Aims

Limb salvage surgery (LSS) is the primary treatment option for primary bone malignancy. It involves the removal of bone and tissue, followed by reconstruction with endoprosthetic replacements (EPRs) to prevent amputation. Trabecular metal (TM) collars have been developed to encourage bone ingrowth (osseointegration (OI)) into EPRs. The primary aim of this study was to assess whether OI occurs when TM collars are used in EPRs for tumour.

Introduction

A significant burden of disease exists with respect to critical sized bone defects; outcomes are unpredictable and often poor. There is no absolute agreement on what constitutes a “critically-sized” bone defect however it is widely considered as one that would not heal spontaneously despite surgical stabilisation, thus requiring re-operation. The aetiology of such defects is varied. High-energy trauma with soft tissue loss and periosteal stripping, bone infection and tumour resection all require extensive debridement and the critical-sized defects generated require careful consideration and strategic management. Current management practice of these defects lacks consensus. Existing literature tells us that tibial defects 25mm or great have a poor natural history; however, there is no universally agreed management strategy and there remains a significant evidence gap. Drawing its origins from musculoskeletal oncology, the Capanna technique describes a hybrid mode of reconstruction. Mass allograft is combined with a vascularised fibula autograft, allowing the patient to benefit from the favourable characteristics of two popular reconstruction techniques. Allograft confers initial mechanical stability with autograft contributing osteogenic, inductive and conductive capacity to encourage union. Secondarily its inherent vascularity affords the construct the ability to withstand deleterious effects of stressors such as infection that may threaten union. The strengths of this hybrid construct we believe can be used within the context of critical-sized bone defects within tibial trauma to the same success as seen within tumour reconstruction.

Aims

The primary objective of this study was to compare the postoperative infection rate between negative pressure wound therapy (NPWT) and conventional dressings for closed incisions following soft-tissue sarcoma (STS) surgery. Secondary objectives were to compare rates of adverse wound events and functional scores.

National guidelines recommend that trauma centres have a designated consultant for managing metastatic bone disease (MBD). No such system exists in Scotland. We compared MBD cases in a trauma hospital to a national bone tumour centre to characterise differences in management and outcome.

Consecutive patients with metastatic proximal femoral lesions referred to a trauma unit and a national sarcoma centre were compared over a seven-year period (minimum follow-up one year).

From Jan 2010-Dec 2016, 195 patients were referred to the trauma unit and 68 to the tumour centre. The trauma unit tended to see older patients (mean 72 vs. 65 years, p<0001) with cancers of poorer prognosis (e.g. 31% 61/195 vs. 13% 9/68 lung primary, p<0.001).

Both units had similar operative rates but patients referred to the tumour centre were more likely to have endoprosthetic reconstruction (EPR 44% tumour vs. 3% trauma centre, p<0.001). Patients with an EPR survived longer than those with other types of fixation (81% 17/21 vs. 31% 35/112 one-year survival, p<0.001). Patients undergoing EPR were more likely to have an isolated metastasis (62% 13/21 vs. 17% 4/24, p<0.001). One patient from each centre had a revision for failed metalwork.

There was a difference in caseload referred to both units, with the tumour centre seeing younger patients with a better prognosis. Patients suitable for endoprostheses were more likely to have isolated metastatic disease and a longer survival after surgery. An MBD pathway is required to ensure such patients are identified and referred for specialist management where appropriate.

The modified Glasgow Prognostic Score (mGPS) is a validated prognostic indicator in various carcinomas as demonstrated by several meta-analyses.

The mGPS includes pre-operative CRP and albumin values to calculate a score from 0–2 that correlates with overall outcome. Scores of 2 are associated with a poorer outcome.

Our aim was to assess if the mGPS is reliable as a prognostic indicator for soft tissue sarcoma (STS) patients.

All patients with a STS diagnosed during years 2010–2014 were identified using our prospectively collected MSK oncology database. We performed a retrospective case note review examining demographics, preoperative blood results and outcomes (no recurrence, local recurrence, metastatic disease and death).

94 patients were included. 56% were female and 53% were over 50 years. 91% of tumours were high grade (Trojani 2/3) and 73% were >5cm. 45 patients had an mGPS score of 0, 16 were mGPS 1 and 33 were mGPS 2. On univariate analysis, an mGPS of 0 or 2 was statically significant with regards to outcome (p=0.012 and p=0.005 respectively).

We have demonstrated that pre-treatment mGPS is an important factor in predicting oncological outcome. A score of 0 relates to an improved prognosis whilst a score of 2 relates to an increased risk of developing metastases and death. mGPS as a prognostic indicator was not affected by either the tumour size or grade.

We believe that a pre-operative mGPS should be calculated to help predict oncological outcome and in turn influence management. Further work is being undertaken with a larger cohort.

Extracorporeal irradiation of an excised tumour-bearing segment of bone followed by its re-implantation is a technique used in bone sarcoma surgery for limb salvage when the bone is of reasonable quality. There is no agreement among previous studies about the dose of irradiation to be given: up to 300 Gy have been used.

We investigated the influence of extracorporeal irradiation on the elastic and viscoelastic properties of bone. Bone was harvested from mature cattle and subdivided into 13 groups: 12 were exposed to increasing levels of irradiation: one was not and was used as a control. The specimens, once irradiated, underwent mechanical testing in saline at 37°C.

The mechanical properties of each group, including Young’s modulus, storage modulus and loss modulus, were determined experimentally and compared with the control group.

There were insignificant changes in all of these mechanical properties with an increasing level of irradiation.

We conclude that the overall mechanical effect of high levels of extracorporeal irradiation (300 Gy) on bone is negligible. Consequently the dose can be maximised to reduce the risk of local tumour recurrence.

Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2015;97-B:1152–6.

Extracorporeal irradiation and re-implantation of a bone segment is a technique employed in bone sarcoma surgery for limb salvage in the setting of reasonable bone stock. There is neither consensus nor rationale given for the dosage of irradiation used in previous studies, with values of up to 300Gy applied. We investigated the influence of extracorporeal irradiation on the elastic and viscoelastic properties of bone. Bone specimens were extracted from mature cattle and subdivided into thirteen groups; twelve groups exposed to increasing levels of irradiation and a control group. The specimens, once irradiated, underwent mechanical testing in saline at 37°C.

Mechanical properties were calculated by experimental means which included Young's Modulus, Poisson's Ratio, Dissipation Factor, Storage Modulus, Loss Modulus and Dynamic Modulus. These were all obtained for comparison of the irradiated specimens to the control group.

We found there to be a statistically significant increase in Poisson's ratio after increasing irradiation doses up to 300Gy were applied. However, there was negligible change in all other mechanical properties of bone that were assessed. Therefore, we conclude that the overall mechanical effect of high levels of extracorporeal irradiation (300Gy) is minute, and can be administered to reduce the risk of malignancy recurrence.

Extracorporeal irradiation and re-implantation of a bone segment is a technique employed in bone sarcoma surgery for limb salvage in the setting of reasonable bone stock. There is neither consensus nor rationale given for the dosage of irradiation used in previous studies, with values of up to 300Gy applied. We investigated the influence of extracorporeal irradiation on the elastic and viscoelastic properties of bone. Bone specimens were extracted from mature cattle and subdivided into thirteen groups; twelve groups exposed to increasing levels of irradiation and a control group. The specimens, once irradiated, underwent mechanical testing in saline at 37°C.

Mechanical properties were calculated by experimental means which included Young's Modulus, Storage Modulus and Loss Modulus. These were all obtained for comparison of the irradiated specimens to the control group.

There were non-significant negligible changes in all of the mechanical properties of bone that were assessed with increasing dosage of irradiation. Therefore, we conclude that the overall mechanical effect of high levels of extracorporeal irradiation (300Gy) is minute, and can be administered to reduce the risk of malignancy recurrence.

We report our experience of using a computer navigation system to aid resection of malignant musculoskeletal tumours of the pelvis and limbs and, where appropriate, their subsequent reconstruction. We also highlight circumstances in which navigation should be used with caution.

We resected a musculoskeletal tumour from 18 patients (15 male, three female, mean age of 30 years (13 to 75) using commercially available computer navigation software (Orthomap 3D) and assessed its impact on the accuracy of our surgery. Of nine pelvic tumours, three had a biological reconstruction with extracorporeal irradiation, four underwent endoprosthetic replacement (EPR) and two required no bony reconstruction. There were eight tumours of the bones of the limbs. Four diaphyseal tumours underwent biological reconstruction. Two patients with a sarcoma of the proximal femur and two with a sarcoma of the proximal humerus underwent extra-articular resection and, where appropriate, EPR. One soft-tissue sarcoma of the adductor compartment which involved the femur was resected and reconstructed using an EPR. Computer navigation was used to aid reconstruction in eight patients.

Histological examination of the resected specimens revealed tumour-free margins in all patients. Post-operative radiographs and CT showed that the resection and reconstruction had been carried out as planned in all patients where navigation was used. In two patients, computer navigation had to be abandoned and the operation was completed under CT and radiological control.

The use of computer navigation in musculoskeletal oncology allows accurate identification of the local anatomy and can define the extent of the tumour and proposed resection margins. Furthermore, it helps in reconstruction of limb length, rotation and overall alignment after resection of an appendicular tumour.

Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2015;97-B:258–64.

Introduction

Needle guided biopsy of a suspected musculoskeletal malignancy has become increasingly popular as an effective modality for diagnosis. Biopsy performed in a safe manner should be performed in a centre which is also capable of performing the definitive management of such conditions. Our aim was to determine accuracy and success rates of the image guided biopsies performed by our service.

Primary bony tumours of the elbow account for approximately 1% of all osseous tumours. The delayed diagnosis is commonly reported in the literature as a result of lack of clinician familiarity. We present the largest series of primary bone tumours of the elbow in the English literature.

We sought to identify characteristics specific to primary elbow tumours and compare these to the current literature. We discuss cases of misdiagnosis and reasons for any delay in diagnosis. The authors also recommend a collaborative protocol for the diagnosis and management of these rare tumours.

A prospectively collected national database of all bone tumours is maintained by an independent clerk. The registry and case notes were retrospectively reviewed from January 1954 until June 2013. Eighty cases of primary osseous elbow tumours were studied. Tumours were classified as benign or malignant and then graded according to the Enneking spectrum.

There were no benign latent cases in this series. All cases in this series required surgical intervention. These cases presented with persistent rest pain, with or without swelling. The distal humerus was responsible for the majority and most aggressive of cases. The multidisciplinary approach at a specialist centre is integral to management. Misdiagnosis was evident in 12.5 % of all cases. Malignant tumours carried a 5-year mortality of 61%. Benign tumours exhibited a 19% recurrence rate and in particular, giant cell tumour was very aggressive. The evolution in treatment modalities has clearly benefited patients.

Clinicians should be aware that elbow tumours can be initially misdiagnosed as soft tissue injuries or cysts. The suspicion of a tumour should be raised in the patient with unremitting, unexplained non-mechanical bony elbow pain. We suggest an investigatory and treatment protocol to avoid a delay to diagnosis. With high rates of local recurrence, we recommend regular postoperative reviews.

Bone and soft tissue sarcoma is an uncommon. Benign swellings are, however, common. An approach to tertiary referral is required to accommodate the need for specialist interpretation of all concerning referrals, while maintaining an acceptable time to diagnosis and management.

We aim to describe a new tertiary sarcoma service, utilising modern communication technology and the “virtual clinic” model through a multidisciplinary approach.

All suspected musculoskeletal sarcoma cases are discussed, with available history and imaging, in a virtual clinic by a multidisciplinary team within a week of referral. Clinic decisions allow either immediate discharge, progress to further investigation, or clinic appointment.

Data from the first thousand patients was prospectively collected for initial management decision, and final intervention, and in 625 for waiting time. Almost one third of patients were discharged from the virtual clinic without physical appointment. 45% were sent for further investigation prior to first clinic appointment. Of 625 patients with referral data, mean waiting time was 5.1 days to virtual clinic. For malignant bone and soft tissue tumours, not requiring neoadjuvant treatment, median time to surgery from virtual clinic review was 37 and 47 days respectively.

Through a virtual clinic approach to tertiary sarcoma care, almost a third of referrals have been managed quickly without need for an unnecessary appointment. For 45% of patients the first appointment will be after all necessary investigations have been performed to facilitate rapid decision making. This enables shorter clinic waiting times and rapid transition from first referral to definitive management.

The surgical management of musculoskeletal tumours is a challenging problem, particularly in pelvic and diaphyseal tumour resection where accurate determination of bony transection points is extremely important to optimise oncologic, functional and reconstructive options. The use of computer assisted navigation in these cases could improve surgical precision and achieve pre-planned oncological margins with improved accuracy.

We resected musculoskeletal tumours in ten patients using commercially available computer navigation software (Orthomap 3D, Stryker UK Ltd). Of the five pelvic tumours, two underwent biological reconstruction with extra corporeal irradiation, two endoprosthetic replacement (EPR) and one did not require bony reconstruction. Three tibial diaphyseal tumours had biological reconstruction. One patient with proximal femoral sarcoma underwent extra-articular resection and EPR. One soft tissue sarcoma of the adductor compartment involving the femur was resected with EPR.

Histological examination of the resected specimens revealed tumour free margins in all cases. Post-operative radiographs and CT show resection and reconstruction as planned in all cases. Several learning points were identified related to juvenile bony anatomy and intra-operative registration.

The use of computer navigation in musculoskeletal oncology allows integration of local anatomy and tumour extent to identify resection margins accurately. Furthermore, it can aid in reconstruction following tumour resection. Our experience thus far has been encouraging. Further clinical trials are required to evaluate its long-term impact on functional & oncological outcomes.

Primary bone tumours of the clavicle are rare. Currently the existing literature is limited to a single case series and case reports or cases. Information regarding the patient's demographics and tumour types is therefore limited.

The aim of this study was to investigate the and also suggest a management protocol for suspected primary bone tumours of the clavicle. We retrospectively reviewed the Scottish Bone Tumour Register from January 1971 to January 2012 and included all primary bone tumours of the clavicle.

We identified only sixteen primary bone tumours over forty one year's highlighting the rarity of these tumours. There were ten benign and six malignant tumours with a mean age of 32 years (Range 4 to 66). The average presentation to orthopaedics after onset of symptoms was two months with five patients presenting following a pathological fracture. Malignant tumour types identified were consistent with previous literature with two cases of Ewing's sarcoma and osteosarcoma and a single case of osteosarcoma post radiotherapy and a single case of chondrosarcoma. Benign tumours were treated effectively with intralesional procedures. Malignant tumours were treated with wide local excision and subtotal or total clavicle excision.

We suggest an investigatory and treatment protocol for patients with a suspected primary bone tumour of the clavicle. This is the largest series of primary bone tumours of the clavicle in the literature.

The surgical management of musculoskeletal tumours is a challenging problem, particularly in pelvic and diaphyseal tumour resection where accurate determination of bony transection points is extremely important to optimise oncologic, functional and reconstructive options. The use of computer assisted navigation in these cases could improve surgical precision.

We resected musculoskeletal tumours in fifteen patients using commercially available computer navigation software (Orthomap 3D). Of the eight pelvic tumours, three underwent biological reconstruction with extra corporeal irradiation; three endoprosthetic replacement (EPR) and two required no bony reconstruction. Four diaphyseal tumours had biological reconstruction. Two patients with proximal femoral sarcoma underwent extra-articular resection and EPR. One soft tissue sarcoma of the adductor compartment involving the femur was resected with EPR.

Histological examination of the resected specimens revealed tumour free margins in all cases. Post-operative radiographs and CT show resection and reconstruction as planned in all cases. Several learning points were identified related to juvenile bony anatomy and intra-operative registration.

The use of computer navigation in musculoskeletal oncology allows integration of local anatomy and tumour extent to identify resection margins accurately. Furthermore, it can aid in reconstruction following tumour resection. Our experience thus far has been encouraging.

Most lumps found in the extremity are benign. Some, however, are not. An approach to tertiary referral is required to accommodate the need for specialist evaluation of all concerning lumps, while maintaining an acceptable time to diagnosis and definitive management. We describe a new approach to tertiary sarcoma service, utilising modern communication technology and the “virtual clinic” approach.

Background

The surgical management of musculoskeletal tumours is a challenging problem, particularly in pelvic and diaphyseal tumour resection where accurate determination of bony transection points is extremely important to optimise oncologic, functional and reconstructive options. The use of computer assisted navigation in these cases could improve surgical precision.

Introduction

Bony tumours of the foot account for approximately 3% of all osseous tumours. However, literature regarding os calcis and talar tumours comprises individual case reports, short case series or literature reviews with no recent large series.

Introduction

The use of computer navigation has a potential to allow precise tumour resection and accurate reconstruction of the resultant defect. This can be useful in difficult areas such as pelvis, diaphyseal (intercalary) resections and geometric bony resections.

Introduction

Bony tumours of foot account for approximately 3% of osseous tumours. However, literature regarding calcaneal tumours comprises individual case reports, short case series or literature reviews, with last large case series in 1973. Literature on bony tumours of the talus is limited to case reports only.