This animal study compares different methods of performing an osteotomy, including using an Erbium-doped Yttrium Aluminum Garnet laser, histologically, radiologically and biomechanically. A total of 24 New Zealand rabbits were divided into four groups (Group I: multihole-drilling; Group II: Gigli saw; Group III: electrical saw blade and Group IV: laser). A proximal transverse diaphyseal osteotomy was performed on the right tibias of the rabbits after the application of a circular external fixator. The rabbits were killed six weeks after the procedure, the operated tibias were resected and radiographs taken.

The specimens were tested biomechanically using three-point bending forces, and four tibias from each group were examined histologically. Outcome parameters were the biomechanical stability of the tibias as assessed by the failure to load and radiographic and histological examination of the osteotomy site.

The osteotomies healed in all specimens both radiographically and histologically. The differences in the mean radiographic (p = 0.568) and histological (p = 0.71) scores, and in the mean failure loads (p = 0.180) were not statistically significant between the groups.

Different methods of performing an osteotomy give similar quality of union. The laser osteotomy, which is not widely used in orthopaedics is an alternative to the current methods.

Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2015;97-B:1628–33.

Introduction: While providing an easier compression, cable tensioners also bring the risk of an iatrogenic fracture when they are unnecessarily over-tightened. In this pilot study we have designed a split femur fracture/osteotomy model to assess the minimal force providing rotational stability for a femoral prosthetic stem during tightening with a cable tensioner.

Methods: Twelve volunteer residents of orthopedics were asked to tighten gradually a cerclage wiring of steel cable with a cable tensioner on a longitudinally split bone encircling a prosthetic stem. Each resident repeated the test 10 times and they aimed to tighten until to a point to provide rotational stability for the stem, that they decided with manual control. The fracture model was reproduced on the distal diaphysis of a 12 mm diameter femur bone of a one-year old sheep cadaver. The femur bone was longitudinally split with an oscillating saw and a semi-cylindrical 5 cm long bone window was split. A 13 mm diameter femoral stem (Restoration HA, Styker) was then inserted into the open segment of the diaphysis and the bone window was closed on it and gently hold in place with a cerclage of steel cables. A special aluminum cable tensioner, integrated with a special digital strain measurement device (Vishay MM, NJ, USA), was used for tightening of the cable. The minimal tension loads that the residents found enough to provide a rotational stability were recorded. The descriptive modules and Student t-test were used in statistical analysis. The p values < 0.05 were considered statistically significant.

Results: Mean tension loads provided by 12 residents were between 176±32N and 876±211N. The mean tension loads of the total 120 tigtening trials was 540 N. Significant difference was found between the highest and the lowest (p< 0.0001). Plateau of the rotational stability was 6N/m. First tension load for reaching this level was found to be 550±45N. The force to break the bone was found to be around 2000N.

Discussion: For secure use, the force interval that will ensure a secure fixation without causing a fracture should be known and the tensioner should be tightened in these ranges. In this in-vitro experimental pilot study we have compared the individual assessment of secure fixation during cable tensioner use. Our results suggest that the individual decision for rotational stability depends largely on the person who evaluates it. A torque-meter can be implemented to our experiment model to obtain more objective assessment of the optimal tightening of the cable tensioner for secure fixation with rotational stability. After determining the force interval for secure fixation a torquesensitive crank can be designed and implemented to the cable tensioner. Such a device should provide a more safe and secure fixation during tightening of cerclage wirings.

We compared time-dependent changes in the biomechanical properties of single-and double-row repair of a simulated acute tear of the rotator cuff in rabbits to determine the effect of the fixation techniques on the healing process.

A tear of the supraspinatus tendon was created in 80 rabbits which were separated into two equal groups. A single-row repair with two suture anchors was conducted in group 1 and a double-row repair with four suture anchors in group 2. A total of ten intact contralateral shoulder joints was used as a control group. Biomechanical testing was performed immediately post-operatively and at four and eight weeks, and histological analysis at four and eight weeks.

The mean load to failure in group 2 animals was greater than in group 1, but both groups remained lower than the control group at all intervals. Histological analysis showed similar healing properties at four and eight weeks in both groups, but a significantly larger number of healed tendon-bone interfaces were identified in group 2 than in group 1 at eight weeks (p < 0.012).

The ultimate load to failure increased with the number of suture anchors used immediately post-operatively, and at four and eight weeks. The increased load to failure at eight weeks seemed to be related to the increase in the surface area of healed tendon-to-bone in the double-row repair group.