There is a strong association between the presence of a calcar collar on a cementless stem and a reduced risk of revision surgery for periprosthetic fracture of the femur (PFF). A medial calcar collar may act to reduce relative movement between the implant and femur during PFF, through calcar-collar contact (CCC). The aims were:
Estimate the effect of CCC on periprosthetic fracture mechanics. Estimate the effect of initial calcar-collar separation on the likelihood of CCC. Three groups of six composite femurs were implanted with a fully coated collared cementless femoral stem. Neck resection differed between groups (group 1 = no additional resection, group 2 = 3mm additional resection, group 3 = 6mm additional resection). PFF were simulated using a previously published technique. Fracture torque and rotational displacement were measured and torsional stiffness and rotational work prior to fracture were estimated. Results between trials where CCC did and did not occur where compared using Mann-Whitney U tests. Logistic regression estimated the odds (OR) of failing with 95% confidence interval (CI) to achieve CCC for a given initial separation. Where CCC occurred fracture torque was greater (47.33 [41.03 to 50.45] Nm versus 38.26 [33.70 to 43.60] Nm, p= 0.05) and torsional stiffness was greater (151.38 [123.04 to 160.42] rad.Nm−1 versus 96.86 [84.65 to 112.98] rad.Nm−1, p <0.01). CCC was occurred in all cases in group one, 50% in group two and 0% in group three. OR of failure to obtain CCC increased 3.8 fold (95% CI 1.6 to 30.2, p <0.05) for each millimetre of separation. Resistance to fracture and construct stiffness increased when a the collar made contact with the calcar prior to fracture and the chances of contact decrease with increasing initial separation at the time of implantation. Surgeons should aim to achieve a calcar-collar distance of less than 1mm following implantation to ensure CCC and to reduce the risk of fracture
To compare the periprosthetic fracture mechanics between a collared and collarless fully coated cementless femoral stem in a composite femur. Two groups of six composite femurs (‘Osteoporotic femur’, SawBones, WA USA) were implanted with either a collared (collared group) or collarless (collarless group) cementless femoral stem which was otherwise identical by a single experienced surgeon. Periprosthetic fractures of the femur were simulated using a previously published technique. High speed video recording was used to identify fracture mechanism. Fracture torque and angular displacement were measured and rotational work and system stiffness were estimated for each trial. Results were compared between collared and collarless group and the comparison was evaluated against previously published work using fresh frozen femurs and the same protocol.Abstract
Objective
Methods
To estimate the effect of calcar collar contact on periprosthetic fracture mechanics using a collared fully coated cementless femoral stem. Three groups of six composite femurs were implanted with a fully coated collared cementless femoral stem. Neck resection was increased between groups (group 1 = normal, group 2 = 3mm additional, group 3 = 6mm additional), to simulate failure to obtain calcar collar contact. Periprosthetic fractures of the femur were simulated using a previously published technique. Fracture torque and rotational displacement were measured and torsional stiffness and rotational work prior to fracture were estimated. High speed video recording identified if collar to calcar contact (CCC) occurred. Results between trials where calcar contact did and did not occur where compared using Mann-Whitney U tests.Abstract
Objective
Methods
To estimate the effect of calcar collar separation on the likelihood of calcar collar contact during in vitro periprosthetic fracture. Three groups of six composite femurs were implanted with a collared cementless femoral stem. Neck resection was increased between groups (group 1 = normal, group 2 = 3mm additional, group 3 = 6mm additional), to simulate failure to obtain calcar collar contact. Prior to each trial, the distances between anterior (ACC) and posterior (PCC) collar and the calcar were measured. Periprosthetic fractures of the femur were simulated using a previously published technique. High speed video recording identified when collar to calcar contact (CCC) occurred. The ACC and PCC were compared between trials where the CCC was and was not achieved. Regression estimated the odds of failing to achieve CCC for a given ACC or PCC.Abstract
Objective
Methods
The aim of this study was to estimate the 90-day risk of revision for periprosthetic femoral fracture associated with design features of cementless femoral stems, and to investigate the effect of a collar on this risk using a biomechanical A total of 337 647 primary total hip arthroplasties (THAs) from the United Kingdom National Joint Registry (NJR) were included in a multivariable survival and regression analysis to identify the adjusted hazard of revision for periprosthetic fracture following primary THA using a cementless stem. The effect of a collar in cementless THA on this risk was evaluated in an Aims
Materials and Methods
In cementless THA the incidence of intraoperative fracture has been reported to be as high 28% [1]. To mitigate these surgical complications, investigators have explored vibro-acoustic techniques for identifying fracture [2–5]. These methods, however, must be simple, efficient, and robust as well as integrate with workflow and sterility. Early work suggests an energy-based method using inexpensive sensors can detect fracture and appears robust to variability in striking conditions [4–5]. The orthopaedic community is also considering powered impaction as another way to minimize the risk of fracture [6– 8], yet the authors are unaware of attempts to provide sensor feedback perhaps due to challenges from the noise and vibrations generated during powered impaction. Therefore, this study tests the hypothesis that vibration frequency analysis from an accelerometer mounted on a powered impactor coupled to a seated femoral broach can be used to distinguish between intact and fractured bone states. Two femoral Sawbones (Sawbones AB Europe, SKU 1121) were prepared using standard surgical technique up to a size 4 broach (Summit, Depuy Synthes). One sawbone remained intact, while a calcar fracture approximately 40mm in length was introduced into the other sawbone. Broaching was performed with a commercially available pneumatic broaching system (Woodpecker) for approximately 4 secs per test (40 impactions/sec) with hand-held support. Tests were repeated 3 times for fractured and intact groups as well as a ‘control’ condition with the broach handle in mid-air (ie not inserted into the sawbone). Two accelerometers (PCB M353B18) positioned on the femoral condyle and the Woodpecker impactor captured vibration data from bone-broach-impactor system (Fig1). Frequency analysis from impaction strikes were postprocessed (Labview). A spectrogram and area under FFT (AUFFT) [4] were analysed for comparisons between fractured and intact bone groups using a nested ANOVA.Introduction
Methods
In Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA), proper bone preparation technique is fundamental to preventing intraoperative fracture. Anecdotally, surgeons suggest they can avoid fracture by listening for changes in the pitch of a mallet strike during broaching. Consequently, it is not surprising that researchers have explored vibroacoustic methods to prevent [1] and identify bone fractures [2, 3]. For instance, a shift in frequency of the acoustic signals during impaction has been correlated with initial stability [4, 5]. In-spite of these research-based successes, we are unaware of an intraoperative application for THA. We submit that idiosyncratic variability during impaction [6] may overwhelm analytical techniques developed in a controlled laboratory environment. The purpose of this test, therefore, was to evaluate the effect of several strike parameters on the vibro-acoustic response during impaction. Specifically, we hypothesized that the A Sawbones femur (SKU1121, Medium) was prepared and broached using standard surgical technique for the Summit hip system (DePuy Synthes) progressing from size 0 to 4. The size 4 broach was firmly seated and impacted ten times (n=10) for each of the prescribed conditions (Table 1) while securely holding the femur by hand. Vibroacoustic data from an accelerometer attached distally on the femur and a directional microphone located within 1 metre (Figure 1) were acquired at a sampling rate of 40kHz and postprocessed using LabView. Spectrograms were generated for qualitative comparisons, while fast fourier transform (FFT) with normalised amplitudes for each strike facilitated quantitative analysis of the area under the FFT curve (AU-FFT). Strike conditions were monitored to ensure the groups were consistent and distinct (Table 1).Introduction
Methods
