The purpose of the study was to compare the mechanical properties, oxidation and wear resistance of a vitamin E blended and moderately crosslinked polyethylene for total knee arthroplasty (MXE) in comparison with clinically established polyethylene materials.

The following polyethylene materials were tested: CPE (30 kGy e-beam sterilized), XLPE (75 kGy gamma crosslinked @ 100°C), ViXLPE (0.1 % vitamin E blended, 80 kGy e-beam crosslinked @ 100°C), and MXE (0.1 % vitamin E blended polyethylene, 30 kGy gamma sterilized). For the different tests, the polyethylene materials were either unaged or artificially aged for two or six weeks according to ASTM F2003-02.

The oxidation index was measured based on ASTM F2102 at a 1 mm depth. Small punch testing was performed based on ASTM F2977. Mechanical properties were measured on unaged materials according to ASTM D638.

Wear simulation was performed on a load controlled 3 + 1 station knee wear simulator (EndoLab GmbH, Thansau, Germany) capable of reproducing loads and movement of highly demanding activities (HDA) as well as ISO 14243-1 load profiles. The load profiles were applied for 5 million cycles (mc) or delamination of the polyethylene components. Medium size AS e.motion^® PS Pro (Aesculap AG, Tuttlingen, Germany) femoral and tibial components with a ZrN-multilayer surface, as well as Columbus^® CR cobalt-chrome alloy femoral and tibial components were tested. Particle analysis was performed on the serum samples of the ISO 14243-1 wear simulations based on ISO 17853:2011 and ASTM F1877.

The analysis of the mechanical properties show that moderately crosslinked polyethylene (MXE) might be a superior material for total knee arthroplasty applications [Schwiesau et al. 2021]. The addition of vitamin E in a moderately crosslinked polyethylene prevented its oxidation, kept its mechanical characteristics, and maintained a low wear, even under a HDA knee wear simulation.

Total knee arthroplasty is a well established treatment for degenerative joint disease with good clinical results. However, complications may occur due to a biological response to polyethylene wear particles, leading to osteolysis and aseptic loosening, as well as local and systemic hypersensitivity reactions triggered by metal ions and particles such as chromium, cobalt and molybdenum. Moreover, there is an increasing demand on the performance of these implants, as this treatment is also performed in heavier, younger and middle-aged adults who have a significant physical activity and higher life expectancy. The purpose of the following study was to compare the wear characteristics and performance of a zirconium nitride (ZrN) coated knee implant, designed for patients with metal ion hypersensitivity, against the clinically established cobalt-chromium (CoCr) version under a high demanding activities wear simulation.

Medium size AS Columbus® DD (Aesculap AG, Tuttlingen, Germany) femoral and tibial components with a ZrN surface were tested in comparison with the cobalt-chromium version Columbus® DD. For both groups, ultra-high-molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) gliding surfaces (size T3, high 10 mm) were used. Wear simulation was performed on a load controlled 4 station knee wear simulator (EndoLab GmbH, Thansau, Germany) capable of reproducing loads and movement of daily activities measured in vivo (Bergmann et al, 2014) on 8 patients and normalized to a patient weight of 100 kg (Schwiesau et al, 2014). The load profiles were applied for 5 million cycles in a combination of 40% stairs up, 40% stairs down, 10% level walking, 8% chair raising and 2% deep squatting. Test serum was changed every 0.5 million cycles and all the components were cleaned and analyzed according to ISO 14243-2:2009(E). The gliding surfaces were evaluated for gravimetric wear and wear patterns, femur components analyzed for scratches and the test medium analyzed for metal ion concentration (cobalt, chromium, molybdenum and zirconium) using ICP-MS according to ISO 17294-2.

The present study showed a wear rate reduction for the ZrN group (1.01 ± 0.29 mg/million) in comparison with the CoCr group (2.40 ± 1.18 mg/million cycles). The articulation surface of the ZrN coated femurs remained polished after the testing period, whereas the uncoated femurs showed wear scratches. Furthermore, the metal ion release from the ZrN coated implants was reduced orders of magnitude in comparison with the CoCr implants through the entire test. These results demonstrate the efficiency of ZrN coated knee implants to reduce wear as well as to prevent metal ion release in the knee joint.

Background

Wear simulation in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is currently based on the most frequent activity – level walking. A decade ago multi-station knee wear simulators were introduced leading to optimisations of TKA designs, component surface finish and bearing materials. One major limitation is that current wear testing is mainly focused on abrasive-adhesive wear and in vitro testing does not reflect “delamination” as an essential clinical failure mode. The objective of our study was to use a highly demanding daily activities wear simulation to evaluate the delamination risk of polyethylene materials with and without vitamin E stabilisation.

Knee arthroplasty with a rotating hinge knee (RHK) prosthesis has become an important clinical treatment option for knee revisions and primary patients with severe varus or valgus deformities and instable ligaments. The rotational axle constraints the anterior-posterior shear and varus-valgus moments, but currently used polyethylene bushings may fail in the mid-term due to insufficient creep and wear resistance of the material. Due to that carbon-fibre-reinforced (CFR) PEEK as an alternativ bushing material with enhanced creep, wear and fatigue behaviour has been introduced in a RHK design [Grupp 2011, Giurea 2014]. The objective of our study was to compare results from the pre-clinical biotribological characterisation to ex vivo findings on a series of retrieved implants.

In vitro wear simulation according to ISO 14243-1 was performed on rotating hinge knee devices (EnduRo® Aesculap, Germany) made out of cobalt-chromium and of a ZrN multi-layer ceramic coating for 5 million cycles. The mobile gliding surfaces were made out of polyethylene (GUR 1020, β-irradiated 30 ± 2 kGy). For the bushings of the rotational and flexion axles and the flanges a new bearing material based on CFR-PEEK with 30% PAN fiber content was used.

Analysis of 12 retrieved EnduRo^® RHK systems in cobalt-chromium and ZrN multi-layer in regard to

-

loosening torques in comparison with initial fastening torques

with a focus on the four CFR-PEEK components integrated in the EnduRo^® RHK design.

For the rotating hinge knee design with flexion bushing and flanges out of CFR-PEEK the volumetric wear rates were 2.3 ± 0.48 mm³/million cycles (cobalt-chromium) and 0.21 ± 0.02 mm³/million cycles (ZrN multi-layer), a 10.9-fold reduction (p = 0.0016). The UHMWPE and CFR-PEEK particles were comparable in size and morphology and predominantly in submicron size [5]. The biological response to representative sub-micron sized CFR-PEEK particles has been demonstrated in vivo based on the leucoyte-endothelian-cell interactions in the synovia of a murine intra-articular knee model by Utzschneider 2010. Schwiesau 2013 extracted the frequency of daily activities in hip and knee replacement patients from literature and estimated an average of 1.76 million gait cycles per year. Thus, the 5 million cycles of in vitro wear testing reflect a mean in vivo service life of 2.9 years, which fits to the time in vivo of 12–60 months of the retrieved RHK devices. The in vitro surface articulation pattern of the wear simulation tests are comparable to findings on retrieved CFR-PEEK components for both types of articulations – cobalt-chromium and ZrN multi-layer coating.

For the rotating hinge knee design the findings on retrieved implants demonstrate the high suitability of CFR-PEEK as a biomaterial for highly loaded bearings, such as RHK bushings and flanges in articulation to cobalt-chromium and to a ZrN multi-layer coating.

Summary Statement

To evaluate carbon-fiber-reinforced PEEK as alternative biomaterial for total disc arthroplasty a closed loop between biotribology (in vitro), application of sterile particle suspensions in the epidural space of rabbits and biological response in vivo was established.