1. The progressive radiographic changes in twenty-five patients suffering from Perthes' disease of the hip are described. 2. The prognostic value of lateral views of the hip is emphasised, and the present concepts of pathogenesis in the light of recent observations are discussed

We compared the prognostic value of the Catterall grouping, the Salter-Thompson grading, the arthrographic shape of the femoral head, and the Herring lateral pillar grouping during the fragmentation stage of Perthes’ disease in 73 patients with 81 affected hips. Radiographs were available for study from the onset of the disease until skeletal maturity. We used the Stulberg classification to assess outcome. The Herring grade and arthrographic sphericity proved to be the best predictors of final outcome. Combining these two values further increased the predictive value. All but one patient in Herring group A achieved an excellent outcome. In Herring group B, the age of the child and the sphericity of the femoral head influenced the end result. If the child was less than seven years old at the onset of symptoms the prognosis was invariably good and all spherical hips in group B had a good outcome with Stulberg grades 1 or 2. Moderately and severely deformed hips on arthrography resulted in Stulberg 3 and 4 hips. None of the hips in Herring group C had a normal appearance at maturity and the outcome was not significantly influenced by the age at onset or the arthrographic appearance

Forty-eight images using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in 16 hips with Perthes' disease were evaluated over a mean period of two years. MRI depicted exactly the infarcted zone in the femoral head before typical radiological changes were evident. Early determination of the extent of the infarcted bone on MRI benefits those patients who require treatment. Follow-up MRI scans at six-monthly intervals, reflected the chronological stages of the repair process in each group classified according to Catterall

There are differences of opinion about the pathogenesis of Perthes' disease. All are agreed that it is due to ischaemia, but the cause of this and the size and number of infarctions are in dispute. Through the generosity of the contributors six whole femoral heads and core biopsies of five other cases have been studied radiographically and histologically. The findings ranged from an ischaemic arrest of ossification in the capital articular cartilage without infarction to multiple complete infarctions of the epiphysial bone. The ensuing reparative process contributes to the pathology, which is of a range to warrant grading or grouping

1. Eighty-nine cases of Perthes' disease are reviewed. 2. The prognosis varies with the amount of the epiphysis involved. 3. It is possible to assess the amount of epiphysial involvement by a study of the early radiographs. Cases were allocated to four groups on this basis. 4. It is confirmed that both sex and age at the time of diagnosis influence the final prognosis. The reasons for this are discussed. 5. The concept of "the head at risk" is suggested and radiological signs described to diagnose such cases. 6. It is hoped that the classification suggested may in future act as a basis for comparisons of treatment

In a prospective five-year study, 294 episodes of acute transient synovitis of the hip were diagnosed in 275 children. The average annual incidence was 0.2% and the accumulated risk of suffering at least one episode was 3%. The risk of recurrence was 20 times greater than the risk of having a single episode. Perthes' disease was diagnosed from one to five months after the acute attack of synovitis in 10 cases (3.4%). Review of the initial radiographs revealed signs of avascular necrosis in three of the 10 cases, and an increased joint space in five. Only two cases had had completely normal radiographs. The value of routine radiographs taken after three months was minimal. Factors associated with the incidence of Perthes' disease included prolonged time in traction before the range of hip movement became normal, increase in joint space on the initial radiographs and the recurrence of hip symptoms after initial relief

In 40 children with unilateral Perthes' disease, we measured the physeal slope, the angle between the physeal plane and the axis of the femoral shaft, from radiographs taken early in the disease. Thirty-seven of the 40 hips were classified as Catterall grades III and IV. Heat-at-risk signs were present in 23. We found no statistically significant difference in the physeal slope between the involved and normal hips (p = 0.20), those with or without head-at-risk signs (p = 0.96), those with or without lateral epiphyseal subluxation (p = 0.82), and different Catterall (p = 0.56) or lateral pillar (p = 0.67) gradings

Seventy children who had suffered from Perthes' disease were reviewed clinically and radiologically three to eight years from the onset of the condition in order to determine retrospectively the most satisfactory method of assessing the prognosis and the correlation between the clinical and radiological result. In younger children the femoral head was more likely to be spherical at the conclusion of the pathological process but not necessarily of normal proportions nor normally covered by the acetabulum. The prognosis was significantly poorer for girls than for boys. Clinical factors were not an aid to prognosis in the individual cases, but overall there was a close correlation between the clinical and the radiological end-results. The most reliable radiological factors indicating the prognosis were the extent of uncovering of the femoral head, the Catterall grouping, the presence of calcification lateral to the outer limit of the acetabulum and lateral displacement of the femoral head, as measured by comparing the head to tear-drop distances on each side

Premature epiphysial closure is an infrequent complication of Perthes' disease. Twenty-two patients with this condition are reviewed, three of whom were bilaterally affected. The aetiology, radiographic features and effect on function are discussed. The incidence of this complication can be reduced by an awareness of the clinical and radiographic signs which contra-indicate treatment by upper fermoral osteotomy

The pathogenesis of Perthes' disease has been related to increased intra-articular pressure secondary to a joint effusion. The pressure within the hip in different positions was measured in eight children with transient synovitis and four with the synovial stage of Perthes' disease. In the position of comfort for the hip this pressure was always less than the arteriolar blood pressure and in a supine position it did not exceed the systolic blood pressure. However, in extension with medial rotation the intra-articular pressure always became several times the systolic blood pressure. This high pressure was also recorded in the stable lateral position which occurs normally during sleep. It is concluded that in the presence of a synovial effusion in the hip, a position of extension and medial rotation causes an increase in intra-articular pressure which may compromise the blood supply to the capital epiphysis of the femur

1. A rationale of subtrochanteric osteotomy with derotation and varus angulation in the treatment of Perthes' disease is suggested. 2. Three months after operation the child returns to a normal unrestricted life. 3. The anatomical results in twelve such operations with an average follow-up of two years and five months are presented. In five children the results were "very good," in four "good," in one "fair" and in one "bad.". 4. These results seem to compare favourably with those observed after conservative treatment of two, three or more years duration

Fifteen independent observers of three levels of experience (consultant staff, fellows, residents) assessed 40 radiographs of children presenting with Perthes' disease using the Catterall and the Salter-Thompson grading systems. Each observer was supplied with descriptions and illustrations of the classifications and each hip was grouped by both systems by each observer. The results were statistically analysed using 'kappa' statistics. The level of interobserver agreement was higher for the Salter-Thompson system and correlated with the level of experience of the observer. Both systems can give acceptable levels of interobserver agreement, but the Salter-Thompson grouping is simpler and easier to apply in the earlier stages of the disease when treatment must be decided, and has a higher degree of reproducibility amongst more experienced observers

The surgical treatment of Perthes’ disease by femoral or innominate osteotomy is not as effective in those over the age of eight years as it is in the younger child. This has prompted the search for other types of management in those who are older. The preliminary results of the use of a lateral shelf acetabuloplasty for such cases have shown encouraging results at two years. The concern with such an operation is that it might interfere with the growth of the outer aspect of the acetabulum and so prejudice the long-term outcome. We describe a review at maturity of 26 children presenting with early disease after the age of eight years who were treated by lateral shelf acetabuloplasty. The results suggest that the outcome is improved; 22 of 27 hips were rated as Stulberg groups 1 to 3. Poor results occurred in children, particularly girls, presenting with Group-4 disease over the age of 11 years

Upper femoral osteotomy is a recognised treatment for selected patients with Perthes' disease. The results of this procedure were investigated at skeletal maturity in 44 patients (48 hips). The indication for operation was Catterall group II, III, and IV hips with 'head-at-risk' signs. Harris and Iowa scores were calculated clinically, and each hip was assigned radiographically to one of the five Stulberg classes, its initial Catterall grading checked and other relevant indices measured. Results showed excellent clinical function. Shortening was present in 14 hips (29%) and a positive Trendelenburg's sign was seen in 12 (25%). On radiographic assessment 58% of hips were Stulberg class I or II, with a good prognosis. The results of femoral osteotomy were better than those for conservatively treated hips in all age groups except those under five years

A new method of recording the three-dimensional anatomy of the proximal femur from a single anteroposterior radiograph is described. This technique shows that in Perthes' disease the femoral head and neck are in significant anteversion and true varus. This anatomical configuration may be important in the pathogenesis and treatment of this disorder

The results of treating 148 hips in 135 children (aged 7 to 16 at the onset of management) for Perthes' disease are analysed. Cases are classified according to the amount of epiphysial containment and the results assessed according to the degree of preserved sphericity. It is concluded that to obtain satisfactory results in this age group treatment should be prolonged until the restitution of the epiphysis so as to maintain the initially achieved containment throughout the reparative process. Containment should be secured initially as follows: by non-operative treatment, in children aged seven to nine years with contained and also with slightly subluxated epiphyses; by femoral osteotomy, in children aged seven to nine years with severely subluxated epiphyses and also in children aged 10 and more with slightly subluxated epiphyses; by Salter's osteotomy, in children aged 10 years and more with contained epiphyses; by Chiari's osteotomy, in all crushed but smooth epiphyses, and also in children aged 10 and more with severely subluxated epiphyses; and by cheilectomy, in all crushed and saddle-shaped epiphyses, but only during the regenerative stage of the disease

A study was undertaken to assess the degree of inter-observer error when a panel of observers classified the radiographs of patients with early Perthes' disease, using Catterall grouping and "at risk" signs. The anteroposterior and lateral radiographs, taken within three months of diagnosis of Perthes' disease, were available for 69 hips and were shown in turn to 10 observers. The radiological end-results were assessed at least four years from diagnosis. The results showed a poor ability of the observers to delineate Groups 1, 2 and 3, with a more satisfactory performance in Group 4 and when Groups 2 and 3 were combined. Interpretation of "at risk" signs was unsatisfactory except when there was an increase in medial joint space greater than two millimetres. The end-results correlated well with early Catterall grouping and "at risk" signs when these were correctly interpreted

The reliability of the Catterall grouping of Perthes' disease was examined by determining the agreement between pairs of observers using weighted kappa statistics. Anteroposterior and lateral radiographs of 100 hip joints were grouped independently by four experienced observers. There was a low, and in our opinion, unacceptable degree of inter-observer agreement even when Groups 2 and 3 were combined

A prospective survey was carried out on all cases of irritable hip presenting at the Royal Liverpool Children's Hospital over a period of one year. All children had a radioisotope scan of the hips and were then followed for one year by serial radiography. Five of the 50 children seen during the one year had areas of ischaemia in the capital femoral epiphysis demonstrated on the scan. all five developed radiological signs of Perthes' disease within sic months. The remaining 45 had radiographically normal hips at one year

Throughout 1976 orthopaedic surgeons in three regions of England forwarded details of all new patients with Perthes' disease attending outpatient clinics or admitted as inpatients. The incidence in the Mersey region (11.1 per 100 000 children under fifteen years) was twice that in Wessex (5.5) with Trent having an intermediate incidence (7.6). The ratio of male to female incidence varied between the regions as did the age distribution of male cases. These findings point to the importance of environmental factors in the aetiology of the disease, and suggest the need for further epidemiological studies