Procedure Based Assessments (PBAs) are one type of Workplace Based Assessment (WBA) introduced recently to orthopaedic training in the UK. They play an increasing role in the assessment of a trainee's surgical competence.

The study aims to determine the most valuable aspects of a PBA to a trainee, and the changes trainees suggest to improving the use of PBAs.

A link to an online questionnaire was sent by email via the eLogbook system to all orthopaedic trainees in the UK with a National Training Number (NTN). The free text responses were coded and categorised. Analysis of results was conducted using the online survey software and Microsoft Excel.

Of 668 responses, 616 met the inclusion criteria, making a response rate of 66% of all trainees with a NTN in the UK. There was a broad, representative spread of seniority and of geographical location. Trainees found the verbal feedback gained from their trainer to be most valuable (47%), followed by the assessment of competence (21%). Trainees identified the PBA form itself as the most important area for change (52.4%). This included increased numbers of PBAs (17.5%), more specific to the procedure (8.6%), more user friendly (15%), more levels of competence (4.5%) and a generic PBA (3.4%). Further suggestions included changing the role of PBAs, with 8.2% suggesting discontinuing their use entirely. Improving trainer investment in the use of PBA was also highlighted.

Trainees value PBAs to gain formal feedback more than their use as evidence of competence in a procedure. There are a number of changes suggested by trainees that could improve the use and effectiveness of PBAs, and we have incorporated these into recommendations made by the British Orthopaedic Trainees’ Association, which should inform the debate on the further development of this assessment tool, and on WBAs in general.