UKA is functionally superior to TKA, with kinematics similar to native knees, nevertheless, UKA implants are used in less than 10% of cases. While advantages of UKA are recognized, ACL-deficiency is generally considered a contraindication. The hypothesis of this study was that fix bearing UKA in ACL-deficient knees, with appropriate adaptation of implant placement, would result in similar kinematic trends to conventional UKA with an intact ACL. Ten conventional UKA patients were compared to eight patients with the same implant but a deficient ACL. A 50% tibial slope reduction was applied to compensate for instability resulting from the deficient ACL. Knee kinematics were evaluated using a moving fluoroscope allowing to track the knee joint during deep knee bend, level walking, ramp descent and stair descent. The results were further compared to six TKA patients.BACKGROUND
METHODS
One of the key factors responsible for altered kinematics and joint stability following contemporary total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is resection of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). Therefore, retaining the ACL is often considered to be the “holy grail” of TKA. However, ACL retention can present several technical challenges, and in some cases may not be viable due to an absent or non-functional ACL. Therefore, the goal of this research was to investigate whether substitution of ACL function through an anterior post mechanism could improve kinematic deficits of contemporary posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) retaining (CR) implants. This was done using KneeSIM, a previously established dynamic simulation tool based on an Oxford-rig setup. Deep knee bend, chair-sit, stair-ascent and walking were simulated for a contemporary ACL sacrificing (CR) implant, two ACL retaining implants, and an ACL substituting and PCL retaining implant. The motion of the femoral condyles relative to the tibia was recorded for kinematic comparisons. Our results revealed that, like ACL retaining implants, the ACL substituting implant could also provide kinematic improvements over contemporary ACL sacrificing implants by reducing early posterior femoral shift and preventing paradoxical anterior sliding. Such ACL substituting implants may be a valuable addition to the armament of joint surgeons, allowing them to provide improved knee function even when ACL retention is not feasible. Further research is required to investigate this mechanism in vitro and in vivo to verify the results of the simulations, and to determine whether kinematic improvements translate into improved clinical outcomes.
Dual-mobility (DM) liners provide increased range of motion and stability. However, large head diameters have been associated with anterior hip pain due to impingement with surrounding soft-tissues, particularly the iliopsoas. Further, during hip extension the liner can get trapped due to anterior soft-tissue impingement that resists rotation being imparted to the liner from posterior stem-liner contact. Over time this can cause liner rim damage, leading to intra-prosthetic dislocation of the small diameter inner head. To address this, an anatomically contoured dual mobility (ACDM) liner was designed to reduce the volume of the liner below the equator that can interact with soft-tissues The average uniaxial stiffness (350 N/mm), and average dimensions (width × thickness = 14mm × 4mm) of 10 cadaver psoas tendon samples were determined in a separate study. The iliopsoas tendon was modelled as a Yeoh hyper-elastic material, and the material constants were tuned to match the experimental uniaxial test data. Cadaver specific FEA models were created for 5 specimens (10 hips) using computed tomography (CT) scans. The implant components were modeled as being rigid relative to the iliopsoas tendon. The iliopsoas tendon was modelled as extending from its insertion point on the lesser trochanter to the psoas notch on the pelvis for hip flexion angles of −15°, 0°, 15° and 30°. Appropriately sized DM components were implanted virtually for each specimen. Once placed in its proper position, the liner was rotated about the flexion axis until it contacted the stem posteriorly to represent its orientation during hip extension (Introduction
Methods
In native knees anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and asymmetric shape of the tibial articular surface with a convex lateral plateau are responsible for differential medial and lateral femoral rollback. Contemporary ACL retaining total knee arthroplasty (TKA) improves knee function over ACL sacrificing (CR) TKA; however, these implants do not restore the asymmetric tibial articular geometry. This may explain why ACL retention addresses paradoxical anterior sliding seen in CR TKA, but does not fully restore medial pivot motion. To address this, an ACL retaining biomimetic implant, was designed by moving the femoral component through healthy in vivo kinematics obtained from bi-planar fluoroscopy and sequentially removing material from a tibial template. We hypothesized that the biomimetic articular surface together with ACL preservation would better restore activity dependent kinematics of normal knees, than ACL retention alone. Kinematic performance of the biomimetic BCR design (asymmetric tibia with convex lateral surface), a contemporary BCR implant (symmetric shallow dished tibia) and a contemporary CR implant (symmetric dished tibia) was analyzed using KneeSIM software. Chair-sit, deep knee bend, and walking were analyzed. Components were mounted on an average bone model created from magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) data of 40 normal knees. Soft-tissue insertions were defined on the average knee model based on MRI data, and mechanical properties were obtained from literature. Femoral condyle center motions relative to the tibia were tracked to compare different implant designs.INTRODUCTION
METHODS
Dual Mobility (DM) implants have gained popularity for the treatment and prevention of hip dislocation, with increased stability provided by a large diameter mobile liner. However, distal regions of the liner can impinge on soft-tissues like hip capsule and iliopsoas, leading to anterior hip pain. Additionally, soft-tissue impingement may trap the mobile liner, leading to excessive loading of the liner rim, from engagement with the femoral stem, and subsequent intra-prosthetic dislocation. The hypothesis of this study was that reducing the liner profile below the equator (contoured design) can mitigate soft-tissue impingement without compromising inner-head pull-out resistance and overall hip joint stability ( The interaction of conventional and contoured liners with anterior soft-tissues was evaluated in 10 cadaveric hips (5 specimens; 2 male, 3 female; age 65 ± 10 yrs; liner diameter 42–48mm) via visual observation and fluoroscopic imaging. A metal wire was sutured to the deep fibers of the iliopsoas tendon/muscle, and metal wires were embedded in the mobile liners for fluoroscopic visualization Resistance to inner-head pull-out was evaluated via Finite Element Analysis (FEA) by simulating a full cycle of insertion of the inner head into the mobile liner and subsequent pullout. The femoral head, acetabular shell, and stem were modeled as rigid, while the mobile liner was modeled as plastically deformable. Hip joint stability was evaluated by dynamic simulations in for two dislocation modes: (A) Posterior dislocation (at 90° hip flexion) with internal hip rotation; (B) Posterior dislocation (starting at 90° flexion) with combined hip flexion and adduction. A 44 mm diameter conventional and a 44 mm contoured liner were evaluated during these tests.Introduction
Methods
Dual-mobility (DM) liners have increased popularity due to the range of motion and stability provided by these implants. However, larger head diameters have been associated with anterior hip pain, due to surrounding soft-tissue impingement, particularly the iliopsoas. To address this, an anatomically contoured dual mobility (ACDM) liner was designed by reducing the volume of the liner below the equator (Fig1). Previous cadaver studies have shown that the ACDM significantly reduces iliopsoas tenting and trapping of the liner compared to conventional designs. We created a finite element study based on previous cadaver testing to further analyze the effectiveness of the ACDM design in reducing soft-tissue impingement, specifically the tendon-liner contact pressure and the tendon stress. The finite element model was developed within COMSOL 4.3b. The psoas tendon was modelled as a Yeoh hyper-elastic Material, which uses 3 constants (c1-c3), density (1.73g/cm3) and a bulk modulus (26GPa)[Hirokawa,2000]. In a previous, separate study, the average stiffness of 10 psoas tendon samples (5 cadavers), were measured to be 339[N/mm] in the linear region with average width and thickness of 14mmX4mm. The 3 constants were tuned to match experimental uniaxial test data, and were 5[GPa], 0[Gpa], and 46[GPa] for c1, c2, and c3 respectively. The implant components were rigidly modeled relative to the psoas. Cadaver specific CT models were used to create the FEA geometry. The insertion points for the Psoas were digitally determined on the proximal end of the lesser trochanter, and the psoas notch on the pelvis for hip flexion angles of −15°, 0°, 15° and 30°. These insertion points determined the length of the psoas and its relative position to the femoral head in 3D. The specific liner size and position for each cadaver was determined by implant planning with the CT models. In this abstract, we only present data for 2 specimens (left/right hips) with 44mm conventional DM, and 44mm ACDM, matching specimen anatomy. A 500N tensile load was applied to the psoas tendon proximally to simulate moderate physiological loading, the average/max stresses and contact pressures between the psoas and the two liner designs were determined.Introduction
Methods
The large diameter mobile polyethylene liner of the dual mobility implant provides increased resistance to hip dislocation. However, a problem specific to the dual mobility system is intra-prosthetic dislocation (IPD), secondary to loss of the retentive rim, causing the inner head to dissociate from the polyethylene liner. We hypothesized that impingement of the polyethylene liner with the surrounding soft-tissue inhibits liner motion, thereby facilitating load transfer from the femoral neck to the liner and leading to loss of retentive rim over time. This mechanism of soft-tissue impingement with the liner was evaluated via cadaver experiments, and retrievals were used to assess polyethylene rim damage. Total hip arthroplasty was performed on 10 cadaver hips using 3D printed dual mobility components. A metal wire was sutured to the posterior surface (underside) of the iliopsoas, and metal wires were embedded into grooves on the outer surface of the liner and inner head to identify these structures under fluoroscopy. Tension was applied to the iliopsoas to move the femur from maximum hyperextension to 90° of flexion for the purpose of visualizing the iliopsoas and capsule interaction with the mobile liner. The interaction of the mobile liner with the iliopsoas was studied using fluoroscopy and direct visual observation. Fifteen retrieved dual mobility liners were assessed for rim edge and rim chamfer damage. Rim edge damage was defined as any evidence of contact, and rim chamfer damage was classified into six categories: impact ribs on the chamfer surface, loss of machining marks, scratching or pitting, rim deformation causing a raised lip, a rounded rim edge, or embedded metal debris.Introduction
Methods
In native knees the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) plays a major role in joint stability and kinematics. Sacrificing the ACL in contemporary total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is known to cause abnormal knee motion, and reduced function. Hence, there is growing interest in the development of ACL retaining TKA implants. Accommodation of ACL insertion around the tibial eminence is a challenge with these designs. Therefore, a reproducible and practical test setup is necessary to characterize the strength of the ACL/bone construct in ACL retaining implants. Seminal work showed importance of loading the ACL along its anatomical orientation. However, prior setups designed for this purpose are complex and difficult to incorporate into a standardized test for wide adoption. The goal of this study was to develop a standardized and anatomically relevant test setup for repeatable strength assessment of ACL construct using basic force-displacement testing equipment. Cadaver knees were positioned with the ACL oriented along the loading axis and being the only connection between femur and tibia. 15° knee flexion was selected based on highest ACL tensions reported in literature. Therefore, the fixtures were adjusted accordingly to retain 15° knee flexion when the ACL was tensioned. The test protocol included 10 cycles of preconditioning between 6N and 60N at 1mm/s, followed by continuous distraction at 1mm/s until failure (INTRODUCTION
METHODS
Mechanical tissue properties of some ligaments and tendons have been described in the literature. However, to our knowledge no data exists describing the tensile properties of the Iliopsoas tendon. The iliopsoas complex is in very close proximity to the hip joint running through the psoas notch from the inner side of the pelvis to the lesser trochanter on the posterior aspect of the proximal femur. The tendon muscle complex wraps around the anterior aspect of the femoral head. Hip joint intervention such as total hip arthroplasty (THA) can interfere with iliopsoas function and contact mechanics, and thereby play a major role in the clinically known condition of anterior hip pain. For computer simulations such as finite element analysis (FEA) precise knowledge of soft-tissue mechanical properties is crucial for accurate models and therefore, the goal of this study was to describe the iliopsoas tensile properties using uniaxial testing equipment. Ten iliopsoas tendons were harvested from five specimens (2 male, 3 female; 82.4 yrs ±7.4 yrs) and then carefully cleaned from any fat and muscle tissue. Two freeze clamps were fixed to each end of the tendon sample. The clamps were submerged in liquid nitrogen for 30 seconds to prevent tendon slip and attached to the test frame and load cell via carabiners allowing the tendon to rotate around its long axis. Width, thickness and initial gauge length of each tendon were measured before testing. The test protocol included 10 cycles of preconditioning between 6 N and 60 N at 0.4 mm/s, followed by continuous distraction at 0.4 mm/s until failure. For each tendon the linear stiffness was determined by fitting a straight line to the liner region on the force-displacement curve (INTRODUCTION
METHODS
Dual Mobility (DM) implants have gained popularity for the treatment and prevention of hip dislocation, with increased stability provided by a large diameter mobile insert. However, distal regions of the insert may impinge on soft tissues like the iliopsoas, leading to groin pain. Additionally, soft-tissue impingement may trap the mobile insert, leading to excessive loading of the insert rim from engagement with the femoral neck and subsequent intra-prosthetic dislocation. To address this, an Anatomically Contoured Dual Mobility (ACDM) insert with a soft-tissue friendly distal geometry was developed Fluoroscopic imaging was used to evaluate soft-tissue interaction with ACDM and conventional DM inserts in four cadaver hips (Introduction
Methods
In Cruciate Retaining (CR) Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA), the Posterior Cruciate Ligament (PCL) is preserved but the Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) is sacrificed. In contemporary CR implants, failure to substitute for ACL function causes abnormal knee motion, with the femur being located excessively posterior on the tibia in full extension ( The kinematics of an ACL-preserving implant, the ASCR implant, and a contemporary CR implant during deep knee bend was simulated using LifeMOD KneeSIM software (Introduction
Methods
Contemporary PCL sacrificing Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) implants (CS) consist of symmetric medial and lateral tibial articular surfaces with high anterior lips designed to substitute for the stability of the native PCL. However, designs vary significantly across implant systems in the level of anteroposterior constraint provided. Therefore, the goal of this study was to investigate kinematics of two CS designs with substantially different constraint levels. The hypothesis was that dynamic knee simulations could show the effect of implant constraint on kinematics of CS implants. LifeModeler KneeSIM software was used to analyze contemporary CS TKA (X) with a symmetric and highly dished tibia and contemporary CS TKA (Y) with a symmetric tibia having flat sections bounded by high anterior and posterior lips, during simulated deep knee bend and chair sit. The flat sections of CS-Y implant are designed to allow freedom prior to motion restriction by the implant lips. Components were mounted on an average knee model created from Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) data of 40 normal knees. Relevant ligament/tendon insertions were obtained from the MRI based 3D models and tissue properties were based on literature values. The condyle center motions relative to the tibia were used to compare the different implant designs. In vivo knee kinematics of healthy subjects from published literature was used for reference.INTRODUCTION
METHODS
Femoral head diameter has a major influence on stability and dislocation resistance of the hip joint after Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA). Dual Mobility (DM) implants can also reduce the risk of dislocation due the large diameter mobile liner which forms the femoroacetbular articulation. However, recent studies have shown that large head prostheses can directly impinge against native soft tissues, particularly the iliopsoas, leading to anterior hip pain. Dual mobility systems have emerged as a revision option in the treatment of failed metal on metal devices because of the high incidence of post revision instability secondary to abductor loss and need for capsulectomy. We hypothesized that an Anatomically Contoured Dual Mobility (ACDM) liner could provide joint stability while better accommodating the soft tissues surrounding the hip joint. The dislocation resistance of a 44 mm ACDM implant was compared to that of a 44 mm conventional DM liner. Both implants consisted of a 28 mm inner small diameter head and the liner was abducted to be in the worst case position for dislocation (Fig. 1). The ACDM liner was based on a 44 mm sphere with smaller radii used to contour the peripheral region below the equator of the liner. MSC Adams was used for dynamic simulations based on two previously described dislocation modes: (A) Posterior dislocation (at 90° hip flexion) with internal rotation of the hip and a posterosuperior directed joint force; (B) Posterior dislocation (starting at 90° flexion) with combined hip flexion and adduction and a posteromedial force direction (Fig. 2). Impingement-free motion (motion without neck impingement against the acetabular cup) and jump distance (head separation from acetabulum at dislocation) were measured for each implant. The acetabular cup was placed at 42.5° abduction and 19.7° anteversion, while the femoral component was anteverted by 9.75° based on published data.INTRODUCTION
METHODS
While kinematic abnormalities of contemporary TKA implants have been well established, a solution has not yet been achieved. We hypothesized that contemporary TKA implants are not compatible with normal soft-tissue function and normal knee motion. We propose a novel technique for reverse engineering advanced implant articular surfaces (biomimetic surface), by using accurate 3D kinematics of normal knees. This technique accounts for surgical placement of the implants, and allows design of tibial and femoral articular surfaces in conjunction. Magnetic resonance imaging was used to create 3D knee models of 40 normal subjects (24 male, 16 female, age 29.9 ± 9.7 years), and bi-planar fluoroscopy was used to capture 3D knee motion during a deep knee bend. These data were combined to create a 3D virtual representation of an average normal knee and its motion pathway. A TKA femoral component was mounted on the average knee, and moved through its normal kinematic pathway to carve out an articular surface from a tibial template (Fig. 1 and 2). The geometry of the resulting biomimetic tibia was compared to that of the native tibia, and a contemporary TKA tibial insert that uses the same femoral component.Introduction:
Methods:
Large diameter femoral heads have been used successfully to prevent dislocation after Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA). However, recent studies show that the peripheral region of contemporary femoral heads can directly impinge against the native soft-tissues, particularly the iliopsoas, leading to activity limiting anterior hip pain. This is because the spherical articular surface of contemporary prosthesis overhangs beyond that of the native anatomy (Fig. 1). The goal of this research was to develop an anatomically shaped, soft-tissue friendly large diameter femoral head that retains the benefits of contemporary implants. Various Anatomically Contoured femoral Head (ACH) designs were constructed, wherein the articular surface extending from the pole to a theta (θ) angle, matched that of contemporary implants (Fig. 2). However, the articular surface in the peripheral region was moved inward towards the femoral head center, thereby reducing material that could impinge on the soft-tissues (Fig. 1 and Fig. 2). Finite element analysis was used to determine the femoroacetabular contact area under peak in vivo loads during different activities. Dynamic simulations were used to determine jump distance prior to posterior dislocation under different dislocation modes. Published data was used to compare the implant articular geometry to native anatomy (Fig. 3). These analyses were used to optimize the soft-tissue relief, while retaining the load bearing contact area, and the dislocation resistance of conventional implants.Introduction:
Methods:
Dual Mobility (DM) hip implants have gained popularity for the treatment and preventions of instability. In DM implants a large diameter mobile insert matches the native femoral head size. However, studies have shown that the peripheral regions of such large diameter implants overhang beyond the native anatomy and can directly impinge against nearby soft tissues, especially the iliopsoas, leading to groin pain (Fig. 1). Soft-tissue impingement can also trap the mobile DM insert, leading to damage of its peripheral rim, which secures the small diameter inner head (Fig. 2). The goal of this research was to develop an anatomically contoured soft-tissue friendly DM insert. Various Anatomically Contoured Dual Mobility (ACDM) insert designs were constructed, wherein the outer articular surface extending from the pole to a theta (θ) angle, matched that of contemporary implants (Fig. 3). However, the articular surface in the peripheral region was moved inward towards the center, thereby reducing implant volume that could impinge on the soft tissue (Fig. 1 and Fig. 3). Finite element analyses were used to determine the insert-acetabular contact area under peak in vivo loads during different activities. Finite element analysis was also used to determine resistance to extraction of the inner head. Published data was used to compare the implant articular geometry to native anatomy. These analyses were used optimize the soft-tissue relief, while matching the load bearing contact area and the resistance to extraction of the inner head in contemporary implants.Introduction:
Methods:
Large diameter femoral heads provide increased range-of-motion and reduced dislocation rates compared to smaller diameter femoral heads. However, several recent studies have reported that contemporary large head prostheses can directly impinge against the local soft tissues leading to anterior hip pain. To address this we developed a novel Anatomically Contoured large diameter femoral Head (ACH) that maintains the profile of a large diameter femoral head over a hemispherical portion and then contours inward the distal profile of the head for soft-tissue relief. We hypothesized that the distal contouring of the ACH articular surface would not affect contact area. The impact of component placement, femoral head to acetabular liner radial clearance, and joint loading during different activities was investigated. A finite element model was used to assess the femoroacetabular contact area of a 36 mm diameter conventional head and a 36 mm ACH (Fig. 1). It included a rigid acetabular shell, plastically deformable UHMWPE acetabular liner, rigid femoral head and rigid femoral stem. The femoral stem was placed at 0°, 10° and 20° of anteversion. The acetabular shell and liner were placed in 20°, 40° and 60° of abduction and 0°, 20° and 40° of anteversion. The femoral head to acetabular liner radial clearances modeled were 0.06 mm, 0.13 mm and 0.5 mm. Three loading cases corresponding to peak in vivo loads during walking, chair sit and deep-knee bend were analyzed (Fig. 2). This allowed a range of component positions and maximum joint loads to be studied.Introduction
Methods
Dual mobility (DM) implants provide increased stability and range-of-motion through the use of a large diameter mobile liner articulating against an acetabular shell. However, recent studies have reported that such contemporary large head prostheses can directly impinge against the local soft tissues leading to anterior hip pain. To address this drawback, a novel Anatomically Contoured Dual Mobility (ACDM) liner was developed that maintains the outer spherical geometry over an approximately hemispherical portion and then contours inward the distal profile of the DM liner for soft-tissue relief. The extent of the inner profile encapsulating the small diameter head is increased to provide more coverage of the head and maintain the inner head pullout force. We hypothesized that the ACDM liner for soft-tissue relief would not affect retention of the small diameter inner head or liner-acetabular load-bearing contact area. A finite element model to evaluate head retention and contact mechanics was created with a rigid acetabular shell, a plastically deformable UHMWPE DM liner, a rigid femoral head and a rigid femoral stem. For the head retention analysis, the extent of head coverage (Fig. 1) was optimized to match the inner head pullout force of a conventional DM liner. Contact mechanics of a conventional DM and ACDM liner were analyzed at the maximum joint load of three activities: gait, deep-knee bend and chair sit. One set of simulations was completed with the mobile liner and head axes aligned and another with the axes mal-aligned so that the mobile liner rim was adjacent to the femoral stem neck and the potential area of contact was away from the mobile liner apex. This allowed a broader range of potential contact to be assessed including what was determined to be a worst-case alignment.Introduction
Methods
Contemporary Posterior Cruciate Ligament (PCL) retaining TKA implants (CR) are associated with well-known kinematic deficits, such as absence of medial pivot motion, paradoxical anterior femoral sliding, and posterior femoral subluxation at full extension. The hypothesis of this study was that a biomimetic implant, reverse engineered by using healthy knee kinematics to carve the tibial articular surface, could restore normal kinematic patterns of the knee. Kinematics of the biomimetic CR and two contemporary CR implants (A, B) were evaluated during simulated deep knee bend and chair-sit in LifeModeler KneeSIM™ software. Anteroposterior motion of the medial and lateral femoral condyle centers was measured relative to a tibial origin. The implants were mounted on an average knee model created from magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of 40 healthy knees. The medial and lateral collateral ligaments, posterior cruciate ligament, quadriceps mechanism, and the overall capsular tension were modeled. The soft-tissue insertions were obtained from the average knee model, and the mechanical properties were obtained from literature. In vivo knee kinematics of healthy subjects from published literature was used for reference.Introduction:
Methods:
ACL retaining (BCR) Total Knee Arthroplasty (TKA) provides more normal kinematics than ACL sacrificing (CR) TKA. However, in the native knee the ACL and the asymmetric shape of the tibial articular surface with a convex lateral plateau are responsible for the differential medial/lateral femoral rollback (medial pivot). Therefore, the hypothesis of this study was that an asymmetric biomimetic articular surface together with ACL preservation would better restore native knee kinematics than retention of the ACL alone. Normal knee kinematics from bi-planar fluoroscopy was used to reverse engineer the tibial articular surface of the biomimetic implant. This was achieved by moving the femoral component through the healthy knee kinematics and removing material from a tibial template. LifeModeler KneeSIM software was used to analyze a biomimetic BCR implant (asymmetric tibia with convex lateral surface), a contemporary BCR (symmetric shallow dished tibia) and a contemporary CR (symmetric dished tibia) implant during simulated deep knee bend and chair sit. Components were mounted on an average bone model created from Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) data of 40 normal knees. The soft-tissue insertions were obtained from the average knee model and the mechanical properties were obtained from literature. Femoral condyle center motions relative to the tibia were used to compare different implant designs. In vivo knee kinematics of healthy subjects from published literature was used for reference.INTRODUCTION
METHODS
