Introduction: A number of surgical techniques have been described for the operative treatment of late stage osteochondritis dissecans (OCD) in the knee and ankle that have failed nonoperative management. However, no particular technique has been universally successful. We report the results of a new technique using retrograde drilling combined with the use of a novel collagen based bone void filler to prevent mechanical failure of the joint surface. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the results of this new technique and analyze the efficacy of both collagen Type-1 based osteoinductive bone void fillers Colloss and Colloss E with and without additional bone grafting.
Methods: The osteoinductive bone void fillers Colloss (bovine) and Colloss E (equine) are bone inducing collagenous sponges. The osteoinductive properties are due to the interactive release of BMP-2, BMP-7, IGF-1 and TGF-beta from the implant and the surrounding host tissue by osteoclastic and osteoblastic action. All surgeries performed in the present series included retrograde drilling procedures for OCD in the talar dome and the femoral condyles. Between 2000 and 2006 eight patients were treated by retrograde drilling or trephine drilling under arthroscopic and fluoroscopic control preventing injury to the cartilage surface. The subchondral cavity was filled with a mixture of 20–40 mg bone void filler and morsellized bone graft. The bone void filler is tamped through the drill guide and into position with a Steinmann pin. Thus, only the subchondral defect was filled but the peripheral area of the drill hole remained empty. Evaluation was achieved by clinical assessment, radiographic, and magnetic resonance imaging examination. The follow-up averaged 24 months up to 48 months.
Results: In all cases, osseous density increased in the Colloss filled subchondral area and mechanical impression of the joint surface could be prevented. Interestingly, clinical examination and follow-up MRI exams demonstrated moderate swelling and joint effusion in 5 of 8 cases for a period of 4 to 10 weeks postoperatively. This may be in part due to the augmentation technique. Nevertheless, good clinical (range of motion, pain) and radiographic results (bony healing) were obtained after this new treatment modality.
Discussion: The subchondral application of Colloss in OCD bone cysts or osteonecrosis induced solid osseous formation at the implantation site. The results of persisting joint reaction such as swelling, pain, and prolonged bone edema in MRI scans may be due to mechanical bearing indicating that augmentation of the defect has to be improved to ensure a solid bony reconstruction. Major advantages of this technique include the ease of performing this procedure, the one-step nature of the procedure, and the ability to avoid violation of stable articular cartilage. In addition, this technique may be repeated according to the size of the lesion.
