There is a strong association between the presence of a calcar collar on a cementless stem and a reduced risk of revision surgery for periprosthetic fracture of the femur (PFF). A medial calcar collar may act to reduce relative movement between the implant and femur during PFF, through calcar-collar contact (CCC). The aims were:
Estimate the effect of CCC on periprosthetic fracture mechanics. Estimate the effect of initial calcar-collar separation on the likelihood of CCC. Three groups of six composite femurs were implanted with a fully coated collared cementless femoral stem. Neck resection differed between groups (group 1 = no additional resection, group 2 = 3mm additional resection, group 3 = 6mm additional resection). PFF were simulated using a previously published technique. Fracture torque and rotational displacement were measured and torsional stiffness and rotational work prior to fracture were estimated. Results between trials where CCC did and did not occur where compared using Mann-Whitney U tests. Logistic regression estimated the odds (OR) of failing with 95% confidence interval (CI) to achieve CCC for a given initial separation. Where CCC occurred fracture torque was greater (47.33 [41.03 to 50.45] Nm versus 38.26 [33.70 to 43.60] Nm, p= 0.05) and torsional stiffness was greater (151.38 [123.04 to 160.42] rad.Nm−1 versus 96.86 [84.65 to 112.98] rad.Nm−1, p <0.01). CCC was occurred in all cases in group one, 50% in group two and 0% in group three. OR of failure to obtain CCC increased 3.8 fold (95% CI 1.6 to 30.2, p <0.05) for each millimetre of separation. Resistance to fracture and construct stiffness increased when a the collar made contact with the calcar prior to fracture and the chances of contact decrease with increasing initial separation at the time of implantation. Surgeons should aim to achieve a calcar-collar distance of less than 1mm following implantation to ensure CCC and to reduce the risk of fracture
