The removal of cement debris at the time of primary and revision joint replacement has been facilitated through the introduction of coloured bone cements. Up to date, few studies have evaluated the effect of methilene blue dye on physical, mechanical and pharmacological properties of cements. In this light, we evaluated the effects of adding methylene blue to bone cement with or without antibiotics (gentamicin, vancomycin or both). The addition of methylene blue to plain cement significantly decreased its mean compression (95.4±3 MPa vs 100.1±6 MPa, p = 0.03) and bending (65.2±5 MPa vs 76.6±4 MPa, p < 0.001) strengths, mean setting time (570±4 seconds vs 775±11 seconds, p = 0.01), as well as its mean elastic modulus (2744±97 MPa vs 3281±110 MPa, p < 0.001). Bending resistance decreases after the supplementation of the coloured cement with vancomycin and gentamicin (55.7±4 MPa vs 65.2±5 MPa, p < 0.001). The release of antibiotics from the bone cement was significantly decreased by the methylene blue. Indeed, the release of gentamicin alone was 385.5±26 μg in comparison to 228.2±24 μg when the methylene blue was added (p < 0.001), while the release of gentamicin in combination with vancomycin was 613±25 μg vs 498.5±70 μg (p = 0.018) when the dye was added to the same formulation. With this study we demonstrated several theoretical disadvantages of the antibiotic-loaded bone cement coloured with methylene blue, although caution should be exercised in transferring our findings to the clinical context. Based on our findings, we do not recommend methylene blue supplementation of PMMA for routine clinical use.