Patella management in total knee arthroplasty remains controversial. Minimizing patella related problems is the main goal in any type of knee arthroplasty. This can be achieved with and without resurfacing. However, patella resurfacing resulted in, at times, catastrophic failures, which increased the popularity of patella non resurfacing, particularly with anatomical femoral groove designs. If patella non resurfacing is to be recommended, clinical outcomes must be equal or better than those of routine patella resurfacing in the specific prosthesis utilized. From a large cohort of over 6000 TKA five studies were conducted to analyze isokinetic strength, subjective, clinical, and radiographic outcomes as well as histopathological data. Isokinetic strength, subjective, clinical, and radiographic outcomes favor nonresurfacing in TKA with proper femoral component rotation and conforming patellar groove. Our data indicate that patella subluxation and femoral component malrotation is significantly associated with development of arthrofibrosis. On the base of our studies we propose specific surgical techniques for optimal patella treatment (patelloplasty) in TKA.
Patellectomized knees often perform poorly with respect to extensor mechanism function. Reconstruction options and literature reports are limited. The purpose of this study was to describe and review bone graft patella reconstruction in TKA.
Clinical scores had a mean of 27 points (max: 30) and mean isokinetic extension strength of 71Nm (81 percent) compared with the opposite healthy patella site. One patient with bilateral patellectomy and unilateral patella reconstruction showed a 50 percent increase of strength on the grafted side. Radiographs showed minor signs of neopatella bone resorption, but a maintained leaver arm. Reconstruction of a neo-patella in TKA with autograft provides marked improvement of isokinetic extensor strength, little evidence of autograft resorption, excellent or good clinical outcome and high patients satisfaction after a mean of 8 years. The results of this study indicate encouraging data for reconstructing a new patella and lever arm in patellectomized knees during primary or revision TKA. Cosmetic improvement in females is another subjective advantage.
The purpose of this prospective and randomized study was to objectively evaluate isokinetic strength, clinical, and radiographical outcome in bilateral TKA using the same prosthesis with and without patella resurfacing. Bilateral TKA, one with, one without patella resurfacing was performed in 22 osteoarthritic patients, mean age was 68 years using the Low-Contact-Stress prosthesis. Minimum Follow-up was one year. Evaluation included clinical investigation, specific patella scores, radiographic analysis and isokinetic strength measurement of both knee flexion and extension at 60 degrees per second (Biodex). surement at 60 degrees per second (Biodex). There was no significant clinical score difference, but mean isokinetic strength of knee extension was significantly (p<
.0001) stronger in the non-resurfaced patella TKA (40.5 Nm) compared with the resurfaced TKA (38,5 Nm). Flexion was also significantly stronger in the patella non-resurfaced group with 22.4 Nm versus 19.5 Nm in the resurfaced group. Mean lateral deviation was significantly (p<
.001) less ideal in the resurfaced group as was postoperative patellofemoral congruent contact (p<
.001). However, there was no correlation between lateral patella deviation or congruent contact and iso-kinetic strength. The results of this study indicate that mean isokinetic strength of both knee flexion and extension was significantly stronger in the non-resurfaced patella TKA. This study provides encouraging data for patella non-resurfacing. However, clinical scores or patient’s preference did not show any difference.
The purpose of this study was to determine whether internal mal-rotation of the femoral component is associated with arthrofibrosis in TKA. Multiple etiological factors have been suggested, but specific causes have not been identified. We hypothesized arthrofibrosis may be triggered by a combination of non-physiological kinematics (femoral component internal rotation) and a tight medial compartment. From a consecutive cohort of 3058 mobile bearing TKA forty-four (1.4%) cases were diagnosed as having arthrofibrosis, of which thirty-eight (86%) cases could be recruited. Thirty-eight patients with a well functioning TKA served as matched controls. Evaluation included CT investigation to determine femoral component rotation with reference to the transepicondylar axis (TEA).
There is a highly significant association between arthrofibrosis in TKA and internal mal-rotation of the femoral component. On the base of these results it was hypothesized that non-physiological kinematics in TKA with mal-aligned femoral components influence and/or trigger arthrofibrosis in TKA.
Accepted landmarks for determining rotation include the posterior condyles, Whiteside’s line, arbitrary 3-4° of external rotation, and transepicondylar axis (TEA). All methods require anatomical identification, which may be variable. The purpose of this study was to radiologically evaluate femoral component rotation (CT analysis) based on a method that references to the tibial axis and balanced flexion-tension.
Cementless fixation in TKA remains controversial because of less predictable osseointegration and difficulty interpreting fixation interfaces. Radiolucent zone analysis (RLZ) of plain radiographs is the only practical method of evaluating the fixation interface.
Correction of fixed valgus is a challenge in primary TKA. Achieving patello-femoral and femoral-tibial stability requires superficial/deep lateral side releases if non-constrained prostheses are utilized. The medial approach has disadvantages with more reported complications. The direct lateral approach, with/without tubercle osteotomy, is an approach option utilized in two reporting centers.
The purpose was to evaluate clinical and radiographical outcome of 1777 patella non-resurfacing in two major centres. Patella management in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is of concern when resurfaced (multiple problems) or when non-resurfaced (pain). Reports in the literature are frequently non-specific regarding surgical approach, femoral rotation alignment, and femoral design. 1777 non-resurfaced patella TKAs from two large centres were evaluated with a 2 to 15 year follow-up, using similar selection criterion, operative techniques, and prostheses. Patient demographics included 70% females (mean age 68 years). Diagnoses included 8% rheumatoid. Radiologic skyline view assessment of 200 cases (100 from each centre) with longest (mean 9. 2 years) follow-up, formed a subset group. Clinical success rate was good/excellent in 94. 6%; scores improved from 59 to 87. Patella-related anterior knee pain requiring re-operation was 1. 1% (19 patients), only 9 (0. 55%) of which had unequivocal improvement following re-surfacing. Twenty-one cases (1. 2%) underwent “incidental” patella resurfacing at revision for other reasons. There were no patella subluxations or dislocations. Two hundred cases with longest follow-up revealed perfect congruent contact in 97. 5% with no lateral deviation (mid-sulcus to patella crown) over 6 mm. Asymptomatic remodelling was noted in 8%, with relative sclerosis and height loss of the lateral facet in 2. 5%. No changes correlated with clinical symptoms. These data support a success rate of over 98% with non-resurfaced patella in a mobile-bearing (LCS) TKA system that includes a patella friendly design, proper soft tissue management, and femoral component rotational alignment using the tibial shaft axis and balanced flexion tension gap method.
Patellofemoral problems are a common cause of morbidity and reoperation after total knee arthroplasty. We made a prospective study of 52 patients who had bilateral arthroplasty (104 knees) and in whom the patella was resurfaced on one side and not on the other. A movable-bearing prosthesis with an anatomical femoral groove was implanted on both sides by the same surgeon using an otherwise identical technique. The mean follow-up was 5.24 years (2 to 10). In the 30 available patients (60 knees) there was no difference between the two sides in subjective preference, performance on ascending and descending stairs or the incidence of anterior knee pain. Radiographs showed no differences in prosthetic alignment, femoral condylar height, patellar congruency or joint line position. The use of an appropriate prosthetic design and careful surgical technique can provide equivalent results after knee arthroplasty with or without patellar resurfacing. Given the indications and criteria, which we discuss, retention of the patellar surface is an acceptable option.