Investigations into the response to implant debris tend to concentrate on how a population of cells proliferate in the presence of implant material, and how the regulation of cytokines change. For the problem of cobalt-chromium (CoCr) implants this has been done for osteoblasts and osteoclasts to understand how bone resorption, leading to aseptic loosening, is occurring. However, investigating the formation of the extracellular-matrix (ECM) may give a better indication of the mechanisms occurring. ECM is excreted from cells and is important for adhesion, structure, signaling and growth. Type I collagen is the most abundant protein in the ECM and is known to direct tissue development and is therefore a key part of understanding the mechanism behind aseptic loosening. 3T3-fibroblasts were seeded in Dulbecco's Modified Eagle Medium (DMEM) and supplemented with 100mM ascorbic acid. Every 48hours cells were fed with DMEM and doped with Co and Cr ions until fixation. Sirius Red dye was used to bind to the type I collagen, then removed using NaOH and analysed using UV absorption to show relative amounts of collagen. Type I collagen gel was formed in the presence of Co and Cr ions with and without DMEM and the fibers were imaged using AFM.Background
Methods
There is much current debate concerning wear and corrosion at the taper junctions of large head total hip replacements, particularly metal-on-metal hips. Is such damage a modern concern or has it always occurred in total hip replacement but not previously noted. To investigate this five explanted V40 Exeter femoral stems (Stryker Howmedica) were obtained following revision surgery at a single centre. In all cases, the 24–26 mm femoral heads were still attached. In conventional ‘small head’ modular hip prostheses such as the Exeter, negligible wear and corrosion is seen at the taper junction of explanted devices.Introduction
Hypothesis
Total hip prostheses which use a ceramic head within a metal liner are a relatively recent introduction. As such, survivorship rates from independent centres alongside explant analysis are rare. The early experience with this novel ceramic-on-metal (CoM) bearing couple is reported. All CoM hips implanted between 2008 and 2009 at a single hospital by a single surgeon were reviewed. Radiographs were analysed using EBRA software to determine acetabular cup inclination and anteversion angles. Blood metal ion concentrations were measured using inductively coupled plasma mass spectroscopy (ICPMS). Explants were measured for bearing surface and taper wear using a high precision co-ordinate measuring machine. The roughness of the articulating surfaces was measured with a non-contact profilometer.Introduction
Methods and Materials
The worldwide withdrawal of the DePuy Articular Surface Replacement (ASR) device in both its resurfacing and total hip replacement (THR) form on 26 August 2010, after 93,000 were implanted worldwide, has had major implications. The 2010 National Joint Registry for England and Wales quoted figures of 12-13% failure at five years; however these figures may be an underestimate. In 2004 a single surgeon prospective study of the ASR bearing surface was undertaken. Presented are the Adverse Reaction to Metal Debris (ARMD) failure rates of the ASR resurfacing and ASR THR systems. The diagnosis of ARMD was made by the senior author and was based on clinical history, examination, ultrasound findings, metal ion analysis of blood and joint fluid, operative findings and histopathological analysis of tissues retrieved at revision. Acetabular cup position in vivo was determined using EBRA software. Mean follow up was 52 months (24-81) and 70 patients were beyond 6 years of the procedure at the time of writing. Kaplan Meier survival analysis was carried out firstly with joints designated ‘failure’ if the patient had undergone revision surgery or if the patient had been listed for revision. A second survival analysis was carried out with a failure defined as a serum cobalt concentration > 7microgrammes/L (MHRA guideline from MDA-2010-069). Full explant analysis was carried out for retrieved prostheses.Background
Patients and methods
Metal-on-metal hip resurfacing prostheses are a relatively recent intervention for relieving the symptoms of common musculoskeletal diseases such as osteoarthritis. While some short term clinical studies have offered positive results, in a minority of cases there is a recognised issue of femoral fracture, which commonly occurs in the first few months following the operation. This problem has been explained by a surgeon's learning curve and notching of the femur but, to date, studies of explanted early fracture components have been limited. Tribological analysis was carried out on fourteen retrieved femoral components of which twelve were revised after femoral fracture and two for avascular necrosis (AVN). Eight samples were Durom (Zimmer, Indiana, USA) devices and six were Articular Surface Replacements (ASR, DePuy, Leeds, United Kingdom). One AVN retrieval was a Durom, the other an ASR. The mean time to fracture was 3.4 months. The AVNs were retrieved after 16 months (Durom) and 38 months (ASR). Volumetric wear rates were determined using a Mitutoyo Legex 322 co-ordinate measuring machine (scanning accuracy within 1 micron) and a bespoke computer program. The method was validated against gravimetric calculations for volumetric wear using a sample femoral head that was artificially worn in vitro. At 5mm3, 10mm3, and 15mm3 of material removal, the method was accurate to within 0.5mm3. Surface roughness data was collected using a Zygo NewView500 interferometer (resolution 1nm). Mean wear rates of 17.74mm3/year were measured from the fracture components. Wear rates for the AVN retrievals were 0.43mm3/year and 3.45mm3/year. Mean roughness values of the fracture retrievals (PV = 0.754nm, RMS = 0.027nm) were similar to the AVNs (PV = 0.621nm, RMS = 0.030nm), though the AVNs had been in vivo for significantly longer. Theoretical lubrication calculations were carried out which found that in both AVN retrievals and in seven of the twelve cases of femoral fracture the roughening was sufficient to change the lubrication regime from fluid film to mixed. Three of these surfaces were bordering on the boundary lubrication regime. The results show that even before the femoral fracture, wear rates and roughness values were high and the implants were performing poorly.
Wear debris induced osteolysis is a recognized complication in conventional metal-on-polyethylene hip arthroplasty. One method of achieving wear reduction is through the use of metal-on-metal articulations. One of the latest manifestations of this biomaterial combination is in designs of hip resurfacing which are aimed at younger, more active patients. But, do these metal-on-metal hip resurfacings show low wear when implanted into patients? Using a Mitutoyo Legex 322 co-ordinate measuring machine (scanning accuracy less than 1 micron) and a bespoke computer program, volumetric wear measurements for retrieved Articular Surface Replacements (ASR, DePuy) metal-on-metal hip resurfacings were undertaken. Measurements were validated against gravimetric calculations for volumetric wear using a sample femoral head that was artificially worn in vitro. At 5mm3, 10mm3, and 15mm3 of material removal, the method was shown to be accurate to within 0.5mm3. Thirty-two femoral heads and twenty-two acetabular cups were measured. Acetabular cups exhibited mean volumetric wear of 29.00mm3 (range 1.35 - 109.72mm3) and a wear rate of 11.02mm3/year (range 0.30 - 63.59mm3/year). Femoral heads exhibited mean wear of 22.41mm3 (range 0.72 - 134.22mm3) and a wear rate of 8.72mm3/year (range 0.21 - 31.91mm3/year). In the 22 cases where both head and cup from the same prosthesis were available, mean total wear rates of 21.66mm3/year (range 0.51 - 95.50mm3/year) were observed. Revision was necessitated by one of five effects; early femoral neck fracture (4 heads), avascular necrosis (AVN) (2 heads, 1 cup), infection (1 head, 1 cup), adverse reaction to metal debris (ARMD) (19 heads, 18 cups) or ARMD fracture (6 heads, 2 cups). Mean paired wear rates for the AVN and infection retrievals were 0.51mm3/year and 3.98mm3/year respectively. In vitro tests typically offer wear rates for metal-on-metal devices in the region of 2-4mm3. Mean paired wear rates for ARMD and ARMD fracture were 17.64mm3/year and 68.5mm3/year respectively, significantly greater than those expected from in vitro tests. In the 4 cases of early fracture, only the heads were revised so a combined wear rate calculation was not possible. The heads exhibited mean wear rate of 8.26mm3/year. These high wear rates are of concern.
