Introduction High precision of axis alignement in Total Knee Arthroplasty by usage of navigation tools is a known fact. However, a common disadvantage of navigation tools is the additional time needed for calibration. Especially in time/cost-sensitive hospital environments this can lead to a neglection of navigation tools usage. In this study we address work-economics during navigation assisted total knee arthroplasty. Specifically, we introduce the concept of a well-trained navigator assistant who performs navigation related work steps during surgery while the primary surgeon concentrates on the remaining work-steps.
In a prospective study of primary TKA we compared environmental parameters of surgeries performed with and without the Navigator Concept.
Materials and Methods 60 Total Knee Arthroplasties were performed using an active navigation system (Stryker Navigation System) (40) or a conventional internal/external alignement jig for implantation of the Interax Knee endoprostheses. Half of the navigated knee arthroplasties were performed using a conventional set-up with a primary surgeon and two assistants serving the navigation system and performing the relevant surgical steps. The other half was done by surgeon teams of a primary surgeon, a navigator assistant and a second assistant. The surgical steps were broken down to a complex work-sharing system. The teams were intensively trained in their work-share by simulating an artificial TKA in a specially designed TKA-Navigation lab. During surgery, the timing of individual steps was recorded. Pre- and postoperative x-rays of the limbs were taken and digitized to an computerized axis-measurement system. Data of both groups were compared using ANOVA and Tuckey post-hoc tests.
Results Results showed a significant difference in surgery time between the three groups (p=0,01) with equivalent surgery times of the conventional and navigator concept group, while the remaining navigated group showed longer surgery times. Axis alignments were statistically not influenced, however demonstrated a tendency to higher precision in the navigator concept group.
Discussion This study is the first to address work-economics in navigated TKA. With the introduction of a specifically trained navigator assistant, a precise work-sharing plan and an intensive training lab, high precision in TKA can be achieved by navigation usage even in a highly cost-sensitive environment. The basis for success, however, is support and investment in training of team surgeons. This concept may provide the basis for other musculoskeletal surgeries demanding both high-tech for precision and time-effectiveness for cost reduction.
