticular distal tibia osteotomy/fracture.
The treatment methods of TKA infection was two-stage exchange in 59 (83%), debridement and retention −5 (7.2%), arthrodesis −5 (7.2%), excision arthroplasty 2 (2.8%). At final followup, 17 knees (24%) had required reoperation: 10 knees (14%) -component removal for reinfection. Two knees were reinfected 3 times, three knees – two times. The median time to first reoperation for reinfection was 1.2 years (range, 0.04–2.5 years). By Kaplan-Meier survival analysis the estimated survivals free of reoperation for infection were 90.5% (confidence intervals, 85.3–96.1%) at 5 years and 82% (confidence intervals, 70.3–94.5%) at 10 years. The Knee Society scores: Pain scores, Functional scores, ROM improved.
Infection is one of the most disturbing and frightening complications of total knee arthroplasty (TKA). The purpose of the present study was to review the management and outcomes of infected total knee arthroplasty. The management and outcomes in 71 patients with 71 infected TKA was reviewed. Two-stage reimplantation with 8 weeks of intravenous therapy between the stages was used in 49 patients. Twenty-four patients ended with an arthrodesis using external fixation or intramedulary (IM) nailing. A two-stage technique was used with IM nail arthrodesis. Infections after TKA associated with bone destruction and loss were treated using an antibiotic-impregnated cement rod-spacer. Two patients required amputation: one because of soft tissue necrosis around the knee, another because of recalcitrant infection. In two patients the antibiotic-impregnated cement rod-spacer was chosen as a definitive treatment. The re-infection rate was about 25%. In most cases of reinfection the pathogens were the same, but of higher virulence and resistance. Infection was eradicated in 85% of patients. More than half of patients ended up with a functional TKA (average function score was 86.5 points, average range of motion from 2 to 109 degrees). One third of patients had a solid fusion. The infection could not be eradicated in 15% of patients. The management and outcomes of infected total knee arthroplasty depend on a rapid and accurate diagnosis. A clear and effective management algorithm should yield favorable outcomes according to well-defined criteria. The two-stage reimplantation is the treatment of choice for chronic periprosthetic knee infection. Knee arthrodesis can be an effective treatment option after the failure of a TKA due to infection.
Serological tests including erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) and C-reactive protein (CRP) are frequently used in the preoperative workup to screen for periprosthetic infection (PPI) in total hip arthroplasty (THA). The cut-off points reported in the literature are arbitrarily chosen by investigators. Similarly, the values used in laboratories to distinguish elevated results vary from one institute to another. Therefore, we intended to define the appropriate cut-off points of ESR and CRP that can be used to differentiate infection from aseptic failure of THA. A review of our joint registry database revealed that 515 THA revisions (131 infected cases) were performed during 2000–2005. Intraoperative samples for culture were taken in all cases. The criteria used for diagnosis of infection were a positive intraoperative culture on solid media, presence of an abscess or sinus tract that communicated with the joint, positive preoperative aspiration culture, and/or elevated fluid cell count and neutrophil differential of the aspirated fluid. Non-infected patients with confounding factors that can elevate ESR and CRP including collagen vascular disease, inflammatory arthropathy, malignancy, and urinary tract infection were excluded. Receiver operator curves were used to determine the ideal cut-off point for both ESR and CRP. The mean value of ESR in the infected group (77mm/ hr) was significantly higher compared to that of the non-infected cohort (29mm/hr) (p=0.0001). Similarly, infected patients presented with a greater mean CRP (9.8 mg/dl) than their non-infected cohort (1.48 mg/ dl) (p=0.0001). The infection threshold for ESR was 45mm/hr with a sensitivity of 85% and specificity of 79%, while the optimal cut-off value for CRP was defined as 1.6 mg/dl which yielded a sensitivity of 86% and specificity of 83%. The optimal threshold values we determined are higher than the arbitrarily chosen values cited in the literature for ESR (30mm/hr) and CRP (1mg/dl). Although it has been previously reported that the sensitivity and specificity of CRP are far greater than that of ESR, we found that the two tests have comparable diagnostic value.
One of the routinely used intraoperative tests for diagnosis of periprosthetic infection (PPI) is Gram stain that is reported to carry a very high specificity and a poor sensitivity. However, it is not known if the result of this test can vary according to the type of joint affected or the number of specimen samples collected. This study intended to examine the role of this diagnostic test in a large cohort of patients from single institution. A review of our joint registry database revealed that 453 total knee arthroplasty (TKA) and 551 total hip arthroplasty (THA) of which 171 and 150 cases were respectively infected underwent revision surgery during 2000–2005 and had intraoperative cultures available for interpretation. A positive gram stain was defined as the visualisation of bacterial cells or ‘many leukocytes’ (>
5 per high power field) under the smear. The sensitivity, specificity, and predictive values of each individual diagnostic arm of Gram stain were determined. Combinations were performed in series that require both tests to be positive to confirm infection and in parallel that necessitate both tests to be negative to rule out infection. This analysis was performed for THA and TKA separately and later compared for each joint type. The presence of organism cells and ‘many’ neutrophils on a Gram smear had high specificity (98%–100%) and positive predictive value (89%–100%) in both THA and TKA. The sensitivities (30%–50%) and negative predictive values (70%–79%) of the two tests were low as expected among both joint types. When the two tests were combined in series the specificity and positive predictive value were absolute (100%). The sensitivity (43%–64%) and the negative predictive value (82%) improved among both THA and TKA. The presence of organisms or ‘many’ leukocytes on the Gram smear can confirm PPI in TJA. As expected, the sensitivity and negative predictive value of the two tests were low, and therefore infection could not be safely ruled out. Although the two diagnostic arms of Gram stain can be combined to achieve improved negative predictive value (82%), Gram stain continues to have poor value in ruling out PPI. With the advances in the field of molecular biology, novel diagnostic modalities need to be designed that can replace these traditional and poor tests.