Aim: As the shoulder and elbow joints share a common objective – spatial positioning of the hand – can the Modified Constant Score of shoulder function be applied to function at the elbow?

Method & Results: All patients with isolated elbow pathology over an eighteen-month period were assessed. Acute fractures and patients with shoulder and/or wrist pathology were excluded. Upper limb function was assessed using the Modified Constant Score and the Mayo Elbow Performance Index. A total of 48 patients with a variety of elbow pathologies were assessed. The mean patient age was 47.8 years, and 26 patients were male. The correlation between the two scoring systems was highly significant (correlation 0.91, t = < 0.001)

Conclusion: The Modified Constant Score may be used as an assessment of both shoulder and elbow function.

Duplicate publication in orthopaedic journals may further an author’s academic career but this is at the cost of both scientific integrity and knowledge. Multiple publications of the same work increase the workload of editorial boards, misguide the reader and affect the process of meta-analysis. We found that of 343 ‘original’ articles published in the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery in 1999, 26 (7.6%) had some degree of redundancy.

The prevalence of duplicate publications in the orthopaedic literature appears to be less than that in other surgical specialties but it is still a matter of concern. It is the author’s responsibility to notify the editor of any duality when submitting a paper for publication.