Advertisement for orthosearch.org.uk
Orthopaedic Proceedings Logo

Receive monthly Table of Contents alerts from Orthopaedic Proceedings

Comprehensive article alerts can be set up and managed through your account settings

View my account settings

Visit Orthopaedic Proceedings at:

Loading...

Loading...

Volume 95-B, Issue SUPP_5 February 2013 Scottish Committee for Orthopaedics and Trauma (SCOT)

Trauma
Full Access
A.D. Duckworth S.E. Mitchell S.G. Molyneux T.O. White C.M. Court-Brown M.M. McQueen

The aim of this study was to document our experience of acute forearm compartment syndrome, and to determine the risk factors for requiring split skin grafting (SSG) and developing complications post fasciotomy. We identified from our trauma database all patients who underwent fasciotomy for an acute forearm compartment syndrome over a 22-year period. Diagnosis was made using clinical signs and/or compartment pressure monitoring. Demographic data, aetiology, management, wound closure, complications and subsequent surgeries were recorded. Outcome measures were the use of SSG and the development of complications following forearm fasciotomy.

90 patients were identified with a mean age of 33 yrs (range, 13–81 yrs) and a significant male predominance (n=82, p<0.001). A fracture of one or both of the forearm bones was seen in 62 (69%) patients, with soft tissue injuries causative in 28 (31%). The median time to fasciotomy was 12hrs (2–72). Delayed wound closure was achieved in 38 (42%) patients, with 52 (58%) undergoing SSG. Risk factors for requiring a SSG were younger age and a crush injury (both p<0.05). Complications occurred in 29 (32%) patients at mean follow-up of 11 (3–60) months. Risk factors for developing complications were a delay in fasciotomy of >6 hrs (p=0.018), with pre-operative motor symptoms approaching significance (p=0.068).

Forearm compartment syndrome requiring fasciotomy predominantly affects males and can occur following either a fracture or soft tissue injury. Age is an important predictor of undergoing SSG for wound closure. Complications occur in a third of patients and are associated with an increasing delay in the time to fasciotomy.


C. Munro H.S. Gillespie P. Bourke D. Lawrie

ARI is a busy trauma unit (catchment: 500 000 people). In September 2010 a day-case Hand Trauma Service (HTS) started. Previously cases were often postponed due to prioritisation of orthopaedic emergencies; therefore increasing inpatient stay and associated costs. We aim to characterise presenting cases, evaluate improvements in service provision and financial costs.

Data was collected from the first HTS year (Sept 10–11), and the preceding year (Sept 09–10). Data was collected on patient characteristics, operation, operative time, anaesthetic type and number of inpatient days. The cost of inpatient stay was calculated from the NHS Scotland resource allocation committee data.

Pre HTS there were 410 cases (500 operative hours). 141 wound explorations, 22 nail-bed repairs, 34 metacarpal ORIF, 68 phalangeal ORIF, 5 scaphoid fixations, 69 tendon repairs, 30 terminalisations, 5 MUA, 19 nerve repairs, 17 unclassified. Accounting for 510 inpatient nights (mean: 1.25, range: 0–8), costing £204,387.60 (mean: £500.95). 123 cases required image intensification (II). Most patients had GA. During the first HTS year there were 282 operations. Most operations were day-case. 77 cases were performed under LA, 81 regional blocks and 34 under GA. During this year cases requiring II continued to be performed in the main theatre.

The HTS has increased time available in main theatres. It has reduced inpatient stay costs, potentially saving £141,267.90. Performing more operations under LA/regional block decreases the risks associated with anaesthesia. Provision of II for the HTS would permit more cases to be performed, improving the service provision and further reducing costs.


C. M. Robinson E. B. Goudie I. R. Murray A. Akhtar P. Jenkins E. Read C. Foster A. Brooksbank A. Arthur T. Chesser

This multi-centre single-blind randomised control trial compared outcomes in patients with acute displaced mid-shaft clavicle fractures treated either by primary open reduction and plate fixation (ORPF), or non-operative treatment (NT).

Two-hundred patients were randomised to receive either ORPF or NT. Functional assessment was conducted up to one-year using DASH, SF-12 and Constant scores (CS). Union was evaluated using radiographs and CT.

Rate of non-union was significantly reduced after ORPF (1 following ORPF, 16 following NT, odds ratio=0.07, 95% CI=0.01–0.50, p=0.0006). 7 patients had delayed-union after NT. Group allocation to ORPF was independently predictive of development of non-union. DASH and CS were significantly better in the ORPF group 3-months post-surgery, but not at one-year (mean DASH = 6.2 after NT versus 3.7 after ORPF, p=0.09; mean CS = 86.1 after NT versus 90.7 after ORPF, p=0.05). Group allocation was not predictive of one-year outcome. Non-union was the only factor independently predictive of one-year functional outcome. There were no significant differences in time off work or subjective scores. Five patients underwent revision for complications after ORPF. 10 patients underwent metalwork removal. Treatment cost was significantly greater after ORPF (p=0.001). ORPF reduces rate of non-union compared with NT and is associated with better early functional outcomes. Improved outcomes are not sustained at one-year. Differences in functional outcome appear to be mediated by prevention of non-union from ORPF. ORPF is more expensive and associated with implant-related complications not seen with NT. Our results do not support routine primary ORPF for displaced mid-shaft clavicle fractures.


J.G. Cowie S.G. McKenzie N. Dempster C.M. Robinson

First-time anterior dislocation of the shoulder is associated with the development of recurrent instability. It is recognised that patients with recurrent instability often have osseous defects. Using 3D computerised tomography (3DCT) it is possible to quantify these defects. Whether these defects are present after the primary dislocation or occur progressively from multiple dislocations is unclear. We correlated the presence of Hill-Sachs lesions and anterior glenoid bone loss with evidence of recurrent dislocation and clinical outcomes.

78 patients were followed up for two years. All underwent a 3DCT within a week of injury. Standardised images of the humeral head and glenoid were produced. Using standardised digital techniques bone loss was measured.

39% of the patients developed further instability. Average Hill-Sachs circumferential length = 15.23%. Average Hill-Sachs surface area = 5.53%. The length and surface area of the Hill-Sachs lesions were significantly associated with further instability. (p=0.019 and p=0.003). Average en face glenoid surface area loss=1.30% with no association to instability (p=0.685). There was poor correlation between the size of the glenoid lesion and the size of the Hill-Sachs lesion.

Results showed that age and increasing size of the Hill-Sachs lesions result in a higher rate of instability. Interestingly glenoid bone loss was relatively low and did not predict recurrent instability. The size of the Hill-Sachs lesion does not have a linear relationship with glenoid bone loss. Further work defining the morphology of the Hill-Sachs lesion and its engagement with a glenoid defect is required.


K.E. Bugler C.D. Watson A.R. Hardie P. Appleton M.M. McQueen C.M. Court-Brown T.O. White

Lateral malleolar plating is associated with complication rates of up to 30%. The fibular nail is an alternative fixation technique, requiring a minimal incision and tissue dissection, with the potential to reduce the incidence of complications. We reviewed our results of 105 unstable ankle fractures fixed with the Acumed fibular nail between 2002 and 2010. The mean age was 65 years and 72% of patients had significant systemic medical comorbidities.

A number of different locking screw configurations were assessed over the study period. A proximal blocking screw resulted in satisfactory stability in 93%, single locking screws in 86%, but nailing without locking in only 66%, leading to the development of our current technique. Of the twenty-one patients treated with this technique there have been no significant complications, and only two superficial wound infections. Good fracture reduction was achieved in all of these patients. The mean physical component SF12, Olerud and Molander and Foot and Ankle Outcome scores were 46, 65 and 83 respectively.

The outcomes of unstable ankle fractures managed with the fibular nail are encouraging, with good radiographic and functional outcomes and minimal complications. This technique should be considered in the management of debilitated patients with unstable ankle fractures.


N.C. Sciberras D. Russell J. McMillan

Frail patients with neck of femur fracture often present to Accident & Emergency (A&E) with concomitant medical problems and are frequently fast-tracked to orthopaedic wards to achieve government waiting time targets.

This is a second cycle of audit since 2008 examining the safety of fast-tracking following several critical incidents. Data was collected prospectively between March and June 2011 by the first on-call orthopaedic doctor.

56 patients (12 male), average age 81.2y (50–97) were fast-tracked. 52 were correctly referred as having intra/extracapsular fracture; 4 patients did not have neck of femur fracture, but did have other medical problems. On arrival to the ward, 8 patients demonstrated abnormal symptoms, signs and vital observations requiring immediate review from the receiving physicians. For the 56 patients, a total of 448 mandatory points of protocol (e.g. intravenous access) should have been addressed prior to transfer; 150 were omitted (33.5%). Vital observations of patients fast-tracked after 2100h were worse (MEWS range 0 to 11) when compared with those fast-tracked prior to 2100h (MEWS range 0 to 3).

Fast-tracking is a common practice amongst many district-general and some teaching hospitals in Scotland. These data support concerns from orthopaedic surgeons and highlight the need for more complete management by A&E and, if necessary, referral to receiving medical staff prior to ward transfer. Early medical optimisation of acute and chronic comorbidities common to these patients is the main facilitator of early surgery. The evidence base demonstrates early surgery is a major variable in reducing post-operative mortality.


N.D. Clement A. Morrison M. Moran

We report the largest series of periprosthetic fractures in the literature, describing the changing epidemiology and predictors of outcome.

A retrospective search of prospectively compiled trauma and elective electronic databases identified 630 periprosthetic fractures presenting to the study centre between 1995 and 2010. Patient demographics, comorbidities, socioeconomic status, mechanism of injury, fracture type, classification, method of fixation, and outcome were recorded using the patients’ notes. The General Register Office for Scotland was used to obtain the mortality status of the patients.

There were 276 total hip replacements (THR), 123 total knee replacements (TKR), 117 hemiarthroplasty, and 114 “other” implants. The incidence of periprosthetic fractures increased significantly during the study period for all implants: THR (p<0.001), TKR (p<0.001), hemiarthroplasty (p=0.002), and other (p=0.003). The majority of fractures were fixed by open reduction and internal fixation (72%). This failed in 14% of THR, 15% of TKR, 21% of hemiarthroplasties, and 18% of “other” implants. Isolated independent predictors of failure of fixation, after multivariate regression analysis, were increasing age, deprivation, a past medical history of asthma or chronic obstructive airways disease, osteoporosis, and steroid use (p<0.05). Failure of fixation was associated with a significantly increased one year mortality rate (OR 12.5, p=0.003).

Periprosthetic fractures involving THR and TKR are becoming more prevalent. Patient demographics can be used to calculate the risk of failure of fixation, and those with an increased risk may benefit from revision of their implant, and avert the associate morbidity of failure of fixation.


P. J. Jenkins N.D. Clement D.F. Hamilton J.T. Patton H.R. Simpson C.R. Howie

The aim was to perform a cost-utility analysis of total joint replacement in the current environment.

Arthritis is a disabling condition that leads to long-term deterioration in quality of life. Total joint replacement, despite being one of the greatest advances in medicine in the modern era, has come under recent scrutiny. The National Health Service (NHS) has competing demands and resource allocation is challenging in times of economic restraint.

Patients undergoing total hip (n=348) and knee arthroplasty (n=323), from January to July 2010, were entered into a prospective arthroplasty database. A health utility score was derived from the Euroqol (EQ-5D) score preoperatively, and at one year, and was combined with individual life expectancy to derive the Quality-Adujusted-Life-Years (QALYs) gained. Predicted need for revision surgery was Incorporated in the model. The 2011–12 Scottish Tariff was used. Two-way analysis of variance was used to compare QALYs gained between procedures, while controlling for baseline differences.

The number of QALYs gained was higher in THR versus TKR (6.53 vs 4.04 years, p<0.001). The cost per QALY for THR was £1371 (95% CI £1194 to £1614) compared with £2101 (£1762 to £2620) for TKR. Predictors of an increase in QALYs gained were poorer health prior to surgery (p<0.001) and younger age (p<0.001). General health (EQ-5D VAS) showed greater improvement in THR versus TKR (p<0.001).

This study provides up to date cost-effectiveness data for total joint replacement. THR and TKR are both extremely clinically and cost-effective interventions, with costs that compare favourably with other medical interventions (e.g. laparoscopic hernia repair vs open: £55,548 per QALY; CHD primary prevention with statins: £21,000).


S. Gupta M. Maclean J.G. Anderson S.J. MacGregor R.D. Meek M.H. Grant

Infection rates following arthroplasty surgery are between 1–4%, with higher rates in revision surgery. The associated costs of treating infected arthroplasty cases are considerable, with significantly worse functional outcomes reported. New methods of infection prevention are required. HINS-light is a novel blue light inactivation technology which kills bacteria through a photodynamic process. The aim of this study was to investigate the efficacy of HINS-light for the inactivation of bacteria isolated from infected arthoplasty cases.

Specimens from hip and knee arthroplasty infections are routinely collected to identify causative organisms. This study tested a range of these isolates for sensitivity to HINS-light. During testing, bacterial suspensions were exposed to increasing doses of HINS-light of (123mW/cm2 irradiance). Non-light exposed control samples were also set-up. Bacterial samples were then plated onto agar plates and incubated at 37°C for 24 hours before enumeration.

Complete inactivation was achieved for all Gram positive and negative microorganisms More than a 4-log reduction in Staphylococcus epidermidis and Staphylococcus aureus populations were achieved after exposure to HINS-light for doses of 48 and 55 J/cm2, respectively. Current investigations using Escherichia coli and Klebsiella pneumoniae show that gram-negative organisms are also susceptible, though higher doses are required.

This study has demonstrated that HINS-light successfully inactivated all clinical isolates from infected arthroplasty cases. As HINS-light utilises visible-light wavelengths it can be safely used in the presence of patients and staff. This unique feature could lead to possible applications such as use as an infection prevention tool during surgery and post-operative dressing changes.


S.M. Johnson Q. Cox

Digital Mucous Cysts (DMCs) arise from the distal inter-phalangeal joints of the digits. They often rupture spontaneously and nail deformities are common. Although surgical excision is recognised as the most successful treatment, there is no clear consensus as to the most appropriate operative technique.

We performed a retrospective review identifying all patients who underwent excision of a DMC using a local rotation skin flap by the senior author over a ten-year period. Patients were all seen pre-operatively and at a minimum of six months post-operatively. Sixty-nine patients were included in the study and were reviewed at an average of 37.7 months post-operatively. No patients were lost to follow-up. There was only one cyst recurrence (1.4%). Sixty-seven (97.1%) patients were happy with the scar and sixty-three patients (91.3%) said they would have the procedure performed again. Sixty-six patients (95.7%) were content with their post-operative range of movement, which was on average 8.1° less than pre-operative values. Thirty-six patients had a nail deformity pre-operatively and twenty-one reported that the deformity grew out following the procedure. Only one patient (3.0%) developed a new deformity post-operatively. Five patients reported infection post-operatively with four prescribed oral antibiotics, but all resolved following one week of treatment.

This study, which is one of the largest analyses of an operative treatment for DMCs, demonstrates that cyst excision with a local rotation skin flap is a safe and effective technique with a low recurrence rate and a high patient satisfaction.


Z Higgs QA Fogg CS Kumar

Isolated talonavicular arthrodesis is a common procedure particularly for posttraumatic arthritis and rheumatoid arthritis. Two surgical approaches are commonly used: the medial and the dorsal approach. It is recognized that access to the lateral aspect of the talonavicular joint can be limited when using the medial approach and it is our experience that using the dorsal approach addresses this issue.

We performed an anatomical study using cadaver specimens, to compare the amount of articular surface that can be accessed, and therefore prepared for arthodesis, by each surgical approach. Medial and dorsal approaches to the talonavicular joint were performed on each of 11 cadaveric specimens (10 fresh frozen, 1 embalmed). Distraction of the joint was performed as used intraoperatively for preparation of articular surfaces during talonavicular arthrodesis. The accessible area of articular surface was marked for each of the two approaches using a previous reported technique3. Disarticulation was performed and the marked surface area was quantified using an immersion digital microscribe, allowing a three dimensional virtual model of the articular surfaces to be assessed.

The median percentage of accessible total talonavicular articular surface for the medial and dorsal approaches was 71% and 92% respectively. This difference was significant (Wilcoxon Signed Ranks Test, p<0.001).

This study provides quantifiable measurements of the articular surface accessible by the medial and dorsal approaches to the talonavicular joint. These data support for the use of the dorsal approach for talonavicular arthrodesis.