Uncemented component retention with polyethylene (PE) liner and femoral head exchange is commonly used to treat periprosthetic osteolysis. The purpose was to determine long-term implant survivorship, risk factors for aseptic failures, clinical outcomes, and complications following PE liner and head exchange.

We identified 116 hips in 110 patients treated with PE liner and head exchange for osteolysis from 1993 to 2004. The mean age was 58, 64 were women, and mean follow-up was 11 years.

Implant survivorship free from all-cause revisions was 91% at 5-years, 81% at 10-years, and 69% at 15-years. Reasons for re-revision included subsequent conventional PE wear and osteolysis in 7 (6%), aseptic acetabular loosening in 5 (4%), and instability in 5 hips (4%). Mean time to revision for aseptic acetabular loosening was 4 years (range 1 – 7 years). Risk factors for aseptic acetabular loosening included acetabular zones of pre-revision osteolysis, percentage of cup involvement, and size of osteolytic defects. Absolute risk of acetabular loosening was 23% for three zones of osteolysis (Relative Risk (RR) 12, p<0.01), 40% if osteolysis involved more than half the cup circumference (RR 14, p<0.01), and 21% for defects greater than 600 mm² (RR 11, p<0.01). Harris hip scores improved from 77 to 87 (p<0.01). The most common complication was dislocation (16%).

These data quantify risk of subsequent component loosening when well fixed, uncemented implants are retained during operations for osteolysis, and may inform operative decisions regarding shell retention versus revision.